[net.news] problems with readnews

tish@adiron.UUCP (Tish Esposito) (11/01/85)

We are running the netnews distributed with 4.2BSD - version 2.10.1
When articles in net.unix-wizards ran beyond 8192 - readnews dumped
core.  After perusing the sources a bit it was discovered that a 
char bitmap[1024] is being used to keep track of articles read by
a user (8 * 1024 = 8192) so our problem seemed apparent. After some
more looking however there seemed to be some other inconsistensies
in netnews bookeeping. Articles may go as high as 99998, and in one
place in the code the bitmap array is cleared from 0 to 99998/8
(12500) entries.  I'm sure that other sites have experienced this
problem. Before hacking away at this code, I was wondering any
site already has a fix for this problem. Any help or suggestions
would be appreciated. Please respond via mail to duke!adiron!tish.
Thanks!!

jbuck@epicen.UUCP (Joe Buck) (11/07/85)

In article <273@adiron.UUCP> tish@adiron.UUCP (Tish Esposito) writes:
>We are running the netnews distributed with 4.2BSD - version 2.10.1

This is the version of news that contains the infamous line-eater bug.
There are other problems as well; you're apparently running into some
of them. Version 2.10.2 has been the standard version of news for over
a year.  2.10.3 is now in beta test. I presume it will be released via
mod.sources soon -- could some knowledgeable person please post a message
discussing its status?

The bitmap is gone from 2.10.2. This is good: the bitmap was too easy
to corrupt. I recommend that you convert to 2.10.2 as soon as possible.
Someone in your area should have the sources.

Will some kind soul that talks to, or is geographically near, adiron,
please provide them with the new sources?

IMPROVE THE NET -- STAMP OUT OBSOLETE NEWS SOFTWARE

-- 
Joe Buck				|  Entropic Processing, Inc.
UUCP: {ucbvax,ihnp4}!dual!epicen!jbuck  |  10011 N. Foothill Blvd.
ARPA: dual!epicen!jbuck@BERKELEY.ARPA   |  Cupertino, CA 95014

mlr0@bunny.UUCP (Martin Resnick) (04/03/86)

I would like readnews to display all of the messages in each specified group
in my .newsrc file before going on to the next group.  Currently, if a message
is posted to more than one group and the other group is in my .newsrc, the
message is sometimes skipped (probably depends on the order of the posted
newsgroups vs my .newsrc) and not displayed until I get to the other group
which contains the message.

I find this to be frustrating when I have a large number of groups in .newsrc
and don't have time to get to all of them.  My .newsrc is arranged so that
the groups are in order of importance.

Does vnews or rn do this?

If I notice a message has been skipped by readnews and read it manually
by specifing the number, readnews seems to get confused and screws up
my .newsrc so that when I subsequently run readnews, I get previously read
(but not saved) messages displayed!!

Has anyone else seen this problem?  Has it been fixed in 2.10.3?
What is the current status of 2.10.3?

Thanks.