[comp.dcom.telecom] Japan and Modems

Jim W Lai <jwtlai@watcgl.waterloo.edu> (05/03/91)

Looking through the ads of a Japanese computer magazine, I was puzzled
by the high cost of modems compared with North America.  No US brands
were for sale.  Can anyone explain the nature of this situation?  I
also noticed the Japanese modem brands were not sold in the US either.

David Gast <gast@cs.ucla.edu> (05/08/91)

> Looking through the ads of a Japanese computer magazine, I was puzzled
> by the high cost of modems compared with North America.  No US brands
> were for sale.  Can anyone explain the nature of this situation?

I know that U.S. made modems like telebits work in Japan because I
have used them in Japan.  You really should not decide what is
available and/or what works based on who is advertizing in a
particular magazine.  It is also possible that some U.S. companies
have sold the rights to market their modems in Japan to another
compnay or that there are joint venture projects such as Fuji-Xerox
that do not include the American name.  Finally, you do not mention if
you read Japanese, but if you don't it is possible that the Japanese
in the ads would have explained the situation.

At any rate, one can buy U.S. modems in Japan.

Jim W Lai <jwtlai@watcgl.waterloo.edu> (05/10/91)

I posted about this recently and received a few pieces of email in
response.  I based my judgment of the lack of availability of US
modems on the ads of mail order companies in some Japanese computer
magazines and the persual of a few stores on a recent visit.  The two
brands of modem that seemed to be most popular on the store shelves
for 2400 baud were Omrom and Aiwa.

Apparently US modems can be bought in Japan and vice versa.  The
reason I was at a loss to explain the situation is because I noted the
ridiculously high cost of 1200 baud modems in Japan.  I fail to find
the protectionism argument satisfactory since even a 100% tariff would
not pose a barrier to the sale of US 1200 baud modems.  Does anyone
know if Japan has strict RFI emissions standards or if there are any
joint ventures with US modem manufacturers?

As an aside, I was told there that the phone lines in Japan were clean
enough to handle 9600 baud.  However, I found their international long
distance system (controlled through another company?) to be somewhat
less reliable.  Due to noise, 2400 baud would probably be the best
that could be relied on.