[sci.med.aids] American Dental Association Policy on HIV-Infected Dentists

ddodell@stjhmc.fidonet.org (David Dodell) (01/26/91)

                      AMERICAN DENTAL ASSOCIATION
                    POLICY ON HIV-INFECTED DENTISTS

            The American Dental Association has adopted the
        following policy in response to the Centers for Disease
       Control January 18 Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report
         on the possible transmission of HIV from an infected
                      dentist to three patients.

The dental profession has  long  adhered  to  a  moral  commitment  of 
service  to the public and an ethical obligation to protect the health 
of  the  patient.   An  Advisory  opinion  to  the   American   Dental 
Associations  "Code of Professional Conduct" urges dentists who become 
ill or impaired to limit the-activities of  practice  to  those  areas 
that do not endanger either patients or dental staff.  

Currently,  there  is  no  scientific  evidence  to indicate that HlV-
positive health-care  providers  pose  an  identifiable  risk  of  HIV 
transmission  to  their  patients.  There has been only one documented 
case of transmission  from  an  HlV-infected  healthcare  provider  to 
patients  during  the  past  ten  Years  of  experience with AIDS,  an 
indication that the  risk  is  infinitesimal.  The  ADA  continues  to 
believe  that  the  recommended  infection  control.   procedures  are 
effective in preventing transmission of infection.  

However,  the recent case of possible HIV transmission from dentist to 
patient  has  raised  some  uncertainty about the risk of transmission 
from healthcare provider to patient.  While  there  is  evidence  that 
this  dental  practice  did not consistently adhere to all recommended 
guidelines  for  prevention  of  disease  transmission,   the  precise 
mechanism   of  transmission  in  this  case  remains  unknown.   This 
uncertainty leads to the conclusion that the foremost concern  of  the 
dental  profession  must  continue  to  be  protection of the patient.  
@hus,  until the uncertainty about transmission is resolved,  the  ADA 
believes  that  HlV-infected  dentists  should refrain from performing 
invasive procedures or should disclose their seropositive status.  

The American Dental  Association  will  assist  and  support  infected 
dentists in sustaining meaningful professional careers.  

--  
   -------------------------------------------------------------------------
          St. Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center, Phoenix, Arizona
        uucp: {gatech, ames, rutgers}!ncar!asuvax!stjhmc!ddodell
    Bitnet: ATW1H @ ASUACAD                    FidoNet=> 1:114/15
    Internet: ddodell@stjhmc.fidonet.org       FAX: +1 (602) 451-1165