[net.news] rn vs notesfiles

dan@rna.UUCP (Dan Ts'o) (10/24/84)

Hi,
	I must be missing something about 'rn'. I have only played with it
a bit - it was excellently packaged and is very nicely tuned visually - but
it so far seems still like a souped up vnews which seems like a visual
readnews. The notesfile interface, on the other hand, seems much more
optimal (at least I prefer it) where articles are grouped by topic or
discussion and you are presented a menu within each newsgroup/notesfiles
of the discussions/subjects of each article.
	Now, I would like to ditch notesfiles because its integration with
the news system is not perfect, but so far my use of an article-by-article
interface such as that of readnews, vnews and rn makes me prefer notes.

	Any insights ? One can only devote so much(little) energy to playing
with the news system. Thanks.


					Cheers,
					Dan Ts'o
					Dept. Neurobiology
					Rockefeller Univ.
					1230 York Ave.
					NY, NY 10021
					212-570-7671
					...cmcl2!rna!dan

j@utah-cs.UUCP (J Lepreau) (10/26/84)

Yeah, I too was disappointed to discover that all-singing all-dancing
rn has the same old one-at-a-time style.  I want to see an index of
subjects/authors/etc in one window and selected articles in the other,
but can't bear the apparently baroque notes/news interface that looses
garbage on the world every month or so.  Emacs' rnews.ml was too slow
when I tried it.  How hard would it be to make rn do this, rn hackers? I
suppose I could hack up dired to do it...