[comp.windows.x] new newsgroup: comp.sources.x

mikew@wyse.com (Mike Wexler) (06/28/88)

I would like to form a moderated newsgroup for X11 sources.  It 
would be archived(any volunteers?). I proposed this to the backbone
and got four positive replies(so far) and no negative ones.
Rick Salz(moderator of comp.sources.unix) also thinks it would be
a good idea.  Here are some questions I expect and some answers
to them.

Why a newsgroup?
It provides efficient and fairly reliable(more so than mail) means of
distributing large sources.  It would also provide access mainly to 
people who do not have Internet access.

Are newsgroups a reliable way of distributing source.
According to Rick Salz, a newsgroups that is widely carried is
very reliable.  Also the archives increase reliability.  The could
probably provide direct connections for archive sites to increase
this reliability.

Why not comp.windows.x?
Their have already been many complaints about sources being posted their.

Why not comp.sources.unix?
Comp.sources.unix already has a large backlog, this would unload some of
that.  People that aren't interested in X sources wouldn't need to archive
or transfer them.  X sources are not necessarily specific to Unix.  
The moderator of comp.sources.x could test the sources to see if they work
with X.  

Why not comp.sources.misc?
Most of the reasons that apply to comp.sources.unix apply here.

Who would moderate it?
I volunteer to moderate it.

If you think this is a good idea, send me mail.  If you have any 
objections I will discuss them by mail our you can post them.
Mike Wexler(wyse!mikew)    Phone: (408)433-1000 x1330

mangerma@nmsu.CSNET (06/29/88)

Mike,

    Good idea.

    What is your address where you are working.

Thanks,

Michael Angerman
Computing Research Lab
New Mexico State University
Las Cruces, NM 88001

mangerma@nmsu.edu

raj@GLACIER.ICS.UCI.EDU (Richard Johnson) (06/30/88)

I think it would be a good idea.  My only problem with it is that we only keep
newsgroups around here for 2 weeks (for lack of disk space).  Lots of times
I can't get around to reading netnews stuff for months!  (I currently haven't
read it for the last 2 months or so because I'm just too busy!)
It'd be really nice if it were also made into an Internet bboard but that's
probably asking too much.

Richard