[comp.software-eng] Which MSDOS RCS

G.Moretti@massey.ac.nz (Giovanni Moretti) (06/26/91)

Hi

I've eventually decided that I that RCS would be really useful but there
seem to be (at least) three versions for the PC.

    DOSRCS.ZIP   - apparently a port of the original version
    MYRCS.ZIP    - GNU RCS #5.5
    MKSRCS.ZIP   - from MKS (at a guess :-)
    SH_RCS       - ??? (name might be incorrect but it starts with SH)


DOSRCS

I tried DOSRCS and it seemed fine, except that \RCS has to be in capitals
and RLOG crashes if you ask for the log entries on many files :-(


MYRCS.ZIP (GNU RCS #5.5)

This seems to clobber the last letter of the filename
   ie FRED.PAS -> FRED.PAV
although it seems to know to put it back if you ask for FRED.PAS
The file didn't contain any documentation :-( but did mention that version
5.6 was nearly out.

MKSRCS
This, I haven't tried.  I assumes it's OK for distribution even though
MKS is a commercial company (otherwise it wouldn't be available ;-)


Given that once you've committed files to an archive (and typed in LOG
entries) they probably not compatible, which one would you recommend if
you were starting off?

My tendency is towards GNU (hopefully 5.6 will be compatible with 5.5)
but I don't much like the way it crunches the last letter the file
extension.

Which do you recommend?

Thanks
Giovanni


-- 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Giovanni Moretti, Computer Science Dept, Massey University, Palmerston North,
Mail: Internet: G.Moretti@massey.ac.nz, Pkt-Radio: ZL2BOI@ZL2TCA | New Zealand
Ph 64 63 69099 x8694,FAX 64 63 505607 | QUITTERS NEVER WIN, WINNERS NEVER QUIT
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

rhyde@hubbell.ucr.edu (randy hyde) (06/27/91)

MKSRCS is commerical software.  You're supposed to pay for it.  It definitely
isn't "available" as shareware or PD, to my knowledge.  Just because somebody
posted it to the net doesn't make it legal.  Unless MKS has released a toned
down version, I'd be suspicious about this product.`

*** Randy Hyde rhyde@ucrmath.ucr.edu