[net.news] News Suggestion

warren (09/22/82)

It seems that every time someone raises a new issue with news, new
articles on the same topic keep coming days later that appear as if
the author is unaware of all of the previous discussion.  Why not
have postnews or inews or whatever check and see if the news
submitter has read all of the articles in the categories to which
she/he is posting.  If not, the user should be warned and given the
opportunity to read the new items before posting.  This may cut down
the amount of duplication in the stuff flying over the net.
x

wagner (09/23/82)

Over in this corner of the net, we get articles all out of
order.  I routinely see replies several days before the 
question arrives.  No doubt we, in ourr isolation, also 
duplicate suggestions/statements made elsewhere, since they
seem to exhibit unpredictible transit times to us.

Michael Wagner, UTCS

ech (09/23/82)

#R:ihnss:-16900:whuxlb:7700004:000:590
whuxlb!ech    Sep 23 15:36:00 1982

Aha, excellent point, Warren!  Now all we have to do is make sure that
all the responses to an article arrive with the article...

Seriously, how do you get around the variable latency in news item delivery?
Respondents A and B may be an equal "net distance" from the original article
(thus see it the same day), but may be arbitrarily far from one another.
The best one can do is to see if you've seen all the locally received
responses, but failing a notes-like interface and a willingness to use
it broadly, there's no mechanical way to even match up items and responses.

=Ned Horvath=

lepreau (09/27/82)

When contemplating a followup or reply, a useful command is "e-", which
forgets that you saw the last article.  Then when you've finished
reading news, you can just readnews again and see any articles you
considered replying to.  The -/multiple newsgrps bug does not bite any
of the <cmd>- constructs that I know of.
-Jay Lepreau