[sci.electronics] The RAMSEY FM-10 STEREO TRANSMITTER KIT REVIEW

flash@lopez.UUCP (Gary Bourgois) (03/27/91)

                          WB8EOH Gizmo Report
                              (Very Long)
 
The Ramsey FM-10 is a low power FM stereo transmitter kit that is easy 
to build and has many practical applications around the home and 
ham/swl shack.  After living with one for several weeks, I could never 
go back to life before I acquired this little "freedom machine".  The 
audio quality and stability of the signal give the unit many HI FI 
type applications, and indeed I am already planning to buy another 
unit to patch into the Audio/Video system.
 
             Egad, you mean you have to BUILD this thing?
 
When my XYL saw that this package I had spent fifty bucks on consisted 
of a couple of polyethylene bags full of plastic bugs and little 
metalic button like pieces, she shook her head in dismay.  Though I 
tinker with computer and radio gizmos all day long, I will admit that 
the past 20 years have seen me become an "appliance operator" more 
content to sit back and PLAY than get in there and tear into the 
circuitry, much less build something from scratch.  Well, the folks at 
Ramsey have honed the art of kitbuilding, and even a klutz like me CAN 
have the satisfaction (like in the old Heath ads) to say "I built it 
myself".  
 
Constructing the FM-10 was in part a happy trip down memory lane.  In 
my distant youth, one of my happiest memories was the construction and 
operation of an Allied Radio Knight Kit #83Y706 three tube AM Phono 
Oscillator.  This wonderful little gadget paved the way not only for 
my interest in Ham radio, but also got me interested in broadcasting, 
a field which put bread on the table for many years.  Well in the more 
than 30 years between the two kits, things sure have changed.
 
First right off, don't even think about dragging out the old Weller 
soldering gun and the old roll of Kester solder.  First thing I had to 
do was borrow a low wattage iron, and get some super thin solder.  The 
Lifetime Supply of solder I bought in 1968 (five pounds) was fine for 
antenna work, and gobbing up audio connectors, but the old stuff is 
actually WIDER than many of the separate connections on the FM-10 PC 
board.  EGAD these components are TINY.  
 
Kudos to Ramsey for the way their whole concept.  The manual is very 
well written.  My only problem was I did not get the companion booklet 
on how to build a kit (the generic HOW TO SOLDER book).  Well I hoped 
that the instructions that came with my 1957 Knight Kit still applied, 
because I remember them.  Heat the component, don't glob it all over 
the place, and try not to melt the PC board.  I was on my own to 
develop a technique.  Ramsey even takes this into account by having 
you mount some of the larger "landmark" components first, namely three 
RCA jacks (left and right audio and the antenna jack).
 
Now I wanted this thing to work.  I would not be able to face Elaine 
if it became necessary to send the completed unworking mess back to 
Ramsey for their $18 an hour bail-you-out plan.  So I took absolutely 
extrordinary steps.  With a (borrowed) digital meter, I measured every 
resistor, even though Ramsey gives the color code for each one in the 
manual as you install it.
 
One of the nicest touches is the GIANT print of the PC board, upon 
which you place all the components in the same place they will go in 
the final kit.  I did this with most of the components, except for the 
multitude of .01 capacitors, which I left neatly together (Ramsey 
uses a masking tape type type medium for keeping similar value 
components together).
 
The scariest moment for me was soldering in the 18 pin DIP socket that 
houses the heart of the kit, a ROHM stereo transmitter on a chip.  We 
are talking TEENY TINY little pins separated by seeming microns.  
EGAD.  After each dot of solder, I held the PC board a quarter inch 
from my eyeballs to make sure there were no solder bridges.  And I 
measured all the components with the Digital meter a second time 
before installing each one.  You probably won't take these 
extrordinary steps, which make the simple kit an all night project.
 
But it was a FUN night.  The scent of melting tin/led/rosin... The 
occaisional absolutely PERFECT joint...  Kitbuilding is not only an 
art, it is positively a cosmic experience.  It is relaxing, creative, 
and there is the anticipation of all the wonderful things you will do 
with your kit upon completion.
 
3:25AM
 
Ah.  The moment of truth.
 
Connect the nine volt battery, push the power switch, and TUNE around 
on the FM radio to find the carrier.
 
And I found.......
 
NOTHING.
 
It did not work.
 
Now this is where we separate the men from the boys.  How well you 
manage not to throw the thing through the window.
 
So I went back through the whole manual.  checked EVERY joint.  
Eyeballed EACH component.  I could find NOTHING wrong.
 
Elaine came into the shack as I was holding the PC board.  I hated to 
admit defeat.  But I told her it did not work.... yet.
 
She held the board and looked at it with wonder.  She could not 
believe that I had placed each of the little parts in their places.  
She told me I would figure out what was wrong with it.  
 
The next day, I went through the manual again.  I took voltage 
measurements, and found all the proper voltages on the chip and RF 
amplifier.  I was stymied.
 
Then I looked very closely at the OTHER side of the board.  I stared 
at the ROHM chip, which Elaine had called a "train trestle".  Hmmm.  I 
wonder if I pushed on the chip if it would go in any farther.
 
Push.  Click.  It snapped into place.
 
I pushed the power switch, turned on the FM radio, and found a nice 
clean carrier at 102.3, with the stereo light blazing away in pure 
clear silence.
 
Hot DAWG it WORKS!
 
First thing I did was to move the frequency.  Since it was 
transmitting on top of one of the local stations, this seemed in 
order.  Ramsey's manual stresses the importance of selecting a clear 
channel so as not to bring the wrath of neighbors and the FCC.  Up 
here in the boonies, there is a tremendous clear swath from about 98 
Mhz to 102 mhz.  (I plan to pouplate it).
 
The next thing required is adjustment of the subcarrier frequency and 
stereo balance.  Surprisingly mine was already right on for the 
subcarrier adjustment, and I found out that this adjustment is 
actually pretty critical.  There is a test point if you have a freq 
counter to get it exactly on 19khz, but it can be done by just turning 
the little variable capacitor until the stereo light goes on.
 
The "stereo balance" control takes a bit of explaining.  This is not a 
simple LEFT-RIGHT adjustment, but actually adjustment of the level of 
left MINUS right.  It is more of a separation adjustment, and also 
seems to have a real effect on tonal quality.  It took quite a bit of 
diddling to get it right, and there seems to be some interaction 
between the two controls, as the stereo light will go out just when 
you think you have the sound right...  The end result is a surprising 
quality signal with amazing separation.  However, one thing to make 
note of...  The RM-10 is designed with NO audio level controls.  This 
is a bit of an oversight, because when using it with components that 
have fixed level output, the unit is prone to overmodulation.  You 
MUST be able to lower the audio level of whatever it is you are 
feeding to the tranmitter, as it is too sensitive with EVERY component 
I tried connecting direct.  Once you get the level under control, 
though, it actually sounds better than many local FM stations because 
the signal is not run through all sorts of "Enhancers" that 
broadcasters use to be the loudest thing on the band.  I did find 
though that adding an audio limiter (an old DBX 119) really helped 
tame the overmodulation problem.
 
I finished the project by mounting it in the $12.95 Ramsey Kit 
cabinet.  OK, this is where the Ramsey guys make a few bucks.  It does 
give the kit a finished look, but I would have to say that this is a 
bit dear for a simple plastic case.   I think the next one will be 
built into a VIDEOTAPE plastic case or other cheapo cabinet.
 
One oversight is that there is no hole in the cabinet for the whip 
antenna which mounts to the circuit board.  Ramsey suggests 
constructing a dipole or groundplane antenna, which I did initially in 
the final installation in my hamshack.  I have since stopped using 
this antenna however (more on why later)
 
             OK NOW WHAT CAN I DO WITH THIS LITTLE GADGET
 
Ramsey gives many practical applications in the manual.  I found the 
unit handy for listening to MDS stereo TV on a little sony walkman in 
the wee hours without having to run headphone cords.  Remote listening 
of ANYTHING on your main stereo system in any room in your home by 
just tuning the radio is just ONE thing the kit can be used for.
 
My own application is a bit unique.  I have the FM-10 in my ham/swl 
shack, and it is connected to a stereo mixer, to which I have several 
receivers patched in.  I am a communications junkie and often in the 
shack I listen to several things at once.  The only problem is that 
one can not stay in ones hamshack all day long.  Well with the FM-10 
and a pocket stereo receiver, you can monitor whatever you wish in 
your home or yard.  Now since the Ramsey Kit is a STEREO transmitter, 
you can do what I do (if you are insane enough)  I have a 2 meter rig 
on the LEFT channel, scanner on the RIGHT channel, and the HF rig 
panned dead center.  The ears and the brain manage to sort it all out. 
I feel sorry for any of the neighbors who happen to tune in when in 
this configuration (when I am in my active monitoring mode).  
 
               No Code, No License, No Kidding It's LEGAL
 
Now speaking of neighbors, lets focus for a moment on the LEGALITY of 
using this kit under part 15 of the FCC rules.  In 1989, the FCC 
revised part 15, changing the way the measurements are taken to 
determine if a device is legal.   The new standard is: 250 microvolts 
per meter.  A calibrated Field Strength Meter is needed to make sure 
the signal complies with this regulation (FCC rule 15.239).  Beyond 
this, part 15 requires that the unit produce no interference to 
licensed stations.  Basically those are the rules.  What you put on 
the device is YOUR business.  It comes under the same type of 
regulation as cordless phones, baby monitors, and walkie talkies.  the 
only difference is that this unit operates in a BROADCAST band rather 
than a semi-hidden part of the spectrum like the others.
 
The Ramsey manual has a chart that shows that even if one complies 
FULLY with this measurement, the transmitter has a surprising range. 
Doing the math of the inverse square law, we find that there is still 
.41 microvolts at 5000 feet from the transmitter, nearly a mile.  
Since the Ramsey kit has a FINAL AMPLIFIER, it is much more powerful 
than a similar kit sold by another manufacturer which uses the chip 
output only (that one can be heard well within only 20 feet).  I found 
that the kit with a dipole antenna cut to the operating frequency has 
TOO MUCH range for my own use.  Those who wish to "Play DJ" might be 
interested in running the recommended dipole antenna (making CERTAIN 
they make the Field Strength Measurement) to get the maximum range out 
of the unit.  I found that just a small piece of wire gives me all the 
coverage in my home that I need. 
 
For someone interested in providing a broadcast type service, to a 
college dorm, appartment complex or local neighborhood (Legally the 
signal can be quite loud over a quarter mile away) It can be legally 
done under part 15 of the present FCC rules (as ammended in June of 
1989) by simply adding a mixer, microphone, and sound sources to the 
Ramsey Kit.  
 
An application I am considering is connecting the audio output of my 
new satellite system and tuning it to the BBC audio feed and just 
leave it run that way when I am not using the dish for other purposes. 
This way I can enjoy BBC in FM quality and so can my immediate 
neighbors.  Now before the flames begin, please remember that 
copyrights, etc, do not apply to part 15 transmissions.  You can put 
on ANYTHING you want.  Just as if you were listening on closed circuit 
speakers.  The only difference is that your immediate neighbors CAN 
also enjoy the transmissions as well.
 
FCC RULE 15.215(a) Says:  "Unless otherwise stated, there are no 
restrictions as to the types of operations permitted under these 
sections."  This general provision *APPEARS* to leave you free to use 
the fm transmitter for just about ANY type of operation you desire, 
including becoming a "legal low power broadcaster".
 
Now the nitty Gritty:
 
     RAMSEY FM-10 FM STEREO TRANSMITTER KIT
 
     Price:  Circuit Board and Components -- $29.95 
             Cabinet (black plastic)      -- $12.95
 
     Shipping add 6%.
 
                          Ramsey Electronics
                          793 Canning Parkway
                           Victor, NY 14564
 
                        (716) 924-4560 (Voice)
                        (716) 924-4555   (FAX)
 
    o  Operates from internal 9 volt battery
    o  Choice of onboard whip or external antenna
    o  Stable output, from 88 to 108 MHz
    o  Left and Right channel RCA line audio input jacks
    o  Use with Mixers, cassette or CD decks etc.
    o  Clear, step-by-step assembly instructions
    o  Helpful information on FCC rules included
 
    TYPICAL USES:
 
    o  Extension of home stereo system without wires
    o  Student-operated school radio station
    o  Home or neighborhood radio station
    o  College dorm favorite music broadcast service
    o  Listening aid for auditoriums, churches
 
 
 
NOTE1:  I am in NO WAY affiliated with Ramsey Electronics other than 
        being one of their very satisfied customers.
 
NOTE2: If you plan to use the kit as a "broadcasting" service, I would
       STRONGLY SUGGEST you have the output level CERTIFIED by an 
       engineer assertaining for SURE it is no more than 250 
       microvolts per meter.  This kit has an almost amazing range,
       and I imagine it could very easilly exceed LEGAL SPECIFICATIONS
       if you are not careful.
 
       
 

-- 
=Marquette MI: It's Not the END of the world, but you can see it from here=
==  Gary Bourgois flash@lopez (rutgers!sharkey!lopez!flash)  GWN UPLink  ==
==  3.950  Nationwide Amateur Radio Nightly after 0200z=Learning Channel ==
=============== WB8EOH = The Eccentric Old Hippie = WB8EOH ================

randall@informix.com (Randall Rhea) (03/28/91)

I big thank-you to Gary for his outstanding review of the Ramsey FM
Stereo transmitter.

I too have built and used one.  Considering the price ($30.00), it is
a fantastic unit.

I have had the following problems:

1) I cannot get the thing to work on frequencies above 98 MHz.  You have
a choice of three capacitors to solder into the unit depending on the
frequency range you want.  Only the capacitor designed for the low end of
the band seems to work.

2) That little variable capacitor that controls the subcarrier is indeed
important.  You need to be very patient in adjusting this thing, or your
receiver's stereo light will not come on. 

3) Getting the transmitter tuned to exactly the right frequency is 
not easy.  You need a TV alignment tool and a lot of patience.  On
modern digital FM receivers, such as my car stereo, you will not get the
stereo light to come on unless you've got the transmitter tuned correctly.

4) Finding an open frequency in the SF area, or any large metropolitan
area, is very difficult.  This of course is not a problem with the 
transmitter, but it can reduce its usefulness.


I hooked the transmitter to a 2-meter ham J-pole antenna on the roof, 
and found that its range was about 1/2 mile.   If I built an antenna 
that was tuned to 88 MHz, I could probably increase its range.

-- 

=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Randall Rhea                                        Informix Software, Inc. 
Senior Programmer/Analyst, MIS                  uunet!pyramid!infmx!randall

flash@lopez.UUCP (Gary Bourgois) (03/30/91)

In article <1991Mar27.235352.17436@informix.com> randall@informix.com (Randall Rhea) writes:

>I big thank-you to Gary for his outstanding review of the Ramsey FM
>Stereo transmitter.

You be more than welcome....


>I have had the following problems:

>1) I cannot get the thing to work on frequencies above 98 MHz.  You have
>a choice of three capacitors to solder into the unit depending on the
>frequency range you want.  Only the capacitor designed for the low end of
>the band seems to work.

Mine is on 100.1, which used to be used here, but the station moved (to
add more power)  I used the capacitor supplied for the TOP of the band
(there are three to chose from, so do your research first before you
solder it in).  Mine came on at 102.3 so I had to tune it DOWN.  I think
your problem is probably just localized to your particular unit.  You
might try purchasing a replacement capacitor from radio shack.

>2) That little variable capacitor that controls the subcarrier is indeed
>important.  You need to be very patient in adjusting this thing, or your
>receiver's stereo light will not come on. 

Well like I said, MINE came on IN STEREO  (believe it or not) but you
have to tune it slowly because there is only 5% of the range of the
adjustment that works.  


>3) Getting the transmitter tuned to exactly the right frequency is 
>not easy.  You need a TV alignment tool and a lot of patience.  On
>modern digital FM receivers, such as my car stereo, you will not get the
>stereo light to come on unless you've got the transmitter tuned correctly.


I did not have a TV alignment tool and at 3:25AM no way to get one.  I
busted a tine of a plastic fork, and it worked PERFECTLY.  

I have noticed the following though:

The unit does drift slightly, and your antenna loads the tank circuit
somewhat.  Depending on which antenna I use, the unit will shift
frequency.  A bigger antenna puts the signal higher in the band.

>4) Finding an open frequency in the SF area, or any large metropolitan
>area, is very difficult.  This of course is not a problem with the 
>transmitter, but it can reduce its usefulness.

Well no such problem here.  We have only four stations, and they are all
horrible.  Now the RAMSEY is my FAVORITE local station (I am sure the
neighbors don't agree, since the format is so CHANGEABLE :-) 


>I hooked the transmitter to a 2-meter ham J-pole antenna on the roof, 
>and found that its range was about 1/2 mile.   If I built an antenna 
>that was tuned to 88 MHz, I could probably increase its range.

I started with the indoor ground plane, and loved the nice solkd signal
all over the house and yard.  UNTIL one of my ham friends a mile away
and over a hill said the signal was copyable on his ZENITH TRANS-OCEANIC
with indoor antenna.  This was during some weird weather, so that might
have had something to do with it, but I immediately made a smaller
antenna to keep the signal on my own block.  Now it is a little noisy in
the computer room on my walkman, but at least the FCC won't be trying to
find the location of the "weird" station, hi.  If I had a field strength
meter, and could verify that it was indeed 250 microvolts at one meter
away (I kinda think it was, but did not want to take chances)


-- 
=Marquette MI: It's Not the END of the world, but you can see it from here=
==  Gary Bourgois flash@lopez (rutgers!sharkey!lopez!flash)  GWN UPLink  ==
==  3.950  Nationwide Amateur Radio Nightly after 0200z=Learning Channel ==
=============== WB8EOH = The Eccentric Old Hippie = WB8EOH ================

phil@ux1.cso.uiuc.edu (Phil Howard KA9WGN) (03/31/91)

A friend of mine is interested in using one of these FM transmitter kits to
transmit over a small area.  I want to make sure that whatever frequency I
set him up on (I have a couple possible in mind that seem to be clear enough)
is very stable.  What I am wondering is if any kits are made like this but
based on a better frequency reference, like a crystal.
-- 
 /***************************************************************************\
/ Phil Howard -- KA9WGN -- phil@ux1.cso.uiuc.edu                              \
\ Lietuva laisva -- Brivu Latviju -- Eesti vabaks                             /
 \***************************************************************************/

barry@mothra.rose.hp.com (Barry Fowler) (04/09/91)

Gary,

Guestimating, what frequency response would you say the FM
transmitter has?  Is it anything near the quality of the sound
one would hear on an FM broadcast station or less?

I've been interested in this one too in order to receive, through my
outside antenna/good receiver and re-transmit long distance stations
around my lot out here (max. distance around 400 feet).

barry


 
  ----------------------------------------------------------------------
  
  Barry M. Fowler                        Hewlett Packard Company

  Networked Computer Manufacturing Operation - Roseville, California
  (can't we think of a shorter name?)

  e-mail:  barry@mothra.rose.hp.com
  Verbal:  Hey Barry!
  R.F.  :  WB6JZL
  NAR   :  51644