[comp.sys.mac] Summary: TCP/IP and NFS for the Mac

dan@srs.UUCP (Dan Kegel) (08/06/88)

I recently asked the net for info about networking for the Mac SE, and
recieved many helpful responses.

There seem to be only two systems that let plain old Mac programs transparantly 
access files on a remote Unix fileserver:

1. TOPS, a proprietary network file system developed independantly 
   and later purchased by Sun; this has been available for some time.
   The only Unix box that TOPS currently runs on is the Sun-3.
   Either LocalTalk or Ethernet may be used to connect the Macs to the Sun.
   TOPS phone number is (800) 445-8677 or (415) 769-8700.
   System cost:
    Software:
     TOPS server on Sun ($900 for 1-4 clients, $1600 for 1-16 clients)
     TOPS client on Mac ($250 per client)
    Hardware:
     using LocalTalk: $50 per client + $2000 for the Kinetics Fastpath bridge
     using EtherTalk: $600 per client

2. Cayman Systems' Gatorbox, an NFS (Ethernet) to AFP (LocalTalk) bridge; 
   the box and software sell for $3495, and takes about 6 weeks to get.
   The Unix box must be running NFS (and most can; many are shipped with it).
   It links up to 32 Macs running Apple's network (AFP on LocalTalk) to 
   a standard Ethernet network.
   Cayman Systems' phone number is (617) 494-1999.
   System cost:
	$50 per client (for LocalTalk cable) + $3500 for the Gatorbox bridge

Other NFS systems, rumored but not currently available, are
3. University of Michgan had a client version of NFS for the Mac at last 
   years Sun Connectathon.  Don't think they ever fielded it.

4. Peter Honeyman (one of the authors of HoneyDanBer uucp?) led a project 
   that put tcp/ip and NFS on Macs, under contract to Apple.
   Apple has the software now; it's unclear when if ever they will release it.

LocalTalk is Apple's 200 kilobit/sec serial networking hardware, which
is quite slow compared with the 10 Megabit/sec Ethernet;
one might therefore expect to be able to connect up only five or ten Macs
per LocalTalk bus before seeing degradation, as opposed to fifty or so on an 
Ethernet bus.  (I've never tried it, so I dunno.)


There are also systems available that let TCP/IP aware programs communicate
with other machines on an Ethernet; this isn't as nice as transparant file
access, but it can be pretty darn useful.

1. Kinetics sells Ethernet boards for all versions of the Macintosh; it
   also sells a TCP/IP (Ethernet) to TCP/IP (Appletalk) bridge.

2. NCSA maintains a professional-looking TELNET package for the PC and the Mac
   which supports remote login, multiple VT102 emulation, Tek 4014 emulation,
   subnetting, and dynamic IP address assignment via RARP.
   I think this is shipped with Kinetics equipment.
   It is available for anonymous FTP over the Darpanet from 
   ftp.ncsa.uiuc.edu   (128.174.20.50).   Contacts listed on their blurb:
       Tim Krauskopf                timk@ncsa.uiuc.edu (ARPA)
       Gaige B. Paulsen             gaige@ncsa.uiuc.edu
       National Center for Supercomputing Applications (NCSA)
       University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign

3. Either Stanford or Columbia maintain something called KIP and CAP
   which seems to be another TCP/IP package; NCSA would know more about it.

4. Phil Karn's KA9Q package is another (public-domain?) TCP/IP implementation.

Thanks to everybody who replied.  I'm still looking for something that
supports NFS over Ethernet right to the Mac...
-- 
  Dan Kegel   "We had to get it passed before the columnists attacked!"
  srs!dan@cs.rochester.edu  rochester!srs!dan dan%srs.uucp@harvard.harvard.edu

winter@Apple.COM (Patty Winter) (08/06/88)

In article <944@srs.UUCP> srs!dan@cs.rochester.edu (Dan Kegel) writes:
>
>4. Phil Karn's KA9Q package is another (public-domain?) TCP/IP implementation.
					^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

For amateur radio and university research uses, yes. Otherwise, no.



Patty

=============================================================================  
Patty Winter N6BIS                        DOMAIN: winter@apple.com
AMPR.ORG: [44.4.0.44]                     UUCP: {decwrl,nsc,sun}!apple!winter
=============================================================================

root@sbcs.sunysb.edu (root) (08/06/88)

This is a bit tangential an answer to the original question "Who has
NFS on MacOS?".  For small machines there are NFS implementations
available for both the IBM PC and Amiga.  Sun sells PC-NFS for the
IBM PC - package price is ~$900.  Ameristar Technology sells NFS
for the Amiga - package cost also $900.  Since part of my time
is spent at Ameristar, I'll allow myself the luxury of giving
their phone number: (516) 698-0834.  You probably already know
how to contact Sun anyways :-).

				Rick Spanbauer
				Ameristar Technology


PS. I would like to hear from anyone who has a Gator Box.

falken@caen.engin.umich.edu (David R Falkenburg) (08/09/88)

In article <944@srs.UUCP>, dan@srs.UUCP (Dan Kegel) writes:
> 3. University of Michgan had a client version of NFS for the Mac at last 
>    years Sun Connectathon.  Don't think they ever fielded it.
> 
> 4. Peter Honeyman (one of the authors of HoneyDanBer uucp?) led a project 
>    that put tcp/ip and NFS on Macs, under contract to Apple.
>    Apple has the software now; it's unclear when if ever they will release it.

Here at university of michigan, we had been using (testing, etc.) the
CITI MacNFS.  Both 3 & 4 were the same project--  Honeyman was project
manager for both MacIP and MacNFS.

both products are now in apple's hands.

ALSO

didn't anybody mention CAP (specifically AUFS)?

it allows the unix box to act as an appleshare file server
with the advent of System 6.0's inclusion of AppleShare Client
this is a mostly free (with the exception of the kbox) alternative
to systems like tops.

-dave falkenburg
 university of michigan computer aided engineering network
 falken@caen.umich.edu
 umix!caen.engin.umich.edu!falken

karn@thumper.bellcore.com (Phil R. Karn) (08/11/88)

There has apparently been some confusion regarding the status of my
TCP/IP package. As it very clearly states when you bring it up, it is
copyrighted by myself. Although I have granted to noncommercial users
(including university and amateur radio groups) the right to use, copy
and modify it for free, this does not in any way diminish my other
rights under copyright, nor does it place the package into the public
domain.

I am well aware that my policy of openly publishing my sources makes it
much harder, as a practical matter, to keep commercial users from
abusing my copyright restriction. It has also probably diminished the
commercial value of the software.  However, very early on I decided
that, despite this risk, open publication was essential to maximize the
benefit to the amateur radio community for which the package is
primarily intended.

Although most of the code in the package is by myself, certain sections
have been contributed by other amateurs with the same understanding:
free for noncommercial use only.  The authors of these sections are
identified by comments in their respective source files.

I ask others to respect the wishes of myself and the other authors in
this matter. Thank you.

Phil Karn, KA9Q

minshall@kinetics.UUCP (Greg Minshall) (08/14/88)

Just to add a bit to the list, Kinetics has recently announced
a "TCPort Toolkit", which includes TCP/IP support for the Mac
(installed as drivers) and a programming library to interface to
the drivers (and a "socket emulation" library).  It isn't available
until October or so (I haven't seen the announcement).  (In addition,
there is a separate product with telnet, ftp, etc.)

Greg Minshall					Kinetics
...ucbvax!mtxinu!kinetics!minshall		(415)947-0998