[comp.sys.mac] Recovering Disks: Query

jdm@ut-ngp.UUCP (Jim Meiss) (05/07/87)

There was a message on INFO-MAC Digest 29 Apr 1987 Volume 5 : Issue 83
about recovering crashed disks which said:
>people report that when they try to recover from a crash,
>they get a message:
>
>                0 FILES in 0 FOLDERS found
>
>and every time the reason is that they had executed either MACTOOLS or FEDIT+
>and
>                MOUNTed !!!!
>                                        the disk.
>
>***** DO NOT DO THIS ****** IT DESTROYS VALUABLE DATA NEEDED FOR RECOVERY ****
>
Can someone explain the correct procedure to use?
I've tried to recover an HFS disk with MacTools 6.3 several times without
success. It seems to me that there are not many options, aside from "mounting"
the disk...

Which is the best program to use to recover HFS disks? I'm pretty upset with
the quality of MacTools. It seems to crash often and fail most of the time.

Any Thoughts?

					Jim Meiss
					jdm@ut-ngp.utexas.eduv

robertj@yale.UUCP (Rob Jellinghaus) (05/07/87)

In article <5153@ut-ngp.UUCP> jdm@ut-ngp.UUCP (Jim Meiss) writes:
>I've tried to recover an HFS disk with MacTools 6.3 several times without
>success. It seems to me that there are not many options, aside from "mounting"
>the disk...
>
>Which is the best program to use to recover HFS disks? I'm pretty upset with
>the quality of MacTools. It seems to crash often and fail most of the time.
>
>Any Thoughts?

There are several utilities that are far more useful than MacTools for
disk repair.  Here is a partial list:

	Disk First Aid, from Apple
		Very effective at repairing certain kinds of
		disk problems automatically.  Free from any
		public domain source.

	MacZap, from some company (sorry I don't know the name)
		This utility has been getting raves on the net
		recently.  It apparently works on both hard
		disks and regular floppies.  Fairly easy to use.

	Fedit Plus, again from a company whose name I don't know
		This is very powerful if you're willing to take time
		to learn about the details of Macintosh disk
		formats.  It's not as automated as MacZap or Disk
		First Aid, but some people think it's the best
		repair utility available.

These are some of the most popular ones around.  All of them should
be available from any Mac mail-order company, and all of them are
probably worth the less than $100 you'd pay for them.  (Except Disk
First Aid, which is free.)

Good luck!


---------------------------------------------------------------------
Robert Jellinghaus                |"We're on a road to nowhere...
That's my name, don't wear it out.| Yaaahh!"  -- THeads
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Jellinghaus@yale-celed.UUCP  **or**  ..something..!yale!jellinghaus
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Disclaimer (dis-klay'-mer) n.  A statement disclaiming something.
Disclaimer disclaimer: Definition taken from the _Oxford American
Dictionary_, Oxford University Press, New York, 1980.
Disclaimer disclaimer disclaimer:  No, I am NOT paranoid.
Why do you ask??  Maybe I could use another disclaimer!!!!!

(P.S.  I am NOT associated with any of the companies that produce the
software I mentioned above.  I apologize for not having the company
information as I wrote this posting.)