[rec.birds] Bird Misidentifications I have known

dragon@eleazar.dartmouth.edu (Sam Conway) (12/06/89)

>................. One day, she got a call from a woman who
>said she had an eagle in her yard.  Judy (my friend) asked the woman to 
>describe the bird.  The woman gave the description, and had Judy completely
>stumped.  Finally, in exasperation, Judy decided to drive the 5 miles or
>so to the woman's house to see the alleged eagle.  The bird turned out to
>be a chicken!   (True story, I swear!)
>
>-Greg

I believe it!  I have taken many calls from many people who had wounded
birds in their possession.  Some are particularly notable:

A "two-foot-tall orange hawk" which turned out to be a kestrel.

A "baby golden/bald eagle" which turned out to be a redtail (common).

A "fish hawk" that was really a great blue heron (they eat fish, right?)

A "peregrine falcon" that was really a pigeon (pigeon hawk?)

A "hawk with a 5-foot-wingspan" that was really a grouse.

A "woodpecker" that was really a goshawk (boy, was THAT a surprise!)

And my favorite, a "baby great horned owl that was orphaned and injured,
although it was 45 minutes before it was finally cornered and caught with
a net".  This was really an adult saw-whet owl with no injury whatsoever.
How they had thought a feisty, flying bird was injured is beyond me.
 
 If anyone has any more of these, feel free to e-mail them to me.  Stories
 such as these are fun to collect!


 (and the heron mentioned above nearly put out the eye of the man who
  tried to catch it.  NEVER handle a heron without a face shield!)


--
Sam Conway 
dragon@eleazar.dartmouth.edu                                         
Chemistry Dept., Dartmouth College
Vermont Raptor Center, VINS                         Save the Humans!

king@cbnewsk.ATT.COM (joyce.l.king) (12/10/89)

My rescue area runs the full length of Key Largo, so I get a lot of funny
bird identifications.  Many of the people on Key Largo are tourists, and
they aren`t familiar with our birds.  But a ranger at John Pennekamp
underwater park called me with a pelican that was a great blue heron.  And
just last week I picked up a "baby osprey" that was an immature little
green heron.  I had a call last Sunday to pick up a "crane" that was an
injured white ibis.  We get them almost every day.  

Joyce Andrews King (from the Florida Keys via modern communications)