[comp.dcom.telecom] New Hotel Ripoff

dgc@math.ucla.edu (David G. Cantor) (03/27/91)

I was just a guest at the Del Mar Hilton Hotel (in Del Mar,
California).  The telepone in the room had printed on it, quite
clearly, "Local calls 50 cents" and I placed a call to a number in La
Jolla, California, which is immediately adjacent to Del Mar and which
is a local call from Del Mar (according to PacTel, which provides
local telephone service in the area and which provided the telephone
directory in my hotel room).  My bill contained a $4.86 charge for
this call.  I objected and the clerk replied that it wasn't a local
call.  After it became clear that I was familiar with the area, etc.,
she stated that "Yes, it is a local call from the [PacTel] payphone in
the lobby, but not from our system"! . . .


David G. Cantor    Department of Mathematics   University of California
Los Angeles, CA 90024-1555     Internet:  dgc@math.ucla.edu

Barton.Bruce@camb.com (Barton F. Bruce) (03/29/91)

In article <telecom11.245.8@eecs.nwu.edu>, dgc@math.ucla.edu (David G.
Cantor) writes:

> I was just a guest at the Del Mar Hilton Hotel (in Del Mar,

> clearly, "Local calls 50 cents" and I placed a call to a number in La

> My bill contained a $4.86 charge for  this call.  I objected and the clerk 

If enough folks on the net were interested to see if the Hilton Hotels
have some chain policy, they could EACH call Hilton's 1.800.445.8667
number and ask. It might be reasonable to also ask if the Del Mar
property is Hilton owned or privately owned, and if privately owned,
'Are they supposed to be conforming to chain policies that prevent one
property from giving the rest of the chain a bad reputation?'.

It is always wise to do as much travel planning ahead of time as
possible, and this little call may simplify future decisions.

john@zygot.ati.com (John Higdon) (03/29/91)

"David G. Cantor" <dgc@math.ucla.edu> writes:

> I objected and the clerk replied that it wasn't a local
> call.  After it became clear that I was familiar with the area, etc.,
> she stated that "Yes, it is a local call from the [PacTel] payphone in
> the lobby, but not from our system"!

When you step over the threshold of a motel or hotel, you are subject
to its tender mercies. It controls the horizontal and the vertical. It
can make the image a soft blur or sharpen it ... oops, sorry. Wrong
program. But you get the idea. It can charge whatever it likes.

A visitor from out of the area stayed at a Day's Inn in Santa Clara.
For those not familiar with the area, Santa Clara is completely
encompassed by the "San Jose 2" calling area. It includes all of Santa
Clara, San Jose, Sunnyvale, Campbell, Los Gatos, Mountain View and Los
Altos (in 415), Milpitas, and Cupertino as local. But the sign on the
telephone indicated that anything outside of Santa Clara was "long
distance".

So a perfectly local call to my house from the lobby pay phone ended
up being a rather costly "long distance" call from the room. Remember,
you pay dearly for that convenient telephone in your room.


        John Higdon         |   P. O. Box 7648   |   +1 408 723 1395
    john@zygot.ati.com      | San Jose, CA 95150 |       M o o !

yazz@prodnet.la.locus.com (Bob Yazz) (04/01/91)

On that Del Mar Hilton the phone bill overcharge --

This hotel is in my local calling area so I called them up and asked
about it.  I got the manager in charge of their phone system.  She
insisted that it was Pacific Bell that programmed their system and
that Hilton charged their hotel guests a non-local rate Only because
Pac Bell charged Hilton a non-local rate.

I insisted her information was false.  She offered to look at my bill,
and I believe that if I had been the guest with the bill she'd have
refunded the $4.86 for "guest relations" reasons and let it go, but
she did promise to get with Pac Bell and make sure they were charging
correctly.

She also indicated exactly what the earlier poster indicated -- that a
call to La Jolla (an abutting community to the south) was a local call
from the Pac Bell payphone in the lobby but Not a local call from the
Pac Bell programmed Hotel Telephone System.

My Pacific Bell directory indicates that Del Mar to La Jolla is a zone
1 (as local as it gets) call.

Anybody at Pac Bell or Hilton reading this?


Payphone ripoff problems in California?  Call Pacific Bell at 800/352-2201
Bob Yazz --  yazz@lccsd.sd.locus.com         They take complaints M-F, 8-5