covert%covert.DEC@decwrl.dec.com (John R. Covert) (03/16/89)
Date: 15 March 1989 To: The Commonwealth of Massachusetts Department of Public Utilities Boston, Massachusetts 02202 Re: New England Telephone Company -- CLASS Services Calling Number Identification CC: Attorney General's Office of Consumer Protection, Utilities Division From: John R. Covert, Consumer New England Telephone has announced their intention to begin providing a new family of telephone features called CLASS. These features provide some useful enhancements to telephone service, such as: - The ability to cause a call trace record to be generated by the telephone company for later inquiry, - The ability to automatically return a call from the last number which called a telephone, - The ability to block incoming calls from a list of one or more numbers, - The ability to enable distinctive ringing for calls from one or more numbers All of the above mentioned features will be welcome additions to the services offered by New England Telephone. However, one additional feature is of significant concern: - The ability for any subscriber to obtain the number of the telephone which is currently calling. There are serious privacy problems associated with providing this information to anyone except law enforcement agencies. A subscriber may wish to call a business to obtain information about a product without that business automatically being able to place the calling telephone number on a list for follow-up sales calls. A subscriber may wish to place a call from a private number, and would like for the called party to return calls only to a number specified by the caller, not necessarily the number from which the call is currently being placed. For example, a personal call made from a business number might properly only be returned at home, or a business call made while at home might properly only be returned to the business number. -2- A woman in a battered women's shelter may wish to call her children without making it possible for her husband to determine her location. The Massachusetts DPU and Attorney General should study the privacy implications of this feature. If calling number display devices are to be permitted at all, subscribers must be able to disable transmission of the number from which they are calling, must be able to do this from any and all tele- phones within the Commonwealth at no added cost, and must be able to disable calling number transmission without remembering to dial a special code before each call. Sincerely, John R. Covert