[comp.unix.questions] TALKing to another user

moonunit@meteor.wisc.edu (Chris Bovitz) (03/06/91)

I've been trying to use talk to talk to someone on another system,
but something's wrong.  When I type "talk user@address", I get the
standard "[No connection yet]", but then it shows "[Checking for 
invitation on caller's machine]" and hangs there ad infinitum.
She has set her messages off.  I've even tried "talk user@address tty".

Is this normal?  I'd assume that if a user doesn't want messages,
it would say on the sender's machine.  

Any comments would be most welcome.


Chris
-- 
          |  Chris Bovitz              |  Late to bed,              |
          |  moonunit@meteor.wisc.edu  |  Early to rise,            |
          |  Univ of WI-Madison        |  Makes a man               |
          |  :-) :-) :-)  (-: (-: (-:  |  Damn tired come noon.     |

kepowers@mbunix.mitre.org (Powers) (03/07/91)

In article <1991Mar6.050511.13981@meteor.wisc.edu> moonunit@meteor.wisc.edu (Chris Bovitz) writes:
>
>I've been trying to use talk to talk to someone on another system,
>but something's wrong.  When I type "talk user@address", I get the
>standard "[No connection yet]", but then it shows "[Checking for 
>invitation on caller's machine]" and hangs there ad infinitum.
>She has set her messages off.  I've even tried "talk user@address tty".

That depends on the type of machines that are involved.  There are two
types of talk protocals that are not compatible.  For instance,
Ultrix and SunOS cannot 'talk' to each other.  Unfortunately, talk
does not realize that an incompatability exists and it just keeps
trying.  

-- 
Kelly-Erin Powers		The MITRE Corporation
Unix Systems Group		Burlington Road
(617) 271-2143			Bedford, MA 01730
kepowers@mbunix.mitre.org	linus!mbunix!kepowers

jik@athena.mit.edu (Jonathan I. Kamens) (03/07/91)

In article <1991Mar6.161028.25932@linus.mitre.org>, kepowers@mbunix.mitre.org (Powers) writes:
|> That depends on the type of machines that are involved.  There are two
|> types of talk protocals that are not compatible.  For instance,
|> Ultrix and SunOS cannot 'talk' to each other.  Unfortunately, talk
|> does not realize that an incompatability exists and it just keeps
|> trying.  

  Elaborating a little bit: Some machines have both versions of talk
installed.  If "talk" doesn't work for you, try "ntalk", "otalk", "talk.old"
and "talk.new" if any of them are available.

  If none of them are available and work, then you lose.

-- 
Jonathan Kamens			              USnail:
MIT Project Athena				11 Ashford Terrace
jik@Athena.MIT.EDU				Allston, MA  02134
Office: 617-253-8085			      Home: 617-782-0710