[comp.ai] Laming on Sensory Analysis: BBS Multiple Book Review

harnad@mind.UUCP (06/10/87)

The following is the abstract of a book that will be multiply reviewed in BBS
[Behavioral and Brain Sciences -- An international, interdisciplinary
Journal of Open Peer Commentary, published by Cambridge University Press].

Self-nominations by potential reviewers/commentators are invited. Please note
that the editorial office must exercise selectivity among the nominations
received so as to ensure a strong and balanced cross-specialty spectrum of
eligible commentators. The procedure is explained after the abstract.

-----

                      SENSORY ANALYSIS

                       Donald Laming
           Department of Experimental Psychology
                  University of Cambrdige
                 Cambridge CB2 3EB ENGLAND

                        ABSTRACT


     Sensory analysis is that initial, preconscious stage of
     perception  at  which features (edges, temporal discon-
     tinuities, and periodicities) are picked out  from  the
     random  fluctuations  that  characterize  the  physical
     stimulation of sensory receptors. Sensory analysis  may
     be  studied by means of signal-detection, psychometric-
     function and threshold experiments, and my  book,  SEN-
     SORY  ANALYSIS, presents a succinct, quasi-quantitative
     account of the phenomena revealed thereby. This account
     covers  all  five  sensory  modalities, emphasizing the
     similarities between them.

     A succinct account depends on identifying simple  prin-
     ciples  of wide generality, of which the most fundamen-
     tal are that (a) sensory discriminations are  differen-
     tially  coupled  to  the  physical stimuli and that (b)
     small stimuli are subject  to  a  square-law  transform
     which makes them less detectable than they would other-
     wise be. These two principles are established  by  com-
     parisons   between   different  configurations  of  two
     stimulus levels to be discriminated; they are  realized
     within  a  simple physical-analogue model which affords
     certain low-level comparisons  with  neurophysiological
     observation. That physical-analogue model consists of a
     sequence of elementary operations on the stimulus  con-
     stituting  a stage of sensory processing.  The concate-
     nation of two of three stages in  cascade  accommodates
     an  increased  range  of  experimental phenomena, espe-
     cially the detection of sinusoidal gratings.

     My BBS precis is organized in three parts: Part I  sur-
     veys SENSORY ANALYSIS as economically as may be, begin-
     ning from the  simplest,  most  fundamental  ideas  and
     working  towards  phenomena of increasing complexity. A
     rather short Part II reviews the most important  alter-
     native  models  addressed  to some part or other of the
     phenomena surveyed. Finally, a very short Part III con-
     tributes  some metatheoretic remarks on the function of
     a theory of sensory discrimination.

-----

This is an experiment in using the Net to find eligible commentators
for articles in the Behavioral and Brain Sciences (BBS), an
international, interdisciplinary journal of "open peer commentary,"
published by Cambridge University Press, with its editorial office in
Princeton NJ.

"Eligibility" usually means being an academically trained professional
contributor to one of the disciplines mentioned earlier, or to related
academic disciplines. The letter should indicate the candidate's
general qualifications as well as their basis for wishing to serve as
commentator or reviewer for the particular target article or book in
question. It is preferable also to enclose a Curriculum Vitae. (This
self-nomination format may also be used by those who wish to become BBS
Associates, but they must also specify a current Associate who knows their
work and is prepared to nominate them; where no current Associate is known
by the candidate, the editorial office will send the Vita to
approporiate Associates to ask whether they would be prepared to
nominate the candidate.)

Potential commentators/reviewers should send their names, addresses, a
description of their general qualifications and their basis for seeking to
review this book in particular to the following USmail or Email address:

			Stevan Harnad, Editor
			Behavioral and Brain Sciences
			20 Nassau Street, Room 240
			Princeton NJ 08542
			(phone: 609-921-7771)
{seismo, psuvax1, bellcore, rutgers, packard}  !princeton!mind!harnad
harnad%mind@princeton.csnet     harnad@mind.princeton.edu
-- 

Stevan Harnad                                  (609) - 921 7771
{bellcore, psuvax1, seismo, rutgers, packard}  !princeton!mind!harnad
harnad%mind@princeton.csnet       harnad@mind.Princeton.EDU