[comp.sys.mac] Perfect operation under Multifinder -- the sequel...

clive@drutx.ATT.COM (Clive Steward) (01/16/88)

Well, I have further good news, it seems.  Be sure to read through to the 
caveats, though.

With the following, I have perfect operation* with large bunches of
complicated applications, for instance, Hypercard, Superpaint 1.0sp,
Word 3.01, MacProject 1.2, and Macterminal 2.2.  I cut and paste big
chunks, run several viewable windows to visually trade information, etc.

Here's how it's set up to work:

	1)  Clean Desktop as before.
	2)  Applications re-set to normal out-of-the-box memory allocations
	   (MacProject doesn't have; it's happy at 150k, probably less)
	3)  Boot blocks set for no (0) additional System Heap space
	4)  Finder set for 220k allocation instead of the 160k default.

    * see caveats below...

The Finder setting seems consistent with the fact that, using the default
allocation instead, rebuilding the Desktop always fails to complete, with 
an alert message.  With extra memory, it completes fine.  I was running 180k,
which was better than 160, but 220 is what gives complete freedom from errors.
Somewhere between might work, don't know.

The reduction of System Heap allocation to the nominal seems to bring
further improvement, as well as give back 80k of memory.  Now, da's in the 
DA Runner layer seem to self-allocate as they're supposed to.  Not enough 
experience to know if it's perfect, but so far da's are just fine.

I'd originally increased the initial heap space because with a small 
extra (16k), many da's didn't seem to want to work, unless they were opened 
in an application's space.  It might be a 'near the boundary, but not over, 
so don't do anything' situation, and then the da used a little more, and 
crashed.  Don't know.  Curious, but neat when it works.  

Letting the system do what it's stated to want, it seems much happier.  


Now the caveats.

    1)  All of this may have something to do, of course, with the
    specific disk device driver for my MacBottom 45 meg disk, even
    the version I'm on, and about to change.  Programmer types
    will understand why.

    2)  I do get the perfect operation, for hours of really
    complicated work, and it's a joy.  Have you ever tried to put
    together a large project plan, without being able to look at
    word processor screens when constructing a Pert chart in
    Project?  I can't say enough for this, it's what I bought the
    original 128k Mac, and upgraded this far, to be able to use.

    Apple has brought something you can't touch, anywhere else.

    But.
    
    As soon as the Mac heats up, 1-2 hours in air-conditioned office, 
    half hour in overheated winter room, it's that close, something 
    starts letting go, and I get bombs within seconds or minutes 
    of startup, often on simple mouse movement (thus I suspect SCC 
    over-interrupting, overfilling a queue).  The funny thing is that 
    it still works perfectly without Multifinder, but again, other 
    programming/hardware types will see ways this could happen.

    So I have to get the Mac fixed, before it's assured that results
    so far are really valid.   I think they are, and that the heat
    problem is simply additional grief.  
    
    Have to see if I can arrange a trial swap.  This is what
    (established friendly) dealers are for.


Cheers,


Clive




Plus one more.  I have an even better running system now, by increasing 
the Finder allocation to 220k, and setting the boot blocks so that the 
System Heap is 0 over 'normal'.

It's absolutely error free, running 6 or seven complicated apps.
For an hour or two, until the Mac heats up.  When cool, it's good again.
Rats.

I will publish this, I guess, but with the caveat that the behaviour
just might be caused by whatever (I have reason to believe SCC) breaks
when hot.

I do believe, though, that the increased allocation is valid, since it 
prevents the 'Can't finish rebuilding Desktop' message.  Might be because 
I have a full 45 meg disk, or due to peculiarities of the disk device driver.

Well, now I have it essentially written, so guess I'll post.


Thanks, and good luck.


Clive

kaufman@Shasta.STANFORD.EDU (Marc Kaufman) (01/18/88)

In article <6473@drutx.ATT.COM> clive@drutx.ATT.COM (Clive Steward) writes:

-    As soon as the Mac heats up, 1-2 hours in air-conditioned office, 
-    half hour in overheated winter room, it's that close, something 
-    starts letting go, and I get bombs within seconds or minutes 
-    of startup, often on simple mouse movement (thus I suspect SCC 
-    over-interrupting, overfilling a queue).  The funny thing is that 
-    it still works perfectly without Multifinder, but again, other 
-    programming/hardware types will see ways this could happen.

-It's absolutely error free, running 6 or seven complicated apps.
-For an hour or two, until the Mac heats up.  When cool, it's good again.
-Rats.

-I will publish this, I guess, but with the caveat that the behaviour
-just might be caused by whatever (I have reason to believe SCC) breaks
-when hot.

Certain 8530s, notably those from Zilog, have a tendency to overheat and
go bonkers.  It takes only a very little air moving over them to fix the
problem.  The latest versions (e.g. AMD's 8530H and Zilog's 85C30) are
said to have this problem fixed.

Marc Kaufman (kaufman@Shasta.stanford.edu)