[comp.protocols.tcp-ip] Codenoll Fiber modems

peter@julian.UUCP (10/19/87)

We have couple of buildings that happen to have some spare 50 micron
fiber cable between them.  We want to use this cable to link a set of
ethernets via IP gateway boxes (probably Cisco systems).  One product
that was recommended to us (by Cisco systems) was the model 3030a
modem from Codenoll (us$795 each).  This seems like a very reasonable
price for a 10Mb/sec modem.  I'm looking for sites that are using
these modems to get some idea about how well they work.  Anyone using
them?
-- 
Peter Marshall, Data Comm. Manager
CCS, U. of Western Ontario, London, Canada N6A 5B7
(519)661-2151x6032 
pm@uwovax.BITNET; pm@uwovax.uwo.cdn; peter@julian.uucp; ...!watmath!julian!peter

ron@topaz.rutgers.edu (Ron Natalie) (10/20/87)

We put a pair of FiberCom Whisperlan transcievers into operation
recently.  These are running over about 2000' of fiber between
two buildings here at Rutgers.  One end is plugged directly into
an IP/DECNET Gateway (CISCO) and the other is plugged into a
TCP multiport box which intern has the central gateways (a collection
of several CISCO boxes and a VAX 750).  The boxes cost about $850
and we haven't had any problem with them.  They have the advantage
(unlike the Codenol, I believe) of allowing multiple units to be
ringed.  That is, you can connect three or more of these boxes
together using fiber rather than using them as a point to point
link.  This ends up saving you the price and the overhead of a
board in the CISCO box in the middle of the net having to copy
packets bridging accross the two fiber segments.

There are a number of others coming on the market including one
from Optical Data Systems that claims to be selling for under $600.
We haven't seen them yet.

-Ron

chris@gargoyle.UChicago.EDU (Chris Johnston) (10/28/87)

We have both Cisco gateways and Codenol fiber optic ethernet
tranceivers (modems).

We have had been using Codenol for 3 years now and have been very
pleased with the reliability.  We have a fiber optic back bone
connected at the center by a passive star.  Gateways are at the ends
of the fiber arms.  Coax and fiber ethernets radiate from the
gateways.

This is a very good topology (no loops).  And extremely reliable
technology (no midnight cable taps destroying your network).  The
gateways protect your backbone bandwidth from most net nonsense.

For us this has been a low cost, low maintainance, high reliability
configuration.

cj


-- 
* -- Chris Johnston --        * UChicago Computer Science Dept
* chris@gargoyle.uchicago.edu * 1100 East 58th Street
* ...ihnp4!gargoyle!chris     * Chicago, IL  60637
* johnston@uchicago.BITNET    * 312-702-8440