[news.software.b] Path/From lines

sanand@sp90.uucp () (08/13/90)

	>Newsgroups: to.sp90
-------->Path: sp90!sp90.uucp!sanand
	>From: sanand@sp90.uucp ()
	>Subject: testpath
	>Organization: Sanand Patel
	>Sender: sanand@sp90.uucp

Can someone help me track down where my PATH line is generated. The problem
is that (I assume) it should read:

	Path: sp90!sanand  or
	Path: sp90.uucp!sanand
but not
	Path: sp90!sp90.uucp!sanand.

I am running Cnews. The path is OK before "inews", but somewhere after,
the header gets broken.

The contents of mailname and whoami are:

sp90.uucp
sp90

Thanks.
Sanand
(sp90!sanand -- not sp90!sp90.uucp!sanand)

henry@zoo.toronto.edu (Henry Spencer) (08/14/90)

In article <1990Aug13.162742.2031@sp90.uucp> sanand@sp90.uucp () writes:
>Can someone help me track down where my PATH line is generated. The problem
>is that (I assume) it should read:
>
>	Path: sp90!sanand  or
>	Path: sp90.uucp!sanand
>but not
>	Path: sp90!sp90.uucp!sanand.
>
>I am running Cnews. The path is OK before "inews", but somewhere after,
>the header gets broken.

Uh, why is there a Path before inews at all?  For normal news postings,
inews should be generating Path for you.  Only in specialized situations,
like gatewaying of mail to news, should there be a Path line in the input
to inews.  That is the problem:  inews sees the Path line, says "hmm, he
must know what he's doing", and leaves it alone, passing the article to
relaynews, which does what it's supposed to do and prepends the local
host name to Path.  You need to look *before* inews and figure out where
that "sp90.uucp!sanand" is coming from.
-- 
It is not possible to both understand  | Henry Spencer at U of Toronto Zoology
and appreciate Intel CPUs. -D.Wolfskill|  henry@zoo.toronto.edu   utzoo!henry

cudep@warwick.ac.uk (Ian Dickinson) (08/16/90)

In article <1990Aug14.153657.18531@zoo.toronto.edu> henry@zoo.toronto.edu (Henry Spencer) writes:
>In article <1990Aug13.162742.2031@sp90.uucp> sanand@sp90.uucp () writes:
>>Can someone help me track down where my PATH line is generated.

>Uh, why is there a Path before inews at all?  For normal news postings,
>inews should be generating Path for you.  Only in specialized situations,
>like gatewaying of mail to news, should there be a Path line in the input
>to inews.  That is the problem:  inews sees the Path line, says "hmm, he
>must know what he's doing", and leaves it alone, passing the article to
>relaynews, which does what it's supposed to do and prepends the local
>host name to Path.  You need to look *before* inews and figure out where
>that "sp90.uucp!sanand" is coming from.

It's certainly was there on recent (pl40 upwards, but not pl47?)
versions of rn/rrn.

The Pnews.header includes it for nntp posting, giving:

news-host!nntp-posting-host!user

I just removed the Path definition in Pnews.header because I want
to 'site hide' anyway.

Of course, if sanand isn't using rn, sorry.
--
\/ato.  Ian Dickinson.    GNU's not got BSE.    When I grow up I want to be a
vato@cu.warwick.ac.uk          Plinth.          Water Elemental.   Shower me!
vato@tardis.cs.ed.ac.uk        Sabeq.         
gdd046@cck.cov.ac.uk                          "Nuke me tender, nuke me good!"

sanand@sp90.uucp (08/18/90)

Writes cudep@warwick.ac.uk (Ian Dickinson)

>In article <1990Aug14.153657.18531@zoo.toronto.edu> henry@zoo.toronto.edu (Henry Spencer) writes:
>>In article <1990Aug13.162742.2031@sp90.uucp> sanand@sp90.uucp () writes:
>>>Can someone help me track down where my PATH line is generated.
>
>>Uh, why is there a Path before inews at all?  For normal news postings,
>>inews should be generating Path for you.  Only in specialized situations,
>>like gatewaying of mail to news, should there be a Path line in the input
>>to inews.  That is the problem:  inews sees the Path line, says "hmm, he
>>must know what he's doing", and leaves it alone, passing the article to
>>relaynews, which does what it's supposed to do and prepends the local
>>host name to Path.  You need to look *before* inews and figure out where
>>that "sp90.uucp!sanand" is coming from.
>
>It's certainly was there on recent (pl40 upwards, but not pl47?)
>versions of rn/rrn.
>
>The Pnews.header includes it for nntp posting, giving:
>
>news-host!nntp-posting-host!user
>
>I just removed the Path definition in Pnews.header because I want
>to 'site hide' anyway.
>
>Of course, if sanand isn't using rn, sorry.
>--

I am using Pnews directly. I have yet to succesfully get nn to post an
article (working on it).