[comp.edu] Graduate School Admissions questions?????????

erspert@athena.mit.edu (Ellen R. Spertus) (04/07/90)

1. Preparing for the GREs will be one of the most worthwhile things
you can do (in terms of getting into graduate schools), in that one
afternoon of study will make a big improvement.  You will want a book
of actual practice CS tests (usually must be ordered from ETS) and a
book on preparing for it.  I hadn't taken algorithms at the time, so
knowing that I needed to know which sorts were O(n^2), etc., and having
a table to memorize, was a big help.  Start looking for a subject test
book early, because most bookstores don't carry them, and you may have
to order it by mail.

Also, prepare for the general GRE.  If you have any brains at all, 
math will be no problem.  You should practice at the analytic section
because it's entirely unlike the SAT.  An hour or so at old analytic
problems will greatly improve your actual score.  If you want to review
for math and English, I'd recommend the Princeton Review guide.

You should take the GRE by October.  This is preferred over December.
If you don't sign up early, you may not get your first choice
location.

2. I don't think it hurts to have worked.  I just visited grad
schools, and several of the other prospectives had been in industry.
(We had all been accepted at this point.)

3. Apply for fellowships.  Schools ask which you've applied for.
Apply for NSF, ONR, Hertz, and any others you qualify for (i.e. I
don't know if you're a minority).  If your company will pay, let them
know that.  If the application form doesn't have a slot for that,
write it where it asks what fellowships you applied for.

4. Have people read over your statement of purpose, etc.  If at all
possible, get a faculty member somewhere to do so.  I was told that
most applicants shoot themselves in the foot in their statement of
purpose, although I was not told in what sense.  If you can't consult
a faculty member, ask people who have been admitted to the appropriate
schools to show you their statements.  You can solicit these on the net.
People have been extremely willing to show me their statements, and
I found it helpful.

5. Be careful about recommendations.  References from professors in
nontechnical subjects aren't taken very seriously (at least at MIT).
Professors are preferred over supervisors.  You should have at least
one professor or possibly two.  (Because I'm straight out of college,
I only had one non-professor.)  Most places require three
recommendations, but some (like the NSF) require four.  You have
several months to cultivate some references.  If your old professors
remember you, and if it's possible, go and talk with them in person to
refresh their memory of you.  Ask them far in advance for references.
I know several people who have gotten burned on references, because
the professor left town or blew them off.  Give your referees stamped
addressed envelopes, etc.  It's considered okay to ask a potential
referee, "I'd like to get a recommendation from you.  Do you feel that
you can write me one or that I should get one from someone else?"
Recommendations from TAs are taken less seriously than those from
professors.  If you aced a class and only the TA knows you, see if
it's possible for him/her to speak to the professor and have the
professor write the recommendation.

6. Yes, publish some papers if at all possible.  The whole point of
the GRE, GPA, etc., is to serve as an indicator of how good of
research someone could do.  Having the real thing to show them is even
better.

					Ellen Spertus

swsh@carom.uchicago.edu (Janet M. Swisher) (04/10/90)

About recommendation letters:

An acquaintance of mine who has been Director of Graduate Admissions of the 
CS dept. of a mid-sized midwestern university once told me that he considered
glowing recommendations from professors he had never heard of to be better
than average recommendations from big shots in the field.  If you are the best
student that Joe Faculty has ever had, it says a lot more about you than if
you did OK in Mr. Famous' class of 300 students. Of course, if you are the best
student Mr. Famous ever had, that's best of all.

Keep in mind though, that this is one person's experience, and other admissions
people may be more easily impressed by flash.

(Please excuse sexist references; most CS faculty, especially big-shots, are
currently men.)


Janet Swisher