[comp.dcom.modems] Comments on Digicom V.32 modems

wtm@uhura.neoucom.EDU (Bill Mayhew) (05/28/91)

(By the time I could reply the orginal article expired; apologies)


We have eight rack-mount Digicoms in a Digicom rack in our computer
room.  The modems themselves work pretty well; about as well as
could be exptected.  The basic functional block, not surprisingly,
is the Rockwell V.32 chip set daughter board.  The rack models
respond to "AT" commands over the serial interface, or may be
programmed from the front panel of the rack.  The rack sports four
arrow cursor keys and an enter key.  Choices are displayed on a 16
character non-backlit LCD display.

There are a lot of nice creature features on the modems.  The
modems have a modular data access arrangement.  When the modems are
pulled out of the rack or fail, the DAA automatically busies out
the line; this prevents callers from droppeing into a black hole
caused by an out-of-service modem on an incoming telco rotary.  There
is also a programable inactivity timer that can cut off idle users
and the "AT" command set may be disabled from the front panel so
that users can not alter the set-ups.  The modems are supposed to
be hot-swappable so that you don't have to shut down the entire
rack just to service one modem -- I have my doubts about the hot
swappablility; I wouldn't do it.

What I don't like about Digicom is that the rack is pretty sleezy.
They just used a basic Bud brand or similar open-rail rack with
just left and right side panels.  As such, the rack is much too
flimsy.  When our rack arrived, the slightest vibration would cause
the modem DAAs to lose connection with the modems and cut off
users.  I adjusted the rails a little and got the rack to where it
is fairly stable, but finally had to bolt the rack down to a
separate modular shelf for mounting in out 19" cabinet.  There is
no excuse for such a flimsy design.  Other racks such as Ven-tel or
Telebit are much more rugged.

Overall, the modems look good, but the rack looks pretty lousy.
Based on performance, the external stand-alone modem would probably
be a good choice.  We've got some on order; time will tell.

Bill


-- 
Bill Mayhew      NEOUCOM Computer Services Department
Rootstown, OH  44272-9995  USA    phone: 216-325-2511
wtm@uhura.neoucom.edu   ....!uunet!aablue!neoucom!wtm
via internet: (140.220.001.001)