emv@math.lsa.umich.edu (Edward Vielmetti) (09/02/90)
[this has also been sent to news.announce.newgroups] comp.text.sgml has passed, 137 to 13. this is a mass acknowlegement. the group will be created soon. I hope to work out a mailing list arrangement etc. once the dust has settled. the text of the original call for votes follows, slightly edited. ...the newsgroup 'comp.text.sgml', to discuss the ISO 8879 'Standard Generalized Markup Language', systems which use it, markup languages, and structured documents in general.... Substantive discussions about SGML and related issues are going on in 'comp.text' right now. The text of the original call for discussion can be fetched from the site "sgml.math.lsa.umich.edu" in the directory "/pub/sgml". There's also a brief bibliography of SGML courtesy of Robin Cover, and I hope to put more documents & software there as they become available. Details: the name: comp.text.sgml. It will be a challenge to draw in sufficient expertise in this area to make for good discussion. My sense is that a group that was concerned just with "structured documents" in some nebulous sense would not generate the quality of discussion needed to get SGML experts to be interested. the discussion: one initial task, already started, is to figure out who it is exactly who is using SGML and what purposes they are putting it it. Somewhat to my surprise, I've discovered an ANSI committee (X3V1.8M) charged with the missions of creating SGML document type definitions for hypermedia/time-based documents ("Hytime") and a Standard Music Descrption Language (SMDL). Who knows what all else is out there, but if the group gets going I'm pretty sure that SGML stuff will appear out of the woodwork. another goal on my list is to bring together people who have texts that they have marked up, or are marking up, and to figure out reasonable strategies for doing this. I have a couple of large collections of text (mostly old netnews articles and old e-mail) which I'd like to mark up in some sensible way for further analysis. the alternatives: comp.text is more or less the newsgroup of choice these days for SGML, with roughly one article in 5 referring to SGML in some way. That's not a great enough density to attract the small number of SGML experts who don't have time to wade through postings about troff macros, scanners, or Japanese TeX and non-linear glue. there is no mailing list devoted to SGML. Questions about it, and other information which would be appropriate to comp.text.sgml, are scattered around in a bunch of different lists and newsgroups. I expect to selectively quote from these other lists at the start of the group to try to draw the discussion in. the scope of the discussion: there are other standards for encoding structured documents, including ODA, the ISO Office Documents Architecture. There is the possibility of a certain tension between proponents of these two standards. The applications that I personally have in mind for my needs would seem to fit SGML better than ODA. So, when I started agitating about this group a few months ago ODA never crossed my mind. I would hope that 'comp.text.sgml' would be broad enough to encompass both the picayune details of SGML and the more general issues of document structuring. There are limitations to SGML which will be made apparent by successful uses of ODA, and vice versa. I expect the group to be able to handle intelligent discussion of both. the best thing about standards: there are so many to choose from followups to comp.text (put SGML in the Subject) or news.groups for procedural matters. Edward Vielmetti, U of Michigan math dept <emv@math.lsa.umich.edu> comp.text.sgml ISO 8879 SGML, structured documents, markup languages yes votes 137 "richard_busch.sd"@xerox.com ab@cerc.wvu.wvnet.edu akindele@loria.crin.fr alberta!oha!tony andrew@brownvm.brown.edu andrews@b.psc.edu andy%maximus.uucp@uunet.uu.net andy%mks.uucp@watmath.waterloo.edu anita@tnoibbc.ibbc.tno.nl anne.brueggemann-klein%ruf.uni-freiburg.dbp.de@relay.cs.net ath@prosys.se beck@cs.cornell.edu bill_von_hagen@transarc.com bin@primate.wisc.edu blarsen@usit.uio.no bob@rel.mi.org bobs@sco.com bowe@osf.org bporter@world.std.com brennan@dg-rtp.dg.com brown%dlogics.uucp@uunet.uu.net cape%ncrcis%ncrnd3.stpaul.ncr.com.uucp@relay.cs.net cargo@cherry.cray.com caywood@teb.larc.nasa.gov chenevoy@loria.crin.fr chip%tct.uucp@uunet.uu.net chuckp%bach@uunet.uu.net cjoslyn@bingvaxu.cc.binghamton.edu cooker@rice.edu craig@gpu.utcs.utoronto.ca cso@cis.ohio-state.edu curt%stingray%mead%uccba%decuac%cvl%mimsy%uunet.uucp@mailrus.cc.umich.edu dalamb@qucis.queensu.ca danny@turing-institute.ac.uk david.wright@stl.stc.co.uk david@twg.com dgil@pa.reuter.com dja%cyber%mead%uccba%decuac%cvl%mimsy%uunet.uucp@mailrus.cc.umich.edu djbpitt@unix.cis.pitt.edu drlewi1@dublin.pacbell.com dupuy@hudson.cs.columbia.edu dwood@watdragon.waterloo.edu edb@fairport.eng.ileaf.com efreeman@iuvax.cs.indiana.edu eibo@fbihh.informatik.uni-hamburg.de el407011@brownvm.brown.edu emcguire@cadfx.ccad.uiowa.edu ericb@libdev.dartmouth.edu erik@naggum.uu.no fendt%ecrc.de%ames%sharkey.uucp@umich.edu gamiddleton@watmath.waterloo.edu george@hyper.lap.upenn.edu gil@banyan.banyan.com gja@capgsb.be glenn@ila.com goer@sophist.uchicago.edu greg@cheers.uop.edu gregb%warlock1.uucp@uunet.uu.net gvr@cs.brown.edu harlanb%zelda.sandiego.ncr.com@relay.cs.net hin@tnoibbc.ibbc.tno.nl hwt@bnr.ca jac@paul.rutgers.edu jbarnes@cis.ohio-state.edu jcs@gvlv3.gvl.unisys.com jds@cs.umd.edu jfm@ux.acs.umn.edu jht@suned1.nswses.navy.mil jkp@cs.hut.fi john@minster.york.ac.uk josh@osf.org jsl@barn.com justin@lspsun1.epfl.ch kgilders%ncrcis%ncrnd3.stpaul.ncr.com.uucp@relay.cs.net koontz@alpha.bldr.nist.gov kreed@enh.nist.gov lac@ecs.southampton.ac.uk lane%umt.uucp@apple.com lees@frith.egr.msu.edu leilabd@syma.sussex.ac.uk lou%vax.oxford.ac.uk@pucc.princeton.edu lwv27%cas@pucc.princeton.edu lynne_price.parc@xerox.com marc@txsil.lonestar.org marichal@fan.gipsi.fr mark@drd.com mattf@cac.washington.edu mckay@prc.unisys.com mcs@iris.brown.edu mmac@pegasus.com muller@phoenix.src.umd.edu nathan%kelly%vitec.uucp@uunet.uu.net nhess@us.oracle.com nxh%kamikaze%mead%uccba%decuac%cvl%mimsy%uunet.uucp@mailrus.cc.umich.edu oc@vmp.com oyang@bruce.cs.monash.oz.au oz@nexus.yorku.ca paul@uxc.cso.uiuc.edu pekka.nikander@ngs.fi philippe.louarn@irisa.fr pk@tut.fi plaut%sc2a.unige.ch@pucc.princeton.edu prc@erbe.se ram%claude.cs.umb.edu@relay.cs.net randy@m2xenix.psg.com raymond%tpubs2.cambridge.ncr.com@relay.cs.net rdkeys@ccvr1.cc.ncsu.edu rft@sdimax2.mitre.org richard%net.ebt.anrj.br@uicvm.uic.edu rmackenz%cipc1.dayton.ncr.com@relay.cs.net rmm%unidot.uucp@uunet.uu.net robin@txsil.lonestar.org samg@savant.uchicago.edu spqr@ecs.southampton.ac.uk steff%adler.philosophie.uni-stuttgart.de@relay.cs.net steinar.haug@elab-runit.sintef.no stripes@eng.umd.edu stuart@orac.hq.ileaf.com sylvain@cli53an.edf.fr teexdwu@ioe.lon.ac.uk tom%scocan.uucp@uunet.uu.net tozer%esseye.uucp@uunet.uu.net tvf%ccird2%cci632%rochester.uucp@harvard.harvard.edu twl@cs.brown.edu utdoe!lubo utdoe!tak vanover@atc.boeing.com var@iris.brown.edu wayne@teemc.tmc.mi.org wnp%cossun%iiasa.uucp@relay.eu.net worsch%ira.uka.de@relay.cs.net wpg@mendel.acc.virginia.edu wsk@hpclpa.corp.hp.com wwm%pmsmam.uucp@umich.edu xanthian%zorch.sf-bay.org%ames%sharkey.uucp@umich.edu xxuu475@frio.chpc.utexas.edu No votes: ado%elsie.uucp@ncifcrf.gov bruce@sonyd1.broadcast.sony.com foster@sequoia.cray.com jjc%jclark.uucp@relay.eu.net john%basho.uucp@cis.ohio-state.edu kedgar@alliant.backbone.uoknor.edu lee%sqarc.sq.com%uunet%mailrus.uucp@umich.edu mitchell@community-chest.mitre.org morris@casee.enet.dec.com psrc@mtunq.att.com root%quark.wv.tek.com@relay.cs.net rps@decvax.dec.com thomas@topaz.jpl.nasa.gov