[comp.windows.x] IC3M window managers

jne@goldhill.COM (Jeff Eisen) (08/04/89)

Is there any way for a client to determine whether or not
it is running under an IC3M window manager, other than, of course,
passing some command line argument to the client program.

Jeff Eisen
Gold Hill Computers

wdc@ATHENA.MIT.EDU (Bill Cattey) (08/05/89)

I'd like to take this opportunity to propose a method whereby
applications and window managers could identify levels of ICCCM
conformance.

Although there are parts of the ICCCM that are not going to change for
the forseeable future, there are parts that are clearly marked as
problem areas that need conventions in the future.

It is also easy to see that it is a hard problem cutting over to full
ICCCM conformance.  Look at the discussion on xpert regarding the
question of an X consortium supplied window manager which is fully ICCCM
compliant.

I propose, therefore that each client and window manager be able to
respond to a request "What ICCCM protocol version do you speak." 
Naturally, there would be a "correct" version to be speaking, but at
least there would be a way for applications and window managers to
negotiate their conventions.

-wdc

rws@EXPO.LCS.MIT.EDU (08/08/89)

    I propose, therefore that each client and window manager be able to
    respond to a request "What ICCCM protocol version do you speak."

Your message has been forwarded within the X Consortium for discussion.
The first version of the ICCCM is finished, there is no changing that (for
a variety of reasons).  When a revision is later undertaken, the issue
will undoubtedly come up again.