[comp.protocols.tcp-ip] FTP vs. VMS & long passwords

shj@ultra.UUCP (Steve Jay) (03/01/88)

FTP client on an Amdahl (UTS580-1.1.3, 4.3 Net) system or Ultrix (V2.0-1) gets

   "530 Login failed (bad Username or Password), give new USER and PASS "

when attempting to use FTP server on a VAX VMS system, and the password
for the VAX account is over 8 characters long.

This has been observed with VAX's running Wollongong (versions 3.1 & 4.0)
and Excelan (EXOS Version 4.5) servers.  Client FTP on a BSD 4.3
system to the VMS servers works fine.  The UTS and Ultrix clients also
work when the VMS password is 8 or fewer characters.

Has anyone else seen this behavior?  Does anyone know who's fault it is?
Who should I complain to?

I am not on the tcp-ip list, so please send responses directly to me
at the email addresses shown below.

Thanks for your help.

Steve Jay                       domain: shj@ultra.com
Ultra Network Technologies	Internet: ultra!shj@ames.arc.nasa.gov
2140 Bering drive               uucp: ...ames!ultra!shj
San Jose, CA 95131		
408-922-0100

mf@savax.UUCP (Marc Fleischmann) (03/01/88)

In article <8802292102.AA06989@macduff.ultra.com> shj@ultra.UUCP (Steve Jay) writes:
>
>when attempting to use FTP server on a VAX VMS system, and the password
>for the VAX account is over 8 characters long.
>
>This has been observed with VAX's running Wollongong (versions 3.1 & 4.0)
>and Excelan (EXOS Version 4.5) servers.  Client FTP on a BSD 4.3

 I am running Excelan Release 3.3 V3-3Vv2 which has the server
EXOS Version 4.5 Mon Sept 8 8:41:17 PDT 1986 and have no problems with 
passwords of 16 characters using FTP clients from EXcelan, Ultrix V2.0-1
and Apollo.  

I am running MicroVMS V4.6.


/marc
---

-- 
Marc Fleischmann
Sanders Associates, Inc. - Nashua N.H.  (603) 885-5050
UUCP: ihnp4!decvax!savax!mf

jmg@cernvax.UUCP (jmg) (03/03/88)

In article <8802292102.AA06989@macduff.ultra.com> shj@ultra.UUCP (Steve Jay) writes:
>
>   "530 Login failed (bad Username or Password), give new USER and PASS "
>
>when attempting to use FTP server on a VAX VMS system, and the password
>for the VAX account is over 8 characters long.

Same problem seen on trying to FTP to a Vax from the IBM TCP/IP on our
VM system.
(After hacking attacks many people go beyond 8 characters!)
-- 
 _ _  o |             __                    |    jmg@cernvax.uucp
| | |   |     _      /  \  _   __  _   __  _|    jmg@cernvax.bitnet
| | | | |_)  /_)     |  __/_) | (___\ | (_/ |  J. M. Gerard, Div. DD, CERN,
| | |_|_| \_/\___    \__/ \___|   (_|_|   \_|_ 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland