[comp.sys.apollo] Ethernet board for Apollo3000 Actually a 3Com503 Board?

warren@samsung.com (Warren Lavallee) (10/11/89)

Hello All,

   We have an Apollo 3000 which is a 68020 box based on an AT bus [just
like a PC]. Our machine has a token ring board which is of no use to
us. Apollo offers another board that supports tcp/ip. My boss being
notably tight-fisted balks at spending $700 for a board. On the other I
suspect that the Apollo board is merely a 3COM503 Ethernet II. It would
be nice to verify that.

   Does anyone know?

					Thanks alot...
-- 
Samsung Software America.       Warren J. Lavallee        Systems Administator.
UUCP:  warreng@ginosko.UUCP               NEARnet/Internet:  warren@samsung.com
            ...and my heart beats like a drum, all night...

shull@scrolls.wharton.upenn.edu (Christopher E. Shull) (10/11/89)

In article <4548@ginosko.samsung.com> warren@samsung.com (Warren Lavallee) writes:
[...]
>   We have an Apollo 3000 which is a 68020 box based on an AT bus [just
>like a PC]. Our machine has a token ring board which is of no use to
>us. Apollo offers another board that supports tcp/ip. My boss being
>notably tight-fisted balks at spending $700 for a board. On the other I
>suspect that the Apollo board is merely a 3COM503 Ethernet II. It would
>be nice to verify that.
[...]

The only problems are:

   1)  there is a special chip that Apollo adds to the 3COM503 board
       that lets it figure out its unique 48-bit Ethernet hardware
       address (based on the Apollo's node id), and, 

   2)  the original Apollo DN3000's didn't understand anything but
       token ring boards, and there is a boot PROM (or something) on
       the motherboard that needs to be replaced for them to accept
       an Ethernet board as its primary network.

Good luck!

-Chris

Christopher E. Shull                    shull@scrolls.wharton.upenn.edu
Decision Sciences Department            shull@wharton.upenn.edu
The Wharton School                      University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, PA  19104-6366            215/898-5930
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Damn the torpedoes!  Full speed ahead!"  Admiral Farragut, USN, 1801-1870
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

tpfabian@nasamail.nasa.gov (THEODORE FABIAN) (10/12/89)

regarding the following:

From: warren%ginosko%uakari.primate.wisc.edu%uwm.edu%mailrus.uucp@tut.cis.ohio-state.edu  (Warren Lavallee)
Subject: Ethernet board for Apollo3000 Actually a 3Com503 Board?

Hello All,

   We have an Apollo 3000 which is a 68020 box based on an AT bus [just
like a PC]. Our machine has a token ring board which is of no use to
us. Apollo offers another board that supports tcp/ip. My boss being
notably tight-fisted balks at spending $700 for a board. On the other I
suspect that the Apollo board is merely a 3COM503 Ethernet II. It would
be nice to verify that.

   Does anyone know?

					Thanks alot...
-- 
Samsung Software America.       Warren J. Lavallee        Systems Administator.




-----------------


yes, I believe the alternate board you refer to is a 3COM 503 board..
at least the ones we're using are...
 
 
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
*       Thanks,                                             *
*                                                           *
*         Ted Fabian                                        *
*                                                           *
*            NASA Lewis Research Center                     *
*                   Cleveland, Ohio                         *
*                                                           *
*                 phone:     216-433-6307                   *
*                   FTS:         297-6307                   *
*                                                           *
*                 email:     tpfabian@nasamail.nasa.gov     *
*                            tfabian@earth.lerc.nasa.gov    *
*                            tfabian@csd.lerc.nasa.gov      *
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

lori@hacgate.UUCP (Lori Barfield) (10/13/89)

In article <15362@netnews.upenn.edu> shull@scrolls.wharton.upenn.edu (Christopher E. Shull) writes:
>[...]
>   2)  the original Apollo DN3000's didn't understand anything but
>       token ring boards, and there is a boot PROM (or something) on
>       the motherboard that needs to be replaced for them to accept
>       an Ethernet board as its primary network.

Actually, this little PROM isn't necessary at all.  The only thing it
is used for (apparently) is self-diagnostics at reset time.  If you
take out your ring card (like I did from my DN3000), the diagnostics
will fail because the Domain PROM tells it to look for a ring card.
But since this check comes last, the loss is trivial.  You can EX AEGIS
anyway.

According to our service rep., replacement of this PROM is included as
part of regular maintenance.  I haven't bothered.


...lori

danny@idacom.UUCP (Danny Wilson) (10/13/89)

In article <4548@ginosko.samsung.com>, warren@samsung.com (Warren Lavallee) writes:
>    We have an Apollo 3000 which is a 68020 box based on an AT bus [just
> like a PC]. Our machine has a token ring board which is of no use to
> us. Apollo offers another board that supports tcp/ip. [...]

Two comments:

1. When you order a workstation you have the choice of PHYSICAL interface
   i.e. either Token Ring or Ethernet

2. The TCP/IP protocol is generally independant of PHYSICAL interface
   and can run over both token ring and ethernet.

It appears that what you really _want_ is to run on an ethernet
physical interface with TCP/IP as your transport (and other) protocols...

-- 
Danny Wilson
IDACOM Electronics		danny@idacom.uucp
Edmonton, Alberta		alberta!idacom!danny
C A N A D A		X.400	danny@idacom.cs.ubc.cdn

reb@quintro.uucp (Roger E. Benz) (10/13/89)

In article <4548@ginosko.samsung.com> warren@samsung.com (Warren Lavallee) writes:
>Hello All,
>
>   We have an Apollo 3000 which is a 68020 box based on an AT bus [just
>like a PC]. Our machine has a token ring board which is of no use to
>us. Apollo offers another board that supports tcp/ip. My boss being
>notably tight-fisted balks at spending $700 for a board. On the other I
>suspect that the Apollo board is merely a 3COM503 Ethernet II. It would
>be nice to verify that.
>

Last year we were asking the same question and our Apollo SE said,
"Yes, it is a 3Com board, but it has an Apollo PROM".

-- 
Roger E. Benz		   Phone = (217) 223-3211
Quintron Corporation	   Quincy, Il
UUCP: tiamat!quintro!reb@uunet or quintro!reb@lll-winken 

lau@kings.wharton.upenn.edu (Yan K. Lau) (10/13/89)

In article <5520@hacgate.UUCP> lori@hacgate.UUCP (Lori Barfield) writes:
>
>Actually, this little PROM isn't necessary at all.  The only thing it
...
>But since this check comes last, the loss is trivial.  You can EX AEGIS
>anyway.
>
>...lori

I think there is one caveat here.  The PROM (?) is necessary for
*diskless* machines (yes, we have a few) to be able to boot over the
ethernet.  We have a node without this PROM still running SR9.7 because
we can't get it the recognize the DI E command to run the SR10 invol.


Yan.
   )~  Yan K. Lau    lau@kings.wharton.upenn.edu      The Wharton School
 ~/~                          128.91.11.233       University of Pennsylvania
 /\    Darker grows the moon  And shadows steal across the prison of my room