[comp.protocols.appletalk] Apple IIgs to Sun 2/120?

UD169430@NDSUVM1.BITNET (Mike Aos) (11/20/90)

Help!  I've tried and tried to post but this wonderful machine keeps swallowing
my posts!
I have a Sun 2/50, connected to a 2/120 server.  I also have an Apple IIgs and
I would like to be able to take advantage of the resources available on the
2/120 (large hard disk and tape drive).  I've got Ethernet 'tween the 2/50 and
2/120, and I have AppleShare on my IIgs, and it's supposed to be able to deal
with anything that's AFP v2.0 compatible.  I know there's a program out there
called CAP, but I don't have it, and I don't know if I can use it.  I've been
told I need a "fastpath" box, or SunOS v4.0.3 (I'm using v3.5).  How much is a
"fastpath" box gonna set me back?  I'm on a VERY limited budget.  Does anyone
have any ideas or experience with this matter?   I'm really at a loss.

Mike
---
Mike Aos       "I own a Harley, not just a T-shirt!"  ['68 Sporty]
East Grand Forks, MN (yeah, it's COLD up here)  {Helmit laws still suck!}
(218) 773-9154 -> Home  "Mother do you think they'll drop the bomb
(218) 773-7933 -> Work   Mother do you think they'll like this song"
(218) 773-6834 -> BBS          |  Woz  |    "Mother", Pink Floyd, _The Wall_
UD182050@NDSUVM1 (.Bitnet?) | Apple IIgs, | "Share and Enjoy"    'Stay Tooned!'
UD182050@VM1.NoDak.Edu    |    Sun 2/50     | -Sirius Cybernetics Corporation
 I like to trade.       |    and Sun 2/120    |     (reserved for a Mac slam)
    Write "Fox"      | 'till I can afford a NeXT!|    Save _Alien Nation!_

toddpw@nntp-server.caltech.edu (Todd P. Whitesel) (11/20/90)

If you don't already have a fastpath, you're stuck. Unless you can get an
ethernet interface for the IIgs (doubt it) you'll need a fastpath to get
from the IIgs' LocalTalk to the Sun. The same is true for any group of //'s or
Mac's without ethernet interfaces.

FastPaths cost on the order of a thousand, so I guess you're sunk. It helps a
lot if you already have a Fastpath around to support the computer labs (or the
student's personal machines, which is how I get at the AUFS server here at
Caltech).

The second half of this question is the one I'm working on: putting real
ProDOS support into AUFS. The server already maintains fields earmarked for
prodos file info, but doesn't initialize them to anything meaningful. This
effectively neutralizes any attempt to read a file from the server because
no programs will recognize the invalid file types, and Finder can't copy
files onto a local disk because it passes the invalid filetype to the prodos
file system translator without checking it -- and gets a 'parameter out of
range' error back.

I've discovered _more_or_less_ where in AUFS the code needs to be added, but
I am not at all sure that I am compiling AUFS correctly (I tried setting the
debug option because it said that all the files would be stashed in a
subdirectory for easy checking, but did that work? NOOoooooOOO...)

Todd Whitesel
toddpw @ tybalt.caltech.edu

jerrys@canada.sbi.com (Jerry Simonowits) (11/21/90)

There is now available a localtalk board for use by sun workstations. I know they work with 
sparcstations (or I should say are available, I am not sure if they work). I don't know if
they are available for other types of machines.


Jerry Simonowits
Salomon Technology Services, Inc.
Internetworking & Support Group	
Phone:  201-896-7330
Email:  jerrys@canada.sbi.com		
(KB2GCG)

UD169430@NDSUVM1.BITNET (Mike Aos) (11/22/90)

I talked to someone (forget who now), who said a newer version of CAP that
required SunOS v4.0.3 or 4.1 talked directly to the ethernet hardware and lets
you bypass the fastpath box.  Can anyone deny or confirm this?

Mike
---
Mike Aos       "I own a Harley, not just a T-shirt!"  ['68 Sporty]
East Grand Forks, MN (yeah, it's COLD up here)  {Helmit laws still suck!}
(218) 773-9154 -> Home  "Mother do you think they'll drop the bomb
(218) 773-7933 -> Work   Mother do you think they'll like this song"
(218) 773-6834 -> BBS          |  Woz  |    "Mother", Pink Floyd, _The Wall_
UD182050@NDSUVM1 (.Bitnet?) | Apple IIgs, | "Share and Enjoy"    'Stay Tooned!'
UD182050@VM1.NoDak.Edu    |    Sun 2/50     | -Sirius Cybernetics Corporation
 I like to trade.       |    and Sun 2/120    |     (reserved for a Mac slam)
    Write "Fox"      | 'till I can afford a NeXT!|    Save _Alien Nation!_

hedrick@athos.rutgers.edu (Charles Hedrick) (11/28/90)

The current version of Rutgers CAP will let Suns speak Ethertalk,
phase 1.  This will let you avoid using a Fastpath if you have Macs
connected directly to Ethernet.  If your Macs are on Localtalk, then
you'll need a Fastpath or equivalent in any case, though there may
still be advantages to using Ethertalk.

This version of CAP is on rutgers.edu, as src/ru-cap2.tar.Z.  The
necessary kernel support for Suns (which does not require Sun or Unix
source to install, but will only work for 4.0.3 or later) is
src/enet.tar.Z.  (It is possible to use this code without special
kernel support if you have SunOS 4.0 or later, but in order to do
without the kernel support you have to use /dev/nit.  We believe the
performance implications of using it are likely to be unacceptable to
many users.  On a lightly loaded machine you might get away with it.)
We have it running in test mode on a Pyramid, but the kernel support
requires Pyramid source to install.  The Pyramid version might be the
best starting point for ports to other systems, as it uses System V
shared memory instead of Sun's mmap, and it can use a somewhat more
primitive version of the RPC library.  A port to the newest Ultrix
should be fairly easy, as Ultrix now includes /dev/enet in the kernel.

This is still relatively new software.  The current copy has included
a few changes to improve reliability, and works pretty well here.  But
as with any new P.D. software, there may still be problems.  There
have been some changes in the newest version to allow use on a network
without any Appletalk routers.  This has received less testing than
the rest of the software.

There have been a lot of requests for Ethertalk phase 2.  I'm still
planning to do that, but I'd like to wait until I'm confident in this
version before doing anything more to it.

joseph@elbereth.rutgers.edu (Seymour Joseph) (12/04/90)

Chuck,

I don't think he was asking about appletalk phase II, he was asking
about AUFS's non compliance with the Apple Filing Protocol 2.0 (AFP
2.0).  This protocol is the basis for apple's current file sharing
products and is backward compatible with AFP 1.0 for most Macintosh
applications.  Unfortunately, the Apple IIGS and some other
implementations REQUIRE the current 2.0 implementation or newer.
(rumor has AFP 3.0 ready for release within 6 months)

Since AFP 1.0 works for most machines, many developers of file sharing
tools have not bothered to update them to support 2.0.  When 3.0
ships, they may be very sorry they haven't kept up.

This situation makes things very confusing for folks using applshare
compatible drivers and devices that simply won't work because the
third party applications have never been updated.   AUFS is one of
those applications.

Seymour