[comp.os.minix] Minix compatibility reports. full dump.

broman@cod.UUCP (04/15/87)

Here are my gleanings from posted reports of Minix running or
not running on some system or with some particular hardware.
These are preliminary reports, not guarantees based on full tests.

Typos, misunderstandings, etc are very possible here.  For further info
contact the address given with each entry.

Please help with corrections/additions as you learn more.
Also, could someone report on exactly what controller chip is assumed
in the Minix code for the IBM PC/XT hard disk?
And what chips are "exact replacements" for it?


-----------------------------------------------------------
hardware	   rumorer              rumor

Leading Edge clone ganesh@utah-cs.uucp  runs
Samsung clone      ganesh               runs
IBM PC             ganesh               runs
Maynard Corp Hard Card ganesh           not compat
Epson Equity 3     ast@cs.vu.nl         runs with hard disk
BIOS silent partner ast                 runs with hd
Honeywell AP       ast                  runs with hd
Unisys micro IT    ast                  runs with hd
NCR PC8            ast                  runs but no hd
IBM PC-AT @6MHz    ast                  runs with hd
IBM PC-AT @8MHz    ast                  runs but no hd
IBM PC-XT-286      ast                  runs but no hd
Televideo Telenix 286 ast               runs, hd?
Compaq portable 1  ast                  not compat
Compaq 386         ast                  not compat
EGA video          ast                  code not working
Zenith Z-248 (AT)  ast                  runs with 20Mb hd, not 30Mb hd
Kaypro 286i (AT)   comp13@tjalk.cs.vu.nl runs (by implication)
WD1003-WA3 FDC     comp13 (ogilvie)     runs with posted fix
Unnamed Asian Clone arthur@ubu.uucp     runs
Epson FX-80 prtr   arthur@warwick.uucp  unreliable prtr driver
Xebec HDC with 20Mb disk   arthur       works, but hd <3Mb only
the Amstrad        lindsay@cheviot.newcastle.ac.uk  runs
Amstrad            steve@warwick.uucp   but not from the hard disk
Toshiba T1100+     stuart@bms-at.uucp   runs, w/ 720K drive with posted fix
Toshiba T1100+     bdale@winfree.uucp   runs
Zenith 181         bdale@winfree.uucp   infer from friend that it runs
3.5in disks on Toshiba   bdale@winfree  supported with posted mod.
WD1002A-WX1 HDC, Rodine 204 20M drive, bdale, won't run from HD
Leading Edge, models M&D  wegrzyn@cdx39.uucp  runs
Tandy 1000         kimery@wdl1.uucp     won't boot
Tandy 1000,1000SX,1000EX  john@moncol.uucp  won't run
AT&T 6300          john@moncol.uucp     runs with floppies
AT&T 6300 HD       dklann@marque.uucp   couldn't mkfs on HD
CT-6040S mono-graphics vid ctrlr  go@orstcs.uucp  supported with posted mod.
Faraday motherboard jallen@netxcom.uucp runs with floppies
IMC XT, 8MHz V20, Herc CRTC  beugel@klipper.cs.vu.nl  runs
Kaypro PC           ken@driwash.uucp    runs
Zenith 150          n0ano@wldrdg.uucp   runs on floppies, cannot write HD
Bernoulli disk      acharya@sbcs        has problems doing mkfs thereon
ATronics AT clone   hubble@cae780.uucp  runs
Seagate ST4906 80Mb HD  hubble@cae780.uucp  total confus
ITT XTRA, WD1002 HDC, ST225 HD  allbery@ncoast.uucp  hard disk didn't work.
WD 1002-WS1 HDC, ST225, go@orstcs.uucp  HD works readonly or write-slowly
Compaq DeskPro      walker@xanth.uucp   runs
Compaq DeskPro 286  walker@xanth.uucp   runs
ARC XT clone        m692040@sdsu.uucp   runs
Xebec HDC, 10Mb HD  m692040@sdsu.uucp   runs if minix on 1st partition
Commodore PC-10 II  ast@cs.vu.nl        runs with HD
IBM PC-XT           ast@cs.vu.nl        runs with 10Mb HD
ITT XTRA            ast                 runs
Shitel              ast                 won't run
(PC6300) WD1002A-WX2 HDC, Tulin TL240 jcs@chinet.uucp  works, but flakey at best

In addition, I infer from comparing The Book with my Tech-manual (no test yet)
that the Corona PC-400 should run minix also, with no problems.


Vincent Broman,  code 632, Naval Ocean Systems Center, San Diego, CA 92152, USA
Phone: +1 619 225 2365    Internet: broman@nosc.mil   Uucp: sdcsvax!nosc!broman

bdale@winfree.UUCP (Bdale Garbee) (04/19/87)

Here's another one.

I now have Minix pretty-much-running on a 4.77Mhz clone that started life
as a Tandy 1200, and which now has 640k, an Adaptec 2002 hard disk controller,
and a Rodime 20meg full-height drive (model 242, I think?).  One 360k floppy.

Status is that the Hercules-compatible monochrome card behaves fine, but
I'm having hard disk trouble.  Minix would only mkfs on the number 1 partition,
and wouldn't successfully mkfs a partition bigger than about 5meg.  I am
definitely seeing write errors, most of which get recovered from fairly well.
In addition, using FDISK followed by the DISKFIX utility provided with Minix
DID NOT convert the partitions to non-dos.  I ended up using the Ontrak
Disk Manager which I had lying around to create 4 5meg partitons, the first
of which is Minix' /usr, the fourth of which is PC-Dos 3.2 bootable, and the
middle two of which are waiting for fixes to Minix so I can mkfs them...

I tried both a Tulin 30meg 1/2 height and the Rodime on a WD1002 controller
with no luck at all.  The mkfs always died with a panic about the wini not
resetting.  VERY frustrating.
-- 

Bdale Garbee, N3EUA		phone: 303/593-9828 h, 303/590-2868 w
uucp: {bellcore,crash,hp-lsd,hpcsma,ncc,pitt,usafa,vixie}!winfree!bdale
fido: sysop of 128/19		packet: n3eua @ k0hoa, Colorado Springs