[net.news.group] mailing list v mod v net

ncx@cheviot.uucp (Lindsay F. Marshall) (10/24/85)

It is all very well for people to say "Topic X should be a mailing list
or a moderated group" BUT this is only practical when you are not paying
REAL MONEY for your mail. Sending to a Malinig list or a moderated group
has the immediate implications

	a) You pay for submission (this is not trivial when
	   trans-atlantic costs are consider - there are no moderators
	   outside Northa America as far as I can see), and

	b) You then have to pay AGAIN to receive your own article when
	   it appears in the mod group or mailing list (I know mailing
	   lists dont have to do this, but they almost always do)

This is rather unreasonable I feel as the cost should be distributed
between the readers of the group. This is not easy to do so the solution
is a "net" type group (possibly with limited distribution) which
guarantees single transmission from your site and shared cost. OK, so
the cost is then shared over everbody not just the subscribers, but,
heck, I'm paying part of their bills so it probably works even in the
end.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Lindsay F. Marshall, Computing Lab., U of Newcastle upon Tyne, Tyne & Wear, UK
  ARPA  : lindsay%cheviot.newcastle.ac.uk@ucl-cs.arpa
  JANET : lindsay@uk.ac.newcastle.cheviot
  UUCP  : <UK>!ukc!cheviot!lindsay
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------