[comp.sys.mac] Liability of [benign] virus cre

rmf239@uxf.cso.uiuc.edu (03/24/88)

	I think you missed a major point here.  Your freeware utility Splatz
would have been downloaded by Joe Shmoe and he could(should) have tested it.
Also, Splatz would probably have a *gasp* Disclaimer, and a disclaimer is 
the legal tool (I think, I'm not a lawyer) to protect oneself against lawsuits
of this nature.  But, with virii he didn't have the option of testing this it
and wasn't given a disclaimer. 


B.Y.T.  Is this a new type of software ... Virii-ware :-)

 
--
Bob Frank 

Just another struggling undergrad.

chuq@plaid.Sun.COM (Chuq Von Rospach) (03/25/88)

>Also, Splatz would probably have a *gasp* Disclaimer, and a disclaimer is 
>the legal tool (I think, I'm not a lawyer) to protect oneself against lawsuits
>of this nature.  But, with virii he didn't have the option of testing this it
>and wasn't given a disclaimer. 

Disclaimers are primarily there to make you think you have no rights. The
courts have sometimes disagreed with it, depending on the severity of the
software's screwups. If, for instance, Splatz ate my hard disk for lunch and
laughed at me, causing me to lose a weeks' work and two major clients, no
disclaimer in the world would save you. On the other hand, if Splatz gave me
the option of deleting my hard disk, or allowed me to inadventantly cause a
head crash, with the same results, it's a lot more likely the disclaimer
would be upheld.

And something that comes walking in on another program unanncounced,
installs itself in my system, and then does something to me, that's rape.
I'm all for taking virii manufacturers and hanging them from trees. It might
discourage the next one.

chuq (hard line, yes. But virii do to computers what coke does to noses.
  String up both pushers....)
Chuq Von Rospach			chuq@sun.COM		Delphi: CHUQ

                               Speed it up. Keep it Simple. Ship it on time.
                                                            -- Bill Atkinson

snow@ndmath.UUCP (Dennis Snow) (03/28/88)

In article <46906@sun.uucp>, chuq@plaid.Sun.COM (Chuq Von Rospach) writes:
> I'm all for taking virii manufacturers and hanging them from trees. It might
                     ^^^^^
> discourage the next one.
> 
> chuq (hard line, yes. But virii do to computers what coke does to noses.
                            ^^^^^
>   String up both pushers....)
> Chuq Von Rospach			chuq@sun.COM		Delphi: CHUQ

I have seen this 'virii' one too many times. The plural of virus is
viruses.

Dennis Snow    snow@ndmath.UUCP
Dept. Math.    Notre Dame, IN 46556