[news.misc] Time ordering on news messages

phs@lifia.UUCP (04/04/87)

.
   I am using "rn.c,v 4.3.1.4" and  I am  very  annoyed  each time I read a
message, an answer to which I have just  finished reading.  

   I am   sure that there  are   VERY GOOD reasons  why  messages cannot be
transmitted in the exact order they have been sent.  But when  I (or rather
my site) have received  some of them,  why cannot "rn" propose  them in the
correct order, where   "correct order"  does  not necessarily refer to  the
exact time they have been posted, but may just be a partial order, possibly
based on referenced messages, something like "if mess1 contains a reference
to mess2, and if we have received  mess2, then propose mess2  before mess1"
(note that the ordering of messages may depend on when you read them).

   It seems that such a simple scheme, while not  solving everything, would
remove ALMOST ALL disagreements related to that problem.


- Does there exist a news software which solve the problem ?

- Is there another solution (i.e. other  than changing the  software) ? How
do you handle the problem ?

- Can someone post a survey about the "good reasons" (for our education) ?


(Probably this problem has already been much debated, but then I missed the
discussion,  and  would like  to   hear  the pros  and   cons.  Note that I
redirected follow-ups to news.software.b.)

Thanks,
--
Philippe SCHNOEBELEN,
LIFIA - IMAG,  BP 68                           UUCP : ...mcvax!imag!lifia!phs
38402 Saint Martin d'Heres, FRANCE

"Algebraic symbols are used when you do not know what you are talking about."