[comp.sys.mac] Mac Plus Memory Upgrade Puzzle

eto@spacely.Jpl.Nasa.Gov (Edward Olsen) (02/14/89)

I have been running my Mac Plus with 2.5 MB of memory for a year with a Dove
low profile memory upgrade.  I recently received my Apple low profile 2 MB
memory expansion kit (ordered last May), and proceeded happily to move to
4 MB.  I want to share the experience, for I have encountered some problems
which I do not understand.

I have three sets of chips:
	1) the original 256K ram, which is comprised of -15 chips
	2) my first 2MB upgrade, which is comprised of Dove low profile -12 chips
	3) my second 2MB upgrade, which is comprised of Apple low profile -10 chips

My Mac Plus is one of the last beige colored ones built, and its ROM
is 128K rev .2 (the so-called Lonely Heifer version).  This is apparently the
same ROM version which does not allow you to boot up with a powered-off SCSI
device connected.

I am running System release 6.0.2, and since my boot disk is a 100 MB Jasmine,
I have set the memory allocated to the Finder to be 300 KB (my desktop file
climbs to nearly 200 KB at times).

I had no problems beyond the odd system bomb running at 2.5 MB of memory
with chip combination (1) and (2) above.  I did remove the correct
resistors for the initial upgrade to 2.5 MB.

Upon replacing set (1) with set (3) to go to a full 4 MB, I found that a
host of problems appeared.  I would get system bombs with ID's of -2, -3,
-10, -25, etc at odd times within an application or within Finder.  Bootup
would sometimes be successful, sometimes yield the various system
bombs, and sometimes yield a sad Mac with various codes starting with 0F.
Some I remember are 0F0003, 0F0016 and 0F0021.  This occurred no matter
whether chip set (2) was in Bank A and chip set (3) was in Bank B or vice versa.

Running the Hypercard memory hog provided new errors.  I would get sporadic
messages from Hypercard that it did not understand Mouse Location, or
Continue statements.  In the latter case, it never returned control to me.

I backed off to the 2.5 MB configuration, utilizing chip sets (1) and (3).
All errors disappeared, and the system operated flawlessly.  Several days
later, I installed the other 2.5 MB configuration, utilizing chip
sets (1) and (2).  Again, no errors over several days of operation.

Thus I am left with the suspicion that my ROM version will not support a 4MB
configuration!  Any knowledgable comments will be greatly appreciated.

                           Ed Olsen




/*******************************************************************
 * Edward Olsen                    ARPA: eto@spacely.jpl.nasa.gov  *
 * Mail Stop: 169-506              UUCP: ...!cit-vax!spacely!eto   *
 * Jet Propulsion Laboratory       SPAN: jplrag::olsen             *
 * 4800 Oak Grove Drive                                            *
 * Pasadena, CA 91109                                              *
 *                                                                 *
 * Phone: FTS: 792-7604      Commercial: (818) 354-7604            *
 *******************************************************************/