[rec.birds] "library lifers"; 4 splits, no lumps

dmark@cs.Buffalo.EDU (David Mark) (08/02/89)

The July 1989 issue of the American Birding Association's newsletter
"Winging It" contains some information from the 37th supplement to the AOU
Check-List of North American Birds.  This time, they report 4 "splits"
in which two forms of a former species are elevated to species status,
and NO lumps, in which two 'species' are found not to be distinct, and
are combined.  Thus, if you know you've seen both forms, then you can add
a bird (or 4!) to your life list without ever leaving the library (or in
this case, the terminal).  So, here are the splits:

1.  Hummingbirds

Chlorostilbon bracei          Brace's Emerald
Chlorostilbon ricordii        Cuban Emerald

[first, the 6th edition of the AOU Check-List does not list subspecies for
 C. ricordii; I can only speculate that bracei is the Bahamas form (can
 anyone confirm or correct that?  Secondly, the ABA said they were only
 reporting changes effecting the ABA checklist (US & Canada), so have BOTH
 of these ocurred in the US?!?]


2.  Empidonax flycatchers [arghh!!! ANOTHER empi?!?]

Empidonax occidentalis        Cordilleran Flycatcher
Empidonax difficilis          Pacific-slope Flycatcher [terrible name, eh?]

As discussed in Birding, v. 18, no. 6, p. 324-5, difficilus is on the coast,
and the eastern limits are marked "by the Coast Ranges, the Cascades, and the 
Sierra Nevada."  occidentalis breeds from southern Alberta south into New Mexico
and extends west to Crater Lake area of Oregon (but difficilis is around
Mount Shasta).  It probably is safe to add occidentalis to your life list if
you have seen the species in Alberta, Arizona, or New Mexico; and to add
difficilis if you've seen "Western" flycatchers in those coastal mountains
mentioned.  Other than range, they are best separated in the field by calls:
Coastal:  single, strongly up-slurred note "peweap!" or "pseeyeet!"  
Interior: similar, but sharply two-syllabled "pit-peet!"


3.  Gnatcatchers

Polioptila californica     California Gnatcatcher
Polioptila melanura        Black-tailed Gnatcatcher

melanura in the deserts of the southwest; californica in the coastal sagebrush
and thorn forest of the coast, from LA county south into Baja California.


4.  Towhees

Pipilo crissalis            California Towhee
Pipilo fuscus               Canyon Towhee         [split of "Brown Towhee"]

crissalis occurs on the California coast including the Baja.  fuscus occurs
from SE California through the southern Great Basin areas and into mainland
Mexico.  (see Zink, R.M., The Condor 90:72-82 for details).

===============================================================================

Also, there is now:

Anthus rubescens     American Pipit

split from the old world Water Pipit and Rock Pipit, which I assume have been
split from each other.  So, if you've seen them in America and also both
forms in Europe, add at least 1, and perhaps 2, to your world life-list.

And finally, did you hear that the previous AOU Check-List supplement re-
instated Yellow-green Vireo (V. flavoviridis) are a full species (it had been 
lumped with Red-eyed Vireo in 1973)?

===============================================================================

So, how did you do?  I gained a Towhee and a Flycatcher (on range).

David Mark
dmark@cs.buffalo.edu

mjm@oliven.olivetti.com (Michael Mammoser) (08/04/89)

In article <8948@cs.Buffalo.EDU>, dmark@cs.Buffalo.EDU (David Mark) writes:
 > 
 > So, how did you do?  I gained a Towhee and a Flycatcher (on range).

	Same here. I got Canyon Towhee while I was in Arizona last year.
California Towhees are a common breeding bird here, where I live. The
towhees are easy to identify by plumage. The Pacific-Slope Flycatcher
is also a common breeder here. I saw Cordilleran Flycatchers twice: once
in Colorado (this bird was quiet and had to be identified by range; please
don't tell the ABA) and once in the south fork of Cave Creek Canyon in
Arizona (where, luckily, the bird was calling constantly). I've been
waiting patiently over a year for these splits to take place, but I would
like to know where they came up with the flycatcher names. Ugh!

	I also heard that they were planning on splitting the Rocky
Mountain form of Solitary Vireo. Has anyone heard anything more about
this?

Mike