[comp.sys.mac] The Apple Lawsuit

gmw1@CUNIXD.CC.COLUMBIA.EDU (Gabe M Wiener) (02/28/89)

I've been reading all the press about the Apple lawsuit over the logo, and
there's something I'd like to ask/mention.

I've always been told that a contract can be invalidated if it has not been
enforced.

People have been making music on Apples since the Apple II in the mid 1970's.
Doesn't it seem a little late for Apple Records to come along 13 years later
and demand a piece of the pie?

Anyway, as I see it, none of the computers are expressly designed for making
music.  The only product that I could see a problem with is Apple's selling
a MIDI interface, and if that is a problem, they should just move it over to
Claris. :-)

---------------------------------------------------
Gabe Wiener			Columbia University
Internet: gmw1@cunixd.cc.columbia.edu
Bitnet:   gmw1@cunixc.bitnet
CIS:	  72355,1226
WUI:      650-117-9118

gmw1@CUNIXD.CC.COLUMBIA.EDU (Gabe M Wiener) (03/06/89)

There is something I don't understand.  How can Apple Records be accusing
Apple Computer of making music synthesizig deviced?  Even a mac fully equipped
with MIDI is not a synthesizer.  It only provides the digital information to
drive a synthesizer.

If they consider it a synth because of its own sound chip, then the Apple II
could have been considered a synth and then they should have sued in 1976 or
whenever the Apple II Integer first appeared.

Oh well, let's see how long this one lingers around in the courts.


=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-\ --- /=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
BITNET: gmw1@cunixc                  \\*// Gabe Wiener
INTERNET: gmw1@cunixd.cc.columbia.edu \|/  1410 John Jay Hall
COMPUSERVE: 72355,1226                />\  Columbia University
WUI: 650-117-9118                    / < \ New York, NY 10027    U.S.A.
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-/  >  \=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
*** Message from daemon@cunixd ***  >  |  <"At times it wiser to remain silent 
Lo! The end of the world is nigh!   >-----< and be considered a fool than to 
Please log off.			    > --- < speak and remove all doubt." -Shaw
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=->  -  <=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-