[comp.sys.mac.hypercard] Good books on HyperCard

bskendig@stone.Princeton.EDU (Brian Kendig) (11/08/90)

In article <11162@goofy.Apple.COM> rickf@Apple.COM (Rick Fleischman) writes:
>In article <12015@bsu-cs.bsu.edu> hawkwind@bsu-cs.bsu.edu (Wes Lee Sanford) writes:
>> ...  The best HyperTalk 
>>book I've seen is put out by Addison-Wesley Publishing.  The book is called
>>HyperCard Scripting Language Guide: The HyperTalk Language.
>>...  This book
>>was recommended by Apple's finest HyperCard Guru's.  I have a copy of the
>>book for 1.2.5 and it is a really great book 

>The HyperCard Scripting Language Guide for version 2.0 of HyperCard is NOT
>available through APDA.  We are still only selling the version that covers
>up through HyperCard v.1.2.5.

I've seen this book, and I wasn't terribly impressed.  Sure, it's a
very good reference, but I guess I've been spoiled by the jocular
style of the Bantam books.  If you want a manual written by the
company who made the software, this one's for you; otherwise, try one
of the three below (which were written by the people who wrote
HyperCard).

>The Complete HyperCard 2.0 Handbook, Third Edition by Danny Goodman
>(P/N: T0148LL/B, $29.95)

Well, Danny Goodman didn't exactly write HyperCard, but he worked with
it through its design process.  The Handbook is an excellent guide for
someone who hasn't done much with HyperCard but would like to learn;
this details activities such as painting, using fields, and basic
scripting.

>Cooking with HyperTalk 2.0 by Dan Winkler and Scott Knaster
>(P/N: T0398LL/A, $39.95)

This one, as its preface states, is for people who want to begin
learning serious scripting.  I've looked at it briefly -- it has a
very friendly, winning tone to it that I liked.  (The handler for `on
veggieSoup' was nice -- could someone who has the book email me the
text of that?  It's *cute*.)  It also comes with a disk of stacks to
work with.

>HyperTalk 2.0: The Book by Dan Winkler and Scot Kamins
>(P/N: T0399LL/A, $29.95)

This, in my opinion, is the Bible of it all.  It explains HyperTalk
about as thoroughly as a book can, and has plenty of cross-references
(come to think of it, this book would be useful as a HypperCard
stack...).  It also explains the cases where things don't work as they
should, and tells about all the bugs and differences in versions 1.2.2
and 1.2.5 in case you need to know.  Needless to say, I got myself a
copy.  ;)

The only caveat to getting one of these books is that all three were
written and published before HyperCard 2.0 was finished.  There may be
a few things that have changed between Then and Now (like, is it true
that they released HC2 so late because they realized that the manuals
didn't mention its color capability, and so they had to take the color
out?), so maybe the books are only 99 and 44/100 per cent faithful,
but they're excellent in every other regard.

     << Brian >>

| Brian S. Kendig      \ Macintosh |   Engineering,   | bskendig             |
| Computer Engineering |\ Thought  |  USS Enterprise  | @phoenix.Princeton.EDU
| Princeton University |_\ Police  | -= NCC-1701-D =- | @PUCC.BITNET         |
"It's not that I don't have the work to *do* -- I don't do the work I *have*."

ROBIN@applelink.apple.com (Robin Shank) (11/09/90)

In article <3916@idunno.Princeton.EDU> bskendig@stone.Princeton.EDU (Brian 
Kendig) writes:
      [ some stuff about books deleted }

> >Cooking with HyperTalk 2.0 by Dan Winkler and Scott Knaster
> >(P/N: T0398LL/A, $39.95)
> 
> This one, as its preface states, is for people who want to begin
> learning serious scripting.  I've looked at it briefly -- it has a
> very friendly, winning tone to it that I liked.  (The handler for `on
> veggieSoup' was nice -- could someone who has the book email me the
> text of that?  It's *cute*.)  It also comes with a disk of stacks to
> work with.
> 

Thanks.  : )     I wrote it on a whim for Dan.  I reread it the other 
day and realized it calls _cucumbers_ as a soup ingredient.  Oops.

> >HyperTalk 2.0: The Book by Dan Winkler and Scot Kamins
> >(P/N: T0399LL/A, $29.95)
> 
> The only caveat to getting one of these books is that all three were
> written and published before HyperCard 2.0 was finished.  There may be
> a few things that have changed between Then and Now (like, is it true
> that they released HC2 so late because they realized that the manuals
> didn't mention its color capability, and so they had to take the color
> out?), so maybe the books are only 99 and 44/100 per cent faithful,
> but they're excellent in every other regard.

True.  Any HC 2.0 book that you will find in a bookstore now, went to 
press long before HyperCard did.  The best place to find the final word on 
HyperTalk is the HyperTalk Help stack, shipping with the full HC 
configuration.  This stack was kept up-to-date right until we went final.

Also, Danny has published a stack on compuserve that contains additions 
and corrections to his 2.0 Handbook.

Robin Shank
HyperCard 2.0 Stack Engineer
Apple Computer

_____________________________________________________________________
   < Witty saying. >
< Standard disclaimer. >  
_____________________________________________________________________

jkc@Apple.COM (John Kevin Calhoun) (11/09/90)

In article <3916@idunno.Princeton.EDU> bskendig@stone.Princeton.EDU (Brian 
Kendig) writes:
>
> [discussion of the following books deleted]
>
>>The Complete HyperCard 2.0 Handbook, Third Edition by Danny Goodman
>>(P/N: T0148LL/B, $29.95)
>
>>Cooking with HyperTalk 2.0 by Dan Winkler and Scott Knaster
>>(P/N: T0398LL/A, $39.95)
>
>>HyperTalk 2.0: The Book by Dan Winkler and Scot Kamins
>>(P/N: T0399LL/A, $29.95)
>
>The only caveat to getting one of these books is that all three were
>written and published before HyperCard 2.0 was finished.  There may be
>a few things that have changed between Then and Now

I'm aware of one thing that changed after the book by Winkler and Kamins
went to press.  Their section on the Picture XCMD is almost completely
wrong.  The description of the Picture XCMD in the book by Goodman is
correct, as far as I could tell during my cursory review of it.

Kevin Calhoun
HyperCard Engineer
Apple Computer, Inc.

maddox@blake.u.washington.edu (Tom Maddox) (11/09/90)

In article <11177@goofy.Apple.COM> ROBIN@applelink.apple.com (Robin Shank) writes:

>Also, Danny has published a stack on compuserve that contains additions 
>and corrections to his 2.0 Handbook.

	Can this stack be posted to the binaries newsgroup and/or sumex?

	(I've got the book, would love the stack.)


--
				Tom Maddox
	"Satanic Verses is a despicable book that could not have been
	written by a person who wished to behave decently and responsibly." 
				Orson Scott Card

landman@hanami.Eng.Sun.COM (Howard A. Landman) (11/13/90)

In article <11177@goofy.Apple.COM> ROBIN@applelink.apple.com (Robin Shank) writes:
>Thanks.  : )     I wrote it on a whim for Dan.  I reread it the other 
>day and realized it calls _cucumbers_ as a soup ingredient.  Oops.

Why oops?  Never had gazpacho?

--
	Howard A. Landman
	landman@eng.sun.com -or- sun!landman