[comp.sys.sun] 3rd party disks for SLC's

ramsey@lll.llnl.gov (Ramsey, Susanne) (06/13/90)

I figure that SLC's have been out long enough that I can get some good
information from the net.  Our division is considering purchasing SLC's
for many of our users.  We want to make them "dataless" clients, with page
and swap on a local disk.  My question/problem is: Which disks?  Some
folks want 3rd party because they are less expensive; but I wonder if in
the long term it is not better to go with a SUN made disk.

I would like to hear your comments in support of either way. Also if you
have a favorite please send me info such as the manufacturer, sales rep,
phone number and cost.

By the way, we are considering 104MB disks but if you have arguments for
larger I'd also like to hear those.

Please respond directly to me and I will summarize if there is enough
interest.

Thanks to all.
Susanne (YES that's with an "s" not a "z")

Susanne Barbera-Ramsey		Lawerence Livermore National Laboratory
Internet: ramsey@lll.llnl.gov	7000 East Ave. L-630
(415) 423-9530			Livermore Ca 94550

ballen@csd4.csd.uwm.edu (Bruce Allen) (06/14/90)

I don't have experience with the SLC, but I do have experience with
SparcStations.  The short answer to your question is, don't buy disks from
Sun.  They are too expensive, and you have to pay for service.

At the moment, the disks I am buying are 660 Mbyte formatted, from
R-Squared 800-777-3478.  These disks are in a box, cabled, and ready to
go.  They cost $2112 and have a 5 (five) year warranty.  The basic disk is
a Fujitsu M2263S.	

Smaller size disks are cheaper.

Even with discounts, a 327 Mbyte disk from Sun cost 3K, has a 90 day
warranty, and you have to pay about $60/month for maintenance.  Five year
warranties buy peace of mind.  They are a good idea.  (HP also have 5 year
warranties on disks.)

Conclusion: Don't buy from Sun.