[comp.dcom.modems] problems: MNP & uucico? HELP!

root@vijit.UUCP (Dave Madsen) (08/18/88)

HELP!  I have a MultiTech MultiModem 224E that I'm considering buying (it's
on loan from Inland for two weeks).  It's performed well so far but now I'm 
trying to talk to Ohio State (osu-cis aka cis.ohio-state.edu) to get some
GNU stuff.  The connection there through the Micom switch is going through 
Racal-Vadic modems which support Class 3 MNP.  The 224E that I have supports
Class 5.  

The connection is made, my modem blinks its 2400 light indicating that MNP
is active.  I request the GNU button as a test.  The session ALWAYS hangs
(no, not hangs up -- just hangs) at the same point, when 1536 bytes have
been received in the T* file.  

I have heard that MNP and uucico do not get along together, but it seems to
me that that shouldn't be true since MNP is at the "hardware" level below
the "awareness" of uucico.  Can someone expound on this?

I called MultiTech technical support and they said that my switch settings
as well as the parameters I send to the modem are correct.  The ECM1 PROM
level is 5.06 in the modem (which I was told is a few revs behind but
is still ok).  

Could someone please help me on this?  I talked to a comm person at OSU who
said that since the connection is made and the conversation always hangs
at the same point that it probably isn't any modem problem but perhaps a
protocol problem.  Although I agree, I still can't see anything else
wrong.  The only speculation I have is that one of the modems is buffering
something or losing data (erroneously identified as flow control, perhaps?)
so that uucico is getting confused.

Oh, BTW, I tried turning off MNP via the &E0 parameter.  When I do that,
I get x's and vertical bars and other goop instead of the first "Ohio State..."
message.

** PLEASE E-MAIL **.  If you want to post as well, that's fine, but I'm behind
on news and would almost certainly miss any relevant postings.

Thanks again (and in advance) for ANY tidbits of information ANYONE has!

If anyone wants to call me on the phone, feel free; I'm at either
(312) 425-2529 or (312) 954-6512.

Dave Madsen   ---dcm

gargoyle.uchicago.edu!vijit!madsen


Here's the -x9 listing from a session with osu-cis.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

finds called
getto called
call: no. 16142923124 for sys osu-cis Dial 16142923124
dc - /dev/cul99, acu - /dev/cua99
dcf is 3
Sending initial ATZ
buffer=

buffer=OK

Sending ATE0
buffer=ATE0

buffer=OK

Sending AT &D3 &S2 &E3 &E7 &E8 &E10 &E12
buffer=

buffer=OK

Sending AT $BA0 S25=10 S10=12 S9=8
buffer=

buffer=OK

Sending AT F1 Q0 B1 X4 V1 M1 &C1 S7=60
buffer=

buffer=OK

Dialing... ATDT16142923124
buffer=

buffer=CONNECT 2400

Speed: want 4800 use 14 ps 6
Forked 600 Wait got 600 Status 0
dcr returned as 3
login called
start in send mode
 sent <<cr>>wanted <Name> REMOTE returned <^M^J^@^@The^ Ohio^ State^ University^M^J^@^@Hosts^ are^ TSO,^ WYLBUR,^ CMS,^ DEC20,^ LCS,^ FS^@^M^J^@^@Host^ Name>--ok
 sent <osu-cis><cr>>wanted <RETURN> REMOTE returned <?^ ^G^@osu-cis^M^J^@^@REMOTE^ ACCESS^@^M^@^@^@^@^@^@^J^@^@^@^@^@^@On^ GO^ hit^ RETURN>--ok
 sent <@><cr>>wanted <GO> REMOTE returned <^ twice^M^@^@^@^@^@^@^J^@^@^@^@^@^@Connected^ to^ 03/091(B)^M^@^@^@^@^@^@^J^@^@^@^@^@^@GO>--ok
 sent <@><cr>>wanted <in:> REMOTE returned <^G^M^@^@^@^@^@^@^J^@^@^@^@^@^@A^M^Jlogin:>--ok
 sent <Uanon><cr>> enter us_sst, status is : 11
 Enter us_open, file: /usr/lib/uucp/L_stat
 normal return from us_open.c
 s.sysname : osu-cis
 enter ub_sst, status is : 0
Rmtname: osu-cis
 Enter us_open, file: /usr/lib/uucp/L_sub
 normal return from us_open.c
 imsg < Uanon^M^JUNIX System V Release 3.0 AT&T 3B2^M^Josu-cis^M^JCopyright (c) 1984 AT&T^M^JAll Rights Reserved^M^J^P<
Shere=osu-cis-omsg-<Svijit -Q0 -x9>imsg <^P<
ROK-msg-ROK
 Rmtname osu-cis, my Role MASTER,  Spool - /usr/spool/uucp
Ifn - 3, Ofn - 3, Loginuser - root
rmesg - 'P' imsg <^P<
Pge-got Pge
wmesg 'U'g
omsg-<Ug>send 73
rec h->cntl 73
send 61
state - 1
rec h->cntl 61
send 53
state - 3
rec h->cntl 53
state - 10
Proto started g
protocol g
 enter us_sst, status is : 09
 Enter us_open, file: /usr/lib/uucp/L_stat
 normal return from us_open.c
 s.sysname : osu-cis
*** TOP ***  -  role=1, wrktype R, User - root
wrktype - R,  fileno - 6
wmesg 'R' /u/public/button88.02.ps
send 210
send 220
rmesg - 'R' rec h->cntl 41
state - 10
rec h->cntl 42
state - 10
rec h->cntl 177612
send 41
got RY 664
 PROCESS: msg - RY 664
RCVFILE:
rec h->cntl 177622
send 42
rec h->cntl 177632
send 43
rec h->cntl 177642
send 44
rec h->cntl 177652
send 45
rec h->cntl 177662
send 46
rec h->cntl 177672
send 47
rec h->cntl 177602
send 40
rec h->cntl 177612
send 41
rec h->cntl 177622
send 42
rec h->cntl 177632
send 43
rec h->cntl 177642
send 44
rec h->cntl 177652
rec h->cntl 177672
bad header 53,h->ccntl 165
rec h->cntl 177652
send 25
rec h->cntl 177662
send 46
rec h->cntl 177672
send 47
rec h->cntl 177602
send 40
rec h->cntl 42
state - 10
rec h->cntl 177612
send 41
rec h->cntl 177622
send 42
rec h->cntl 177632
send 43
rec h->cntl 177642
send 44
rec h->cntl 177652
send 45
rec h->cntl 177662
send 46
rec h->cntl 177672
send 47
rec h->cntl 177602
send 40
rec h->cntl 177612
send 41
rec h->cntl 177722
bad header 177623,h->ccntl 145
rec h->cntl 177602
rec h->cntl 177602
rec h->cntl 177602
rec h->cntl 177602
rec h->cntl 177602

***** This is where the session hangs.  I manually hang up the modem at
this point because it seems pointless to continue. *****