[rec.games.video] Comparison between NES M.U.L.E. and old style M.U.L.E

jennifer@bertha.jpl.nasa.gov (Lorini) (10/23/90)

[M.U.L.E. is now available for the Nintendo Entertainment System (NES)
licensed by Electronic Arts to Mindscape Inc.  It sells for $49.95
retail I think, altho I got mine for $39.99 from Electronic Boutique]

There have been postings in rec.games.misc and comp.sys.amiga.games
wishing that M.U.L.E. would be re-released someday.  Well it has, and
the following is a comparison of the old and the new.

Comparison between Nintendo (NES) M.U.L.E. and Atari 800 M.U.L.E.:

The big difference is that they added this (stupid, IMHO) speech synthesis which
says your color and player type.  They also took out nearly every other sound
that was really helpful, such as the sound that indicated that you or another
player had a random event during your turn, the sounds of the players bidding
(that marching type sound), the sound letting you know time is running out on 
your turn, and others that I can't think of right now. The lack of sound really
subtracts from the game play, I have no idea why Mindscape (the producers of the
NES version) did this.

The graphics have changed.  When you go into the store to get your M.U.L.E., you
see a set of doors opening to each option.  You can no longer see if there are
any M.U.L.E.'s available in the M.U.L.E. corral; you have to go in, and then you
can see.  The M.U.L.E.'s look better tho, like what a real M.U.L.E. might look
like.  You no longer can see what the base production is of a M.U.L.E. once he's
been planted on your plot.  This has major implications for Crystite mining,
since now the only way you really know what the base level is for the Crystite
is to assay the plot.  The bidding graphics have not changed.

The game play is exactly the same.  The Wampus is still there, the NPC players
SEEM to still play the same (altho I've only played 3 games so far).  It does
support 4 players with the remote satellite.

Unfortunately (and this is a first that I know of) there is a definite bug in 
the game.  The docs state that you must press the A button in order to get land
during the free land phase at the beginning of the turn.  This doesn't work for
the first piece of land.  If you press the B button, you can get that piece of
land, but no land on the other side of the river.  My husband thinks that you
need to press the A button repeatedly (not documented) but I have found that
sometimes pressing the B button works and sometimes repeatedly pressing the A
button works.  I'm very suprised at this; Nintendo's testing usually gets these
kinds of bugs out early in the QA process.

At any rate, for those of you who are M.U.L.E. fans from way back, I'd still
recommend the game.  Perhaps one day I'll write a full review of the game, but
this one is for comparison purposes only.

[this is not for reprint in any electronic digest without permission]

Lorini		use the addresses below for mail, please!
jennifer@jato.jpl.nasa.gov or elroy!jato!jennifer@csvax.caltech.edu
72466.3413@compuserve.com  Voice:(818) 354-8617
"Great Leaders are rare, so I'm following myself"