rjg@sialis.mn.org (Robert J. Granvin) (06/08/88)
After following the entire original postings and resulting flood of followups, I would say that the only "victor" in this was JJ himself. Consider the following: We have two rounds of postings that supposedly originated from the same person. This person posted a ridiculous article that a lot of people took almost excessively negative. These postings "at least" utilized the crossposting feature which is designed for some measure of efficiency. If the poster had not crossposted, he would have had to do more work, but then you would have literally seen the article all over the place. Since those simple postings, the following has occurred: - The net at large has been extremely vocal about the incident, screaming and flaming publicly. This has resulted in: - Significant increased volume in the groups affected. - More discussion based on previous discussion, causing a nice, sometimes vicious loop, thereby increasing volume again. - "JJ" receiving a great deal of personal attention. - Certain public access sites have been verbally attacked, complete with suggestions that they be totally cut off electronically from the net. This has resulted in several subitems: - Attacks against a select number of public access sites that charge for services and include usenet access in that charge. - Attacks against users of those same sites who are trying to explain to the net at large what services they actually receive from the site, or perhaps just defending it. - Article forgeries intended solely to fuel the fires further: - Encouraging additional flames, discussions and followups, as well as increase anger and aggravation resulting solely in increased net traffic on the subject by trying to convince the reader that the source was actually "JJ". - Name, address and phone number were posted, "subliminally" encouraging the reader to enact harrassment, all of which could provide the recipient with enough reason and evidence to file charges in reverse...: - Mailing letters with postage due. - Making harrassing phone calls during obnoxious hours of the night. - A number of letters a phone calls have undoubtedly be sent to the postmaster in Lincoln in complaint against "Rob Noha". This release of the users name raises one very serious question, and one secondary question: - Has it been confirmed, beyond a doubt, that "JJ", on Portal is indeed Rob Noha? Is it entirely impossible that "JJ" did not provide the name of someone in Lincoln rather than his own? If Rob Noha provided a charge account number to pay for his Portal net access, there is definate proof to support the allegation of his identity, unless the charges were charged against a card whose account number has been stolen. - Do we know for certain that "Jayorr" on ncoast is again the same person and not a copycat? There are others... So, in retrospect, I would say that "JJ" has most probably reached or exceeded his goals. This type of person is not concerned about losing net access, but probably revels in creating and fueling a great deal of attention which centers around himself. I'm sure that even the money issue wasn't one. If he actually got some, I'm sure he would just laugh at all the "suckers" who took him seriously. What this type of person generally wants is attention. Congratulations. He got it. -- "I've been trying for some time to Robert J. Granvin develop a life-style that doesn't National Information Systems, Inc. require my presence." rjg@sialis.mn.org -Garry Trudeau ...uunet!{{amdahl,hpda}!bungia,rosevax}!sialis!rjg