[sci.med.aids] HIV-1 ORIGIN

Robert.Lee@asuvax.asu.edu (Robert Lee) (06/22/89)

Brief excerpt from Seale, J. R. "Origin and transmission of AIDS. 
Multi-use hypodermics and the threat to the Soviet Union: discussion 
paper." Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine. May 1987; pp.301- 
304. 
    
"Its [AIDS] ultimate origins appear to be in the practice of modern 
medicine and modern science themselves; whether by chance in the 
practice of cut-price modern medicine in poor countries, or by an 
accident in a laboratory, or by the design of some scientists with 
warped minds. 
     Whatever the precise origins of the AIDS virus may be, it exists, 
and it is spreading rapidly in humans in every country in the world by 
several routes.  It is the greatest MAN-MADE catastrophe of all 
time.  There are no simple solutions to the multitude of horrendous 
problems the virus will cause the human race.  However, in the 
absence of clear thinking, scientific objectivity and honesty, by 
public health authorities as well as by medical scientists and 
clinicians, there will be no solution at all." 
    
I might add Dr. J. R. Seale, formerly Consultant venereologist at 
the Middlesex and St. Thomas' Hospitals, London, has published 
extensively in English and German scientific journals on AIDS.           
Again, ANYONE care to debate the origin of the AIDS virus?? 
I'd sure like to have someone be able to prove to me that Seale's
hypothesis is incorrect.

--  
Uucp: ...{gatech,ames,rutgers}!ncar!noao!asuvax!stjhmc!10!475!Robert.Lee
Internet: Robert.Lee@f475.n10.z1.fidonet.org

mandel@lll-crg.llnl.gov (Tom Mandel) (06/24/89)

[Referring to a posting of part of a paper in which Dr. J. R. Seale
asserts that AIDS is a disease created accidentally or on purpose
by people...]

You ask us to refute Seale's hypothesis.  What, pray tell, is the
nature of his hypothesis?  All you posted was a statement from
a paper in which he asserts that such is the case.  In other words,
could you say more?

--Tom Mandel	mandel@well.sf.ca.us	mandel@unix.sri.com