[comp.ai] Explanations for Qualitative Reasoning systems?

joungwoo@mensa.usc.edu (John Kim) (04/20/91)

Hello,

	Now that qualitative reasoning (QR) shaped up as a concrete
branch of AI, I would like to know what AI folks' opinions are on the following
question:

	"Do thesedays QR systems lack of proper explanation (or
	justification) of their reasoning?"

If yes,
	"Could this problem be solved by a good explanation framework for
	expert systems? Or should a one for QR systems differ?"

	(When I say "a good explanation framework", I imply it has high level
	concepts like goal, causality, explicit generic problem solving
	strategy, etc. built in to it.)

If an explanation framework for QR systems should differ from those for
expert systems, 
	"In what ways should it differ? And why?"


All comments and opinions would be appreciated and I will post the summary of
the responses I get.

Clarifying questions to me are also welcome.


Joung-woo John Kim
Computer Science Department
University of Southern California
U. S. A.


-- 
Joung-woo John Kim
Computer Science Department
University of Southern California
U. S. A.