[comp.sys.mac] New Mac Programmer -- HELP! *Commentary added

jnh@ece-csc.UUCP (Joseph Nathan Hall) (03/14/89)

In article <64@sppy00.UUCP> jmv@sppy00.UUCP (Jim Vickroy) writes:
>I hope I'm not the only one who has felt the ultimate frustration in moving
>MS-DOS to the Mac. So I'm going to try tapping this wealth of information:
>
>Do anyone out there have a blow-by-blow procedure to:
>1. Change the desktop icons from the defaults to custom icons?

The method for doing this is described in Inside Macintosh II in the
Finder section.  Unfortunately this section is not particularly clearly
written, and what should be one of the easier hurdles in creating a
Mac application becomes a multiple-hour exercise in confusion for a
beginning Mac programmer.  If someone doesn't post a step-by-step
description of how to do this in the next couple of days, I will.

>2. Change the font of text in a window?
>
Easy.  Use TextFont(fontnumber).  See the QuickDraw chapter in IM I.

>If these are really stupid questions please bare with me...

(Taking off my clothes ... :-))

Seriously, folks.  These are simple questions but unfortunately not stupid
questions in the Mac programming world.  I find it immensely frustrating
sometimes trying to discern the *simplest* things about the Toolbox and
OS calls.  There isn't even a good description of what a complex, real-world
event loop should look like in Apple's documentation.

For example:  IM I has a TextEdit chapter.  But where does it say that
lines in the TextEdit record are terminated in carriage returns?  (What
should I assume?  Could be LFs, NULLs, whatever!)  Where does it say whether
the LineStarts are 0- or 1-based?  (They're 0-based).  Basic stuff,
NOT documented in the primary reference.

I've said before that I think the Tech Notes are an abomination.  IM should
have been a looseleaf set from the start.  Tech Notes should exist only
briefly between updates to IM.  There should be no IM 4 and no IM 5 and
thus no need for the silly cross-reference volumn.

Furthermore, there should be GOOD examples of complex Pascal and C event
loops available from Apple (in a book!)--something like a Macintosh
Application Programmer's Guide.  Not piecemeal (Programming for Multifinder--
yuck!), but a good, solid, systematic introduction to the event loop
programming style, + common idiomatic techniques, readily available.  You
can't expect every future Mac applications programmer to be able to attend
a college class, nor expect him/her to want to spend his time trying to
find a good non-Apple reference (difficult since most of them are either
inaccurate or out-of-date).

After 10 years of programming on everything from TRS-80 Model 1s to 11/780s
running VMS and 4.3BSD, I've found the Mac the most difficult and irritating
environment of all to program in.  I've also found the end results the most
satisfying, which is why I put up with all the bull**** in the first place.

But still ... what do we user/programmers have to do to get decent reference
materials from Apple?  Why do we join APDA, collect inaccurate/
inadequate textbooks, buy $200 of separately-bound IM and related reference
works, collect Tech Notes, post questions on USENET, then STILL run into
undocumented "features", bugs, inaccurate documentation (the new Sound
Manager!), and inconsistencies?



-- 
v   v sssss|| joseph hall                      || 201-1D Hampton Lee Court
 v v s   s || jnh@ece-csc.ncsu.edu (Internet)  || Cary, NC  27511
  v   sss  || the opinions expressed herein are not necessarily those of my
-----------|| employer, north carolina state university . . . . . . . . . . . 

jmv@sppy00.UUCP (Jim Vickroy) (03/14/89)

In article <3949@ece-csc.UUCP> jnh@ece-csc.UUCP (Joseph Nathan Hall) writes:
=>beginning Mac programmer.  If someone doesn't post a step-by-step
=>description of how to do this in the next couple of days, I will.

I have received several replys to this problem but haven't had a chance to
try them yet. I will post what works when I get that chance.

=>
=>>2. Change the font of text in a window?
=>>
=>Easy.  Use TextFont(fontnumber).  See the QuickDraw chapter in IM I.

I tried this but the font didn't change. I think, however, the problem is
mine because I pass to TextFont what I get from LoWord. Probably wrong.

[ commentary deleted for space ]

I can't agree with you more. I feel I'm a fairly accomplished programmer
(6+ years professionally on mainframes to micros) but I haven't been more
frustrated than trying to figure out these two seemingly simple procedures.

Another problem I have is the hundreds of dollars you have to spend just
accumulating the necessary documentation (Apple and other publishers) so
you can write the simplist of applications.

BTW, I just ordered the looseleaf edition of Inside Macintosh vI - V
because the IM's I was using were borrowed. The price tag: $130. (from APDA)

jim
--

!==================================================================!=========!
! Jim Vickroy                          | cbosgd!osu-cis!sppy00!jmv !/././././!
! Online Computer Library Center, Inc. |---------------------------!././././.!
! Dublin, Ohio  43017                  | jmv@sppy00                !/././././!
!------------------------------------------------------------------!././././.!
! "That voodoo stuff don't do nothin' for me"                 -jrr !/././././!
!==================================================================!=========!

bin@primate.wisc.edu (Brain in Neutral) (03/14/89)

Inside Mac isn't so bad.  (But then, I like to read manuals).
Consider trying to get along without it.  However, the comments about
lack of source code in the documentation are correct.  What any beginning
programmer needs to do is get his hands on the source code for already
written applications and study THAT.  If you're trying to understand
scroll bars, get source for an application that uses 'em and study it
(with IM at your side).  Programming with just reference manuals is for
the birds.

Of course, you have to be able to get source code, and since HARDLY
ANYONE POSTS ANY --- STILL!!! --- you may be out of luck.

Paul DuBois
dubois@primate.wisc.edu		rhesus!dubois
bin@primate.wisc.edu		rhesus!bin

stores@unix.SRI.COM (Matt Mora) (03/15/89)

In article <3949@ece-csc.UUCP> jnh@ece-csc.UUCP (Joseph Nathan Hall) writes:
>Seriously, folks.  These are simple questions but unfortunately not stupid
>questions in the Mac programming world.  I find it immensely frustrating
>sometimes trying to discern the *simplest* things about the Toolbox and
>OS calls.  There isn't even a good description of what a complex, real-world
>event loop should look like in Apple's documentation.
>
>For example:  IM I has a TextEdit chapter.  But where does it say that
>lines in the TextEdit record are terminated in carriage returns?  (What
>should I assume?  Could be LFs, NULLs, whatever!)  Where does it say whether

some stuff deleted

>Furthermore, there should be GOOD examples of complex Pascal and C event
>loops available from Apple (in a book!)--something like a Macintosh
>Application Programmer's Guide.  Not piecemeal (Programming for Multifinder--
>yuck!), but a good, solid, systematic introduction to the event loop
>programming style, + common idiomatic techniques, readily available.  You

more stuff deleted

>But still ... what do we user/programmers have to do to get decent reference
>materials from Apple?  Why do we join APDA, collect inaccurate/
 
 Maybe some of us on the net can draft a book (article,letter
 or what ever you want to  call it) on the subject of 
beginning macintosh programming and call it "Everything that you wanted
to know about mac programming but were afraid to ask!". It could include
up-to-date info on the Mac and source code examples. some snippits from
the net about gotchas and bugs. That way if someone asks on the net about 
beginning programming on the mac we could just email them a copy.

just an Idea :-)
Matt Mora
SRI International

jnh@ece-csc.UUCP (Joseph Nathan Hall) (03/15/89)

In article <169@indri.primate.wisc.edu> bin@primate.wisc.edu writes:
>
>Of course, you have to be able to get source code, and since HARDLY
>ANYONE POSTS ANY --- STILL!!! --- you may be out of luck.
>
>Paul DuBois
>dubois@primate.wisc.edu		rhesus!dubois
>bin@primate.wisc.edu		rhesus!bin

( Hi, Paul ... )

Well, sure, so far as IM goes, it's not bad.  My point is just that it doesn't
go far enough.  The lack of source code is miserable, especially for us
1980s-style "C" programmers.  (Well, OK, I suppose you're still a Pascal
type yourself; nevertheless ...)

I've heard from a few people since my last posting who seem to concur that
the lack of *real* programming references is acute, and that there is not
much of a consensus, additionally, as to how one should organize a Mac
application internally, particularly the event loop.

I'd like to suggest that we USENET-ters produce a "Mac Programming Guide."
In particular, we should produce a document describing, in detail, a good,
workable event loop with support for everything; in addition, we should come
up with a collection of efficient paradigms for dialog handling, menu
item dimming/hilighting, file save & load, text editing, etc.  Also, we should
try to explore the general issue of event-driven programming as opposed to
"conventional" programming, and what the differences between the assembler,
Pascal, C and (hopefully!) C++ programming environments are.

I'll be more than happy to take comments and suggestions by e-mail and post
them, and I might be willing to organize and edit the project, since I
have considerable interest in it.

Any takers?

-- 
v   v sssss|| joseph hall                      || 201-1D Hampton Lee Court
 v v s   s || jnh@ece-csc.ncsu.edu (Internet)  || Cary, NC  27511
  v   sss  || the opinions expressed herein are not necessarily those of my
-----------|| employer, north carolina state university . . . . . . . . . . . 

brecher@well.UUCP (Steve Brecher) (03/15/89)

In article <3949@ece-csc.UUCP>, jnh@ece-csc.UUCP (Joseph Nathan Hall) writes:

> IM I has a TextEdit chapter.  But where does it say that lines in the
> TextEdit record are terminated in carriage returns?

IM I-375: "Normally ... the text automatically wraps around ... .  A new line
also begins where explicitly specified by a Return character in the text."
(See also I-378, last para.)

That is, "normally" there are no terminators at the end of each line; this
would be the case for, e.g., most dialog box static text items -- TextEdit
takes care of formatting the text with respect to lines, and calculates the
contents of the lineStarts array based on the width of the destination
rectangle.  For line-oriented text, e.g., most program source code, there
would be a CR at the end of each line of text.

> Where does it say whether the LineStarts are 0- or 1-based?

IM I-377: "lineStarts: ARRAY[0..16000] OF INTEGER" (see also I-379, last
para.)
-- 

brecher@well.UUCP (Steve Brecher)

sarrel@tut.cis.ohio-state.edu (Marc Sarrel) (03/15/89)

Just a meta-comment here.  Could you please restrict yourselves to
comp.sys.mac.programmer?  That's what it's there for.  Thank you for
your support.

--marc

stores@unix.SRI.COM (Matt Mora) (03/16/89)

In article <67@sppy00.UUCP> jmv@sppy00.UUCP (Jim Vickroy) writes:
>In article <3949@ece-csc.UUCP> jnh@ece-csc.UUCP (Joseph Nathan Hall) writes:
>=>beginning Mac programmer.  If someone doesn't post a step-by-step
>=>description of how to do this in the next couple of days, I will.
>
>I have received several replys to this problem but haven't had a chance to
>try them yet. I will post what works when I get that chance.
>
>=>
>=>>2. Change the font of text in a window?
>=>>
>=>Easy.  Use TextFont(fontnumber).  See the QuickDraw chapter in IM I.
>
>I tried this but the font didn't change. I think, however, the problem is
>mine because I pass to TextFont what I get from LoWord. Probably wrong.
>
>[ commentary deleted for space ]
>
>I can't agree with you more. I feel I'm a fairly accomplished programmer
>(6+ years professionally on mainframes to micros) but I haven't been more
>frustrated than trying to figure out these two seemingly simple procedures.
>
If you are tring to get the fontnumber from a menu
to change the textfont of a grafport then
here is an example:

menuitem:=LoWord(the_menu_item_selected)

GetItem(menuhandle, menuitem, fontname);
GetFNum(fontname, fontnum);
TextFont(fontnum);

but if you are tring to change a TE Font
I had a problem with this in LSP.

I think the it would be

procedure CalcText;	{procedure to fix line spacing}
		var
			fInfo: FontInfo;
	begin
		GetFontInfo(fInfo);
		with fInfo, textH^^ do
			begin
				lineHeight := ascent + descent + leading;
				fontAscent := ascent
			end;
end;

menuitem:=LoWord(the_menu_item_selected)

GetItem(menuhandle, menuitem, fontname);
GetFNum(fontname, fontnum);
textH^^.txFont := fontnum;
textfont(fontnum);
CalcText; {call this to fix the line spacing}
TECalText(textH);
InvalRect(myWindow^.portrect); {force an update}

I Hope This Helps

Matt Mora
SRI International

mnkonar@gorby.SRC.Honeywell.COM (Murat N. Konar) (03/16/89)

In article <169@indri.primate.wisc.edu> bin@primate.wisc.edu writes:
> (stuff deleted)>
>Of course, you have to be able to get source code, and since HARDLY
>ANYONE POSTS ANY --- STILL!!! --- you may be out of luck.
>


 Or you can go out and get "Macintosh Revealed" Volumes I and II by
Stephen Chericoff.  These are available almost anywhere that sells
computer books.  The second volume takes you through the 
implementation of a text editing program that supports the Mac 
user interface.  The two volumes together shouldn't cost more than
around $50.  They document the toolbox well enough that you can
get away with not buying Inside Macintosh unless you are really
doing some major thing or something esoteric (relatively speaking).

Source code disks are available from the publisher (Hayden).  The
source is in Pascal.  Printing is not discussed but Volume 3 (just
released) covers this and some other things.  Its not really 
essential (IMHO) unless you neep to print.

I have no connection with etc, etc...

______________________________________________________________________
Have a day. :^|
Murat N. Konar        Honeywell Systems & Research Center, Camden, MN
mnkonar@SRC.honeywell.com (internet) | {umn-cs,ems,bthpyd}!srcsip!mnkonar(UUCP)

jnh@ece-csc.UUCP (Joseph Nathan Hall) (03/16/89)

In article <18784@srcsip.UUCP> mnkonar@gorby.UUCP (Murat N. Konar) writes:
>In article <169@indri.primate.wisc.edu> bin@primate.wisc.edu writes:
>> (stuff deleted)>
>>Of course, you have to be able to get source code, and since HARDLY
>>ANYONE POSTS ANY --- STILL!!! --- you may be out of luck.
>
> Or you can go out and get "Macintosh Revealed" Volumes I and II by
>Stephen Chericoff.  These are available almost anywhere that sells
>computer books.  The second volume takes you through the 
>implementation of a text editing program that supports the Mac 
>user interface.  The two volumes together shouldn't cost more than
>around $50.  They document the toolbox well enough that you can
>get away with not buying Inside Macintosh unless you are really
>doing some major thing or something esoteric (relatively speaking).
>
I have Volumes I and II and I am ambivalent about them.  I find them
to have very little use to me in general since they cover only beginning
and low-to-intermediate level topics, and do not address most of my
"problem" areas, i.e., those that are vaguely or inadequately documented
in Inside Macintosh.  They are also, of course, Pascal-based, and you can
really get screwed trying to figure out how to (for example) declare
callback routines in "C" from descriptions of similar Pascal routines.

There are *no* good "C" programming references for the Mac, unless one has
been released in the past few months.

I might look at MR Volume III, but if it's as leisurely-paced as the first
two volumes, I'll pass on it.

I'd recommend the books only if you are a novice programmer who will be
working in Pascal, and would recommend you spring for at least the first
four volumes of IM while you're at it, since you will run into issues MR
doesn't cover as soon as you start fiddling around with controls, printing,
complicated dialogs, file operations, etc.

To a "C" programmer I'd recommend Lightspeed C (or MPW) and all the Tech
Notes and examples you can get your hands on.  Look at TransSkel--better
yet, use it.  (But we have to write a non-TextEdit-based editor!)  

-- 
v   v sssss|| joseph hall                      || 201-1D Hampton Lee Court
 v v s   s || jnh@ece-csc.ncsu.edu (Internet)  || Cary, NC  27511
  v   sss  || the opinions expressed herein are not necessarily those of my
-----------|| employer, north carolina state university . . . . . . . . . . . 

hammersslammers1@oxy.edu (David J. Harr) (03/16/89)

Hear! Hear! I absolutely agree! Let's take it upon ourselves to write the
definitive Macintosh Programmers Guide (available at your local bookstores
for the low, low price of only $79.95 [softback]). I think that would be a
true example of the spirit of USENET. BTW, Joseph, if you do get chosen to
do this and need any help, let me know. I may not know much about how to
program the Mac, but I think I can handle organizing material for a book.

stores@unix.SRI.COM (Matt Mora) (03/17/89)

In article <3955@ece-csc.UUCP> jnh@ece-csc.UUCP (Joseph Nathan Hall) writes:
>In article <169@indri.primate.wisc.edu> bin@primate.wisc.edu writes:
>>
>>Of course, you have to be able to get source code, and since HARDLY
>>ANYONE POSTS ANY --- STILL!!! --- you may be out of luck.
>>
>
>I've heard from a few people since my last posting who seem to concur that
>the lack of *real* programming references is acute, and that there is not
>much of a consensus, additionally, as to how one should organize a Mac
>application internally, particularly the event loop.
>
>I'd like to suggest that we USENET-ters produce a "Mac Programming Guide."
>In particular, we should produce a document describing, in detail, a good,
>workable event loop with support for everything; in addition, we should come
>up with a collection of efficient paradigms for dialog handling, menu
>item dimming/hilighting, file save & load, text editing, etc.  Also, we should
>try to explore the general issue of event-driven programming as opposed to

Don't for get about the dirty word "scrolling".
I think it would be great to have a guide to get
a handle on the aspects of programming the mac. I remember
someone saying that before you can write you have to know
how to read. That goes for any language (be it english or 
any computer language). let's say you wanted to write a 
MDEF. You could scan the back issues of Mactutor to try to
find a good example (if you have all the volumes) only to find
that the author wrote it in a different language. Instead you
can pull out your trusty "Mac Programming Guide" look for the
chapter MDEF's and there you have it. Examples in of mdef's in 
C, Pascal, asm or whatever. Also at the end of the chapter will 
be a Gothcas and bug report.

Well I better stop my dreaming. (is it that close to april fools? :-))
Well if anyones counting  call this a yes vote.

Matt Mora
SRI International

maw@romeo.cs.duke.edu (Max A. Woodbury) (03/17/89)

In article <3955@ece-csc.UUCP> jnh@ece-csc.UUCP (Joseph Nathan Hall) writes:
>In article <169@indri.primate.wisc.edu> bin@primate.wisc.edu writes:
>>
>>Of course, you have to be able to get source code, and since HARDLY
>>ANYONE POSTS ANY --- STILL!!! --- you may be out of luck.
>>
>
>I've heard from a few people since my last posting who seem to concur that
>the lack of *real* programming references is acute, and that there is not
>much of a consensus, additionally, as to how one should organize a Mac
>application internally, particularly the event loop.
>
>I'd like to suggest that we USENET-ters produce a "Mac Programming Guide."
>In particular, we should produce a document describing, in detail, a good,
>workable event loop with support for everything; in addition, we should come
>up with a collection of efficient paradigms for dialog handling, menu
>item dimming/hilighting, file save & load, text editing, etc. 

After two years of playing/hacking at Mac Programming, we (my Mac specialist
and I) have a simple "blank" application in LSC which we could send off to
whomever is collecting the stuff (or even post [gasp!]) in comp.sources.mac
if the interest warrants it.  I handles a simple one window situation WITHOUT
controls, but it is fairly clear.  I know it could be better, and more
powerful, etc.  but we haven't the time to research everything and still get
the necessary programming done.  Let me know your feelings.
--
Greg Woodbury (using the account of Max Woodbury)
System Manager(UNIX) and System Programmer
Duke U. Center for Demographic Studies	(919)684 6126 (after 1pm EST)
US Mail: 2117 Campus Drive; Durham NC 27706 USA
UUCP: ...mcnc!ecsgate!dukeac!dukcds!ggw  or  ...duke!dukcds!ggw
Internet: ggw%dukcds@cs.duke.edu  or  ggw@dukeac.ac.duke.edu

hpoppe@bierstadt.ucar.edu (Herb Poppe) (03/17/89)

In article <24945@tiger.oxy.edu> hammersslammers1@oxy.edu (David J. Harr) writes:
>Hear! Hear! I absolutely agree! Let's take it upon ourselves to write the
>definitive Macintosh Programmers Guide (available at your local bookstores
>for the low, low price of only $79.95 [softback]). I think that would be a
>true example of the spirit of USENET. BTW, Joseph, if you do get chosen to
>do this and need any help, let me know. I may not know much about how to
>program the Mac, but I think I can handle organizing material for a book.
								     ^^^^
Book, smook. Its about time we have an electronic version! How about a
Hypercard stack with references linked from here to next Wednesday. You
know, where you are reading a card that has the description of a record type,
and you can click on a field and it takes you to the card containing
the type definiton of that field. There would be a "gotcha" card which
would be the starting point for a thread of links to all the caveats
that are sprinkled throughout IM.

You get the idea. Then have BMUG release it on CD-ROM with a copy on
sumex (or your favorite net archive server).

Herb Poppe      NCAR                         INTERNET: hpoppe@ncar.ucar.edu
(303) 497-1296  P.O. Box 3000                   CSNET: hpoppe@ncar.CSNET
		Boulder, CO  80307               UUCP: hpoppe@ncar.UUCP

gandreas@umn-d-ub.D.UMN.EDU (Glenn Andreas) (03/18/89)

In article <1595@ncar.ucar.edu> hpoppe@bierstadt.UCAR.EDU (Herb Poppe) writes:
>Book, smook. Its about time we have an electronic version! How about a
>Hypercard stack with references linked from here to next Wednesday.


Nice idea, but there is one big problem - memory.  Remember that this whole
thread started with help for beginning programmers.  Now you want them to
have to be running HC whenever they are programming.  So you need to be
running MF.  And have 2.5 Megs or more.  And a large screen (since many
times I want to look at my code as well as at the reference).  And a CD rom
with this all on.  At work I've got a IIx with lots of memory (and I could
steal a CD rom), so this would be great and wonderful.  But at home, I've
just got a Mac Plus, One Meg - which is where I do most of my development
work.  There is no way that I (and I suspect many programmers, especially
beginners) could use this system.

=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
= "Whether you like it, or don't like it, sit   | - gandreas@ub.d.umn.edu - =
=  back and take a look at it, because it's the |   Glenn Andreas           =
=  best going today!  WOOOOoooo!" - Ric Flair   |                           =
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

jnh@ece-csc.UUCP (Joseph Nathan Hall) (03/18/89)

In article <1595@ncar.ucar.edu> hpoppe@bierstadt.UCAR.EDU (Herb Poppe) writes:
>In article <24945@tiger.oxy.edu> hammersslammers1@oxy.edu (David J. Harr) writes:
>>Hear! Hear! I absolutely agree! Let's take it upon ourselves to write the
>>definitive Macintosh Programmers Guide (available at your local bookstores
>...								     ^^^^
>Book, smook. Its about time we have an electronic version! How about a
>Hypercard stack with references linked from here to next Wednesday. You
...
This is another option, but it would have to be in addition to the normal
"book" form.  Unless you have the hypercard DA it's not all that convenient
to browse a stack while you're programming.  It's certainly more convenient
(to me, at least) to browse through a well-indexed book.


-- 
v   v sssss|| joseph hall                      || 201-1D Hampton Lee Court
 v v s   s || jnh@ece-csc.ncsu.edu (Internet)  || Cary, NC  27511
  v   sss  || the opinions expressed herein are not necessarily those of my
-----------|| employer, north carolina state university . . . . . . . . . . . 

jln@accuvax.nwu.edu (John Norstad) (03/18/89)

FLAME ON...

You guys are all wimps :-)  You remind me of the people
who ask me if I know of any good books on C - I tell
them to read Kernighan and Ritchie and they give me a
dumb look and whine that "it's tooooo hard to understand."

There's TONS of good Mac programming books and sample code
readily available.  My favorite books are the pair by 
Scott Knaster, and Joel West's book on MPW.  You can
also buy books devoted to C programming on the Mac,
Pacal programming on the Mac, assembler programming on
the Mac, and even MacApp programming on the Mac. 
They're all filled with many, many sample programs
and code fragments.  Apple also gives away a number
of sample programs.  You can also find lots of sample
code and useful information in MacTutor magazine.  Even
Byte magazine, that most unlikely source of Mac info,
has started to jump on the bandwagon.

So stop complaining!  When I started Mac programming
in April, 1984 at Odesta we didn't have any of this
stuff.  Inside Mac was looseleaf, and we got new 
chapters and revised chapters monthly from Apple.  That
was it - there were no other sources of information on
Mac programming.  For that matter, we also didn't have
ResEdit, MPW, LSC, or any other decent programming tools.  
Programs had to be built on a Lisa and downloaded to a 128K 
Mac over the serial ports.  It took 45 minutes to make a one 
line change to Helix. So if you think things are hard now, 
you should have been around back in the "good old days".

I also can't agree with the complaints about Inside
Mac.  I've found it to be exceptionally well-written,
clear, and concise.  Yes, it has too many errors, and
yes, some of it could written more clearly, and yes, it 
slights C in favor of Pascal, and yes, the information 
is spread out over too many places, but compared to most 
other technical manuals I find it quite good.  People who 
complain about it would be better off if they spent more
time reading it (and by reading it I mean cover-to-cover,
all 5 volumes).

...FLAME OFF

p.s. - I also think the TMON manual is pretty good.  So there.

John Norstad
Academic Computing and Network Services
Northwestern University

Bitnet: jln@nuacc
Internet: jln@acns.nwu.edu
Applelink: a0173

bmug@garnet.berkeley.edu (BMUG) (03/18/89)

In article <1595@ncar.ucar.edu> hpoppe@bierstadt.UCAR.EDU (Herb Poppe) writes:
>In article <24945@tiger.oxy.edu> hammersslammers1@oxy.edu (David J. Harr) writes:
>>Hear! Hear! I absolutely agree! Let's take it upon ourselves to write the
>>definitive Macintosh Programmers Guide (available at your local bookstores
>>for the low, low price of only $79.95 [softback]). 
> (stuff deleted)
>Book, smook. Its about time we have an electronic version!
> (stuff about HyperCard stackware version deleted)
>You get the idea. Then have BMUG release it on CD-ROM with a copy on
>sumex (or your favorite net archive server).
>
>Herb Poppe      NCAR                         INTERNET: hpoppe@ncar.ucar.edu
>(303) 497-1296  P.O. Box 3000                   CSNET: hpoppe@ncar.CSNET
>		Boulder, CO  80307               UUCP: hpoppe@ncar.UUCP

Well, speaking on behalf of the guys who put the PD-ROM together for BMUG,
I'm sure we'd be happy to include it on the next version (which is due
out sometime this summer).  Also, if people are serious about a definitive
book of the tangible variety, BMUG may be able to help with the editing
and printing; our developers SIG is considering putting together such
a beast (dealing mostly with LSC issues but open to MPW, LSP and other
programming environments) to be called, tentatively (and no flames,
please), "The Satanic Sources".  Since we have a reasonably good
setup for editing, printing, and distribution, we might be able to
help with the compilation and production for something which would
be extremely attractively priced and available to everyone not on
the net.  People who'd like to discuss or contribute to this effort
are encouraged to get in touch with Greg Dow of the developers SIG.
He can be reached on this account or at apple!bmug!greg.dow@sun.com.

John Heckendorn
"We're in the business of giving away information"
                                                             /\
BMUG                      ARPA: bmug@garnet.berkeley.EDU    A__A
1442A Walnut St., #62     BITNET: bmug@ucbgarnet            |()|
Berkeley, CA  94709                                         |  |
(415) 549-2684                                              |  |