[news.sysadmin] Why are news articles separate file

cball@ishmael (09/06/88)

Since no one else has mentioned it, there is a system that keeps "news"
in a database.  It is called notes.  Notes is an independant development
that was derived from the PLATO system originated by CDC.  Notes was
written by Ray Essick at the University of Illinois.  The latest full
release I've seen was 1.7 and was released in early 1985.  Rich Saltz
distributed some changes to support moderated notesfiles around 1986
when he worked for Mirror Systems.  I've heard very little about it
recently.

The notes user interface is somewhat different from news.  The major
benefit to notes is that it organizes articles in "notestrings".  Each 
string consists of an original article(note) and its responses.  This
feature makes it easy to either ignore or closely follow a discussion.
This combined with access control mechanisms makes notes superior for
internal corporate project communication. 
	The biggest loss is that cross-postings cannot be maintained as
simple links, the entire article must be stored in each topic's database.
Notes also has apparently not been in active development recently, so
it doesn't support features such as similar to news' kill lists, nntp,
etc.
	There are other differences, but I'm not sufficiently familiar
with news to elaborate much further.  The major point is that if you
want to store news articles in a database format, you should start with
notes or at the least take a careful look at it before re-engineering
news.  Personally, I'd rather see the notes user interface ported to
news than the reverse.

	Charles Ball
	cball@inmet