[news.groups] REC.RADIO.SHORTWAVE voting results: 265 yes, 10 no

rshapiro@BBN.COM (Richard Shapiro) (11/12/89)

Rec.radio.shortwave passes with a comfortable margin: 265 yes, 10 no.
In accordance with the guidelines, the complete list of votes appears
at the end of this article.

The distribution over time was as follows: 84% of the votes were cast
in the first week (including 9 of the 10 'no' votes); another 10% the
second week; and the rest dribbled in during the rest of the period.

I'm working right now on the getting the swl-l gateway set up.
Hopefully it will be in place not long after the group is created
(assuming no problems arise during the 5-day waiting period).

Thanks to everyone who voted.



YES votes

abj@ida.liu.se [Andreas Bjorklind]
adrian@cindy.altos.com [Adrian Jefferies]
ae201vk%prism@gatech.edu [V Kaladi]
allbery@ncoast.org [Brandon S. Allbery]
AllanWS@cup.portal.com [Allan W Schlaugat]
amb@cs.columbia.ed [Andrew Boardman]
amull@morgan.com [Andrew Mullhaupt]
arv@hcx.psu.edu [Appa Rao Vaddempudi]
as.mjp@forsythe.stanford.edu [Mike Peters]
austin@caen.engin.umich.edu [Richard Austin]
avr%mtgzx.att.com [Adam V Reed]
bakken@arizona.edu [Dave Bakken]
[bandy] capmkt!bandy@uunet.uu.net
bartsch@thor.acc.stolaf.edu [Eric A Bartsch]
bentrup@cs.uiuc.edu [John Bentrup]
bill@videovax.Tek.com [Bill McFadden]
bjslagt@cs.vu.nl [Bart J Slagt]
bjw@BBN.COM [Benjamin J Woznick]
bosslet@hpscad.enet.dec.com
bporn@finabo.abo.fi
brewer@ace.enet.dec.com [John Brewer]
brooks%csd4.csd.uwm.edu.uucp [Brooks Smith]
[bruceha] microsoft!bruceha@uunet.uu.net
broug@sloth.wimsey.bc.ca [Chris Brougham]
BUTLERC@mof.govt.nz [Chris Butler]
[carlo] electro!carlo@watcgl.waterloo.edu [Carlo Sgro]
castillo@media-lab.media.mit.edu [Brian C Anderson]
cerys@bbn.com [Dan Cerys]
chilcog@jacobs.cs.orst.edu [Greg Chilcote]
[childers] avsd!childers@ucbvax.berkeley.edu [Richard Childers]
chuckb%fluke.uucp [Chuck Bowden]
chuq@apple.com [Chuq von Rospach]
cmp7130@information-systems.east-anglia.ac.uk [Richard O'Neill]
conor@inmos.com [Conor O'Neill]
cook@pinocchio.encore.com [Dale Cook]
cosc6ud@uhvax1.uh.edu [Dwight Everhart]
csg@pyramid.pyramid.com [Carl S Gutekunst]
csshare@mtsu.edu [Brad ?]
dalex@eleazar.dartmouth.edu [Dave Alexander]
[dan] salt!china!dan@uunet.uu.net [Dan Williams]
danj1%ihlpa.att.com [Daniel Jacobson]
darcy@deceat.enet.dec.com [George Darcy]
[davel] vision!davel@relay.eu.net [Dave Lockwood]
daves@amc.com [Dave Schmidt]
dawar@linc.cis.upenn.edu [Anuj Darwa]
dbilar@antares.tymnet.com [Dave Bilar]
[deepak] hpda!hpindda!deepak@uunet.uu.net [Deepak S Sabnis]
defee@tut.fi
[dem] devil!dem%mead.uucp [Dave Myers]
dennett@cygnus.Kodak.COM [Charlie Dennett]
ddodell@stjhmc.fidonet.org [Dave Dodell]
dong@husc8.harvard.edu [Rui-Tao Dong]
doug@hokulea.hig.hawaii.edu [Doug Myhre]
DJCURT01%ULKYVX.BITNET
dross@cs.wisc.edu [Dan Ross]
dww@stl.stc.co.uk [David Wright]
Ed@alderaan.scrc.symbolics.com [Ed Schwalenberg]
eddjp%althea.uucp [Dewey Paciaffi]
edward@pro-harvest.cts.com [Edward Floden]
edwards@ncratl2.atlanta.ncr.com [Gordon Edwards]
egranthm@centec.COM [Ewan Grantham]
emv@math.lsa.umich.edu
erja@daimi.dk [Erik Jacobsen]
etxtsg@solsta.ericsson.se [Thomas Grennefors]
fair@apple.com [Erik E. Fair]
[fal] tuvie!fal@vexpert [Franz Lackinger]
[fel] hpda!hplabs!hpda!fel@uunet.uu.net [Skip La Fetra]
felix@ai.sri.com [Francois Felix]
[fireman] tippy!fireman@newton.physics.purdue.edu [Robert Dale]
[fjb] cbnewsl!fjb%att.att.com
fk00133r@uwasa.fi [Jari Perkiomaki]
flash@lopez.UUCP [Gary Bourgois]
FYSY@vax5.cit.cornell.edu [Don Drinkwater]
gary%sci34hub.sci.com [Gary Heston]
[gary] mrklund!gary@uunet.uu.net [Gary W Marklund]
gbh@dell.dell.com [Geoff Hoese]
gek@sun.com [Jerry Kreuscher]
gelato@astrosun.tn.cornell.edu [Sergio Gelato]
geoff@uunet.uu.net [Geoff Allen]
gmp@rayssd.ray.com [Greg Paris]
guncer%nunki.usc.edu@usc.edu [Selim Guncer]
HAGGT@finabo.abo.fi
hamlin@BLACKBIRD.AFIT.AF.MIL [Joe Hamlin]
HARTJ%WSUVM1.BITNET [Judy Hart]
HAVANAMOON@cup.portal.com
hbe@jato.jpl.nasa.gov [Harris Boldt Edelman]
heller@lewis.crd.ge.com [Aaron Heller]
henry@garp.mit.edu [Henry Mensch]
huopio@lut.fi [Kauto Huopio]
JACKSON%IUBACS.BITNET@uicvm.uic.edu
jak9213@TAMU.EDU [John Arthur Kane]
jay@splut.conmicro.com [Jay Maynard]
jburnell@kean.ucs.mun.ca
jeff@jato.jpl.nasa.gov
[jeffc] pyrdc!eliot!jeffc@uunet.uu.net [Jeffrey Chilton]
jejones%mcrware.uucp [James Jones]
jeremy@inmos.com [Jeremy Thorp]
jeuck@unix.sri.com [Philip Jeuck]
jim@rand.org [Jim Gillogly]
[jim] whuts!jim%att.att.com [Jim Malcolm]
[jim] sequent!jim%ursa-major.spdcc.com.uucp [Jim King]
jj@alice.att.com
jjc@unix.cis.pitt.edu [Jeffrey JB Carpenter]
jk3k+@andrew.cmu.edu [Joe Keane]
joeisham@attctc.dallas.tx.us [Joe Isham]
John_Braden@Stratus.COM [John Braden]
[johnc] sunriv!johnc@uunet.uu.net [John Crittenden]
jonathan@cs.ucla.edu [Jonathan Katz]
jpl@edison.cho.ge.com [Pim Little]
jstolzy@nrtc.northrop.com [Janice Stolzy]
jt@mentat.com [Jerry Toporek]
jusufgun@vondrake.cc.utexas.edu [Jimmy G. Jusuf]
[jwt] atari!jwt@ames.arc.nasa.gov [Jim Tittsler]
kannan@cis.ohio-state.edu [Kannan Varadhan]
katzmann@robotics.jpl.nasa.gov [Steve Katzmann]
kchen@apple.com [Kok Chen]
keegan@sungod.crd.ge.com [James G Keegan]
keenan%sal-sun47.usc.edu@usc.edu [Robert N Keenan]
kenji@jj1bdx.ampr.jp [Kenji Rikitake]
kim@uts.amdahl.com [Kim E DeVaughn]
kingdon@wam.umd.edu [John Kingdon]
[kirsch] gmdzi!kirsch@uunet.uu.net [Berthold Kirsch]
kjl%atexnet.uucp [Ken Lebowitz]
kkelly@elbereth.rutgers.edu [Kevin Kelly]
klee@wsl.dec.com [Ken Lee]
km3t%jjmhome.uucp [ D Pascoe]
lakhani@en.ecn.purdue.edu [Salim Lakhani]
larry@lut.fi [Lauri Toropainen]
lear@net.bio.ne [Eliot Lear]
levin@BBN.COM [Joel B Levin]
liuzzo%ihlpl.att.com [James G Liuzzo]
lrj@fibercom.com [Larry Johnson]
lsefton@apple.com [Laurie Sefton]
lyndon@cs.athabascau.ca [Lyndon Nerenberg]
mac@harris.cis.ksu.edu [Myron A Calhoun]
MACNUTT%RCN.BITNET [Glenn MacNutt]
[marc] infmx!marc@apple.com [Marc Kenig]
markt@wpi.wpi.edu [Mark Robert Tsombakos]
marr-leon@YALE.EDU [Leon T Marr]
maybee%pogo.wv.tek.com [Joe Maybee]
mbates@tusun2.mcs.utulsa.edu [Mike Bates]
mbn@fpssun.fps.com [Mike Northam]
mcb@ncis.tis.llnl.gov [Michael C Berch]
mcnamee%hpspkla.uucp [Mike D McNamee]
mcw%wet.uucp [Martin Warnett]
mike%kc5n.uucp
mitchell@community-chest.mitre.org [George Mitchell]
mjallen@stl.stc.co.uk [Matthew Allen]
[mjeanf] lopez!mjeanf@sharkey.cc.umich.edu
mjh%mvuxd.att.com [Mark Miller]
mjw@neon.stanford.edu [Michael Wolverton]
mkc@squid.graphics.cornell.ed [Mitch Collinsworth]
morganh%shazam.wv.tek.com [Morgan Hall]
mosley@peyote.cactus.org [Bob Mosley III]
mrm@puffin.sun.com [Marianne Kreuscher]
msmith@topaz.rutgers.edu [Mark Robert Smith]
na@cunixa.cc.columbia.edu [Nicole Adaniya]
nan@lancelot.avalon.cs.cmu.edu [Nan Ellman]
newsadm@pioneer.arc.nasa.gov
nieuwendijk%agrt06%rcl.wau.nl [Robert van den Nieuwendijk]
nimalr@ecse.rpi.edu [Nimal Ratnayake]
[njs] scifi!njs@uunet.uu.net [Nicholas J Simicich]
[nrt] scifi!nrtpc!nrt@uunet.uu.net [Nicholas R Trio]
[oltman] motcid!ivory!oltman@uunet.uu.net [Bruce Oltman]
parnass%ihuxz.att.com [Robert S Parnass]
patta@cs.sfu.ca [T. Pattabhiraman]
paul@urbana.mcd.mot.com [Paul Jones]
[paulk] convex!paulk@uxc.cso.uiuc.edu [Paul Kalapathy]
pbhx@tank.uchicago.edu [Peter B Hayward]
peper1@unix.cis.pitt.edu [J Christian A Peper]
peraino@gmuvax.gmu.edu
pete%indep1.uucp [Peter Franks]
pete%ittg.uucp [Pete Sherwood]
peter@ms.washington.edu [Peter Guttorp]
phd_jacquier@gsbacd.uchicago.edu [Eric Jacquier]
[philr] radian!philr@cs.utexas.edu [Phil Riba]
piet@cs.ruu.nl [Piet van Oostrum]
plh@raybed2.msd.ray.com [Paul Hilcoff]
polo%ihlpm.att.com [Mark B Colosia]
poynton@sun.com [Charles A Poynton]
[preacher] lopez!preacher@sharkey.cc.umich.edu
[psmith] convex!psmith@uxc.cso.uiuc.edu [Presley Smith]
pswecker@med.unc.edu [Peter St.Wecker]
rae@gpu.utcs.utoronto.ca [Reid Ellis]
rajiv@ee.rochester.edu [Rajiv Arora]
ralph%lzfme.att.co [Ralph Brandi]
randy@m2xenix.uucp [Randy Bush]
rayan@cs.toronto.edu [Rayam Zachariassen]
rbm%mozart.att.com [Rob Murray]
rcj@caen.engin.umich.edu [Rod Johnson]
rfc@philabs.philips.com [Robert Casey]
rfm@sun.com [Richard McAllister]
rh%well.uucp [Robert Horvitz]
ritz@decwrl.dec.com [John Ritz]
rk76073@tut.fi
rick@pavlov.bcm.tmc.edu [Richard H. Miller]
rja@edison.cho.ge.com
rliyanap@kean.ucs.mun.ca [Ranjith Liyanapathirana]
rmz@ifi.uio.no [Bjorn Remseth]
rod@apollo.com [Rod Owen]
roskos@ida.org [Eric Roskos]
ROSS@mscf.med.upenn.edu [Andy Ross]
rph@sq.sq.com [Pontus Hedman]
rsk@boulder.colorado.edu [Rich Kulawiec]
RSMITH@macc.wisc.edu [Rusty Smith]
rub@aerospace.aero.org
rwlee@ebay.sun.com [Ron Lee]
s_dowman@leaf.enet.dec.com [Steve Dowman]
saaf@joker.optics.rochester.edu [Lennart Saaf]
sac@apple.com [Steve Cisler]
sachin@uivlsi.csl.uiuc.edu [Sachin Sapatnekar]
samson@mipos2.intel.com
savage@dg-rtp.dg.com [Ed Savage]
schinder@astrosun2 [Paul Schinder]
schvan@nmsu.edu [Roger Schvaneveldt]
scott@clmqt.marquette.mi.us [Scott Reynolds]
seth@vax.ftp.com [Seth D Hollub]
sewilco@datapg.mn.org [Scot E Wilcoxon]
shamma@ccu.umanitoba.ca [Walid Chamma]
shari@wpi.wpi.edu
shep@ALLSPICE.LCS.MIT.EDU [Tim Shepard]
[simon] vision!simon@relay.eu.net
sivagnan@handel.cs.colostate.edu [S. Vasanthan]
sjk%WLBR@wlv.imsd.contel.com [Steven Kafka]
SLF@stl.stc.co.uk [Steve Fagg]
smackey@rads32.dayton.ncr.com
soomre@books.enet.dec.com
sp@pro-palace.cts.com [Sten Peeters]
spectre@unix.cis.pitt.edu [Robert Sillett]
springer@dsad.nac.dec.com [Kent Springer]
[st] unhd!st@uunet.uu.net [Sriram]
stan%floyd.att.com [Stan King]
stoppani@slough.enet.dec.com [Pete Stoppani]
stuart@apollo.com [Stuart Troutman]
sundar@hpsrad.enet.dec.com [Ganesh Sundaresan]
switzer@amelia.nas.nasa.gov [George F Switzer]
[swll] portal!cup.portal.com!SWLL@Sun.COM [Christine]
taber@pstjtt.enet.dec.com [Patrick Taber]
tenspeed%fluke.uucp [Jim Ehrmin]
tgt@amine.ecn.purdue.edu [Conan the Librarian]
thompson@BBN.COM [William Thompson]
[thorob] ima!thorob%auto-trol.uucp [Thornton Roby]
thumper@clmqt.marquette.mi.us
tim@attdso.att.com [Tim J Ihde]
tjk%csd4.csd.uwm.edu.uucp [Thomas Krueger]
tjw@unix.cis.pitt.edu [Terry J. Wood]
tl53529@tut.fi [Llyttyniemi Tapio]
Todd.Kaufmann@nl.cs.cmu.edu
tom@mims-iris.waterloo.edu [Tom Haapanen]
tomf%tekigm2.men.tek.com [Tom Flynn]
tuttle@mdaali.cancer.utexas.edu [David C. Tuttle]
urlichs%smurf.uucp@nisc.nyser.net [Matthias Urlichs]
versto%cs.vu.nl.uucp [C Verstoep]
victor@vondrake.cc.utexas.edu [Victor Menayang]
wales@cs.ucla.edu [Rich Wales]
walt@portia.stanford.edu [Walter Garcia-Fontes]
wheeler@ucunix.san.uc.edu [Dan Wheeler]
wright@mdcbbs.com [Dave Wright]
wtm@bunker.uucp [Bill McGarry]
xberri@arecibo.aero.org [Priv Berri]
zawada@en.ecn.purdue.edu [Paul J Zawada]
702WFG%SCRVMSYS.BITNET [Bill Gunshannon]
76703.407@compuserve.com [Scott Loftesness]
8243274@wwu.edu [S Lee Odegard]
8431827@max.acs.washington.edu [Erik Larsen]
 




NO votes

blob@apple.com [Brian Bechtel]
fwar1%pyuxv.uucp [Frank Warren]
harrism@dg-rtp.dg.com [Mike Harris]
howard@dahlbeck.ericsson.se [Howard Gayle]
[hsu] unisoft!hsu [Jeffrey Hsu]
jad@dayton.dhdsc.mn.org [J Deters]
jrp%rducky.uucp [Jim Pickering]
matthew@cs.ucla.edu [Matthew Merzbacher]
michaelk%copper.wr.tek.com [Michael D Kersenbrock]
pgraham@wyse.com [Philip Graham]

geoff@pmafire.UUCP (Geoff Allen) (11/15/89)

Before anyone gets too worked up,

	>geoff@uunet.uu.net [Geoff Allen]

is a vaild vote.  It's from me, but I'm not at uunet.  My real address
is geoff@pmafire.uucp or uunet!pmafire!geoff.

The From: line in our mail gets screwed up somewhere.  It seems to leave
here OK, but who knows what happens in the mysterious world known as
e-mail!

-- 
Geoff Allen                  \  Driggs, Idaho -- cultural hub of the west!
{uunet|bigtex}!pmafire!geoff  \
ucdavis!egg-id!pmafire!geoff   \  (Tom Harper in rec.skiing)

dww@stl.stc.co.uk (David Wright) (11/15/89)

In article <48092@bbn.COM> Richard Shapiro <rshapiro@BBN.COM> writes:
#Rec.radio.shortwave passes with a comfortable margin: 265 yes, 10 no.

Thanks for this timely reminder of how much simpler and better things are
when you *do* take the trouble to agree the name before the vote!   At one
stage the 'swl' group had all the possibilities of a big name controversy,
but Richard & Co took note of the discussion and suggestions and then put
to the vote the above sensible name, which has now deservedly got a very
positive result.

--
Regards,    David Wright       STL, London Road, Harlow, Essex  CM17 9NA, UK
dww@stl.stc.co.uk <or> ...uunet!mcvax!ukc!stl!dww <or> PSI%234237100122::DWW
Living in a country without a written constitution means having to trust in
the Good Will of the Government and the Generosity of Civil Servants.