[comp.dcom.telecom] Projections for V&H Table Coordinates

dattier@jolnet.orpk.il.us (David W. Tamkin) (10/16/89)

John R. Levine contributed to issue 450, volume 9:

| The V&H tape uses some other projection that I expect is intended to
| make equal distances equal.

Intended, perhaps, but not successful.  A projection that makes equal
distances on the earth's surface equal on a plane map is impossible
unless the area being mapped is a mesa top.

As long as the distances between points are to be calculated as
Pythagorean diagonals, something has to break down somewhere.  My
guess is that the coordinates are based on many projections of small
areas; there would still be a problem in joining these smaller maps,
but perhaps the theory is that with greater distances the error is
less significant as rate bands become larger and fewer.

With Illinois Bell, though, the coordinates are gospel: there is an
eight-mile band for local calls, and the Chicago-Irving and Schiller
Park CO's are a few feet more than eight miles apart.  Illinois Bell
dutifully charges a call between those two districts in the
eight-to-fifteen mile band.  On the other hand, the Chicago-Canal East
and Chicago-Canal West switches, being in the same building, have the
same coordinates assigned, so the distance between them never comes
into consideration, though it is perhaps almost as great as the excess
over eight miles in the distance between the Schiller Park and
Chicago-Irving switches.

David W. Tamkin dattier@jolnet.orpk.il.us
{attctc,netsys}!jolnet!dattier P. O. Box 813 Rosemont, Illinois 60018-0813
(708) 518-6769 (312) 693-0591 BIX: dattier GEnie:
D.W.TAMKIN CIS: 73720,1570 The opinions above are mine.