[comp.sys.mac] repairing/replacing failed hard drive?

dba+@andrew.cmu.edu (David Anderson) (09/01/89)

A friend's hard drive (Jasmine 20) has gone through a pattern of failure
that will sound familiar to those following the recent thread on hard
disk failures: it spins, but doesn't boot up. It did this intermittently
for several months, and then failed completely.

A local repair shop says the only way to fix it is to replace the drive
itself: $400. They've said that the power supply and controller
electronics are just fine. The old drive is a standard 20meg Seagate
drive -- so my question is, can we just go out and buy a new 20meg
Seagate drive and plug it in? I see these drives advertised in PC
magazines for about $220-240 -- why should this cost $400? (Obviously at
that price, she'll just buy a new drive, a la Chuq.)

What is everyone else doing with their broken disk drives?

--david

dba+@andrew.cmu.edu

mike@octel.UUCP (Michael D. Crawford) (09/01/89)

I had a lot of trouble that I thought was due to my new drive, but
it turned out to be the SCSI port from Total Systems Integration that I 
had put into my 512 K (along with TSI memory that worked fine).  I
borrowed a different SCSI port which worked fine.  Much to their credit,
the replacement port arrived promptly, no hassle, but I have not yet
put it in.  I'll flame if it does not work...

-- 
Michael David Crawford			Consulting for:
Oddball Enterprises			Octel Communications Corp
694 Nobel Drive				890 Tasman Drive
Santa Cruz, CA 95060			Milpitas CA 95035
pyramid!vsi1,!octel!mike
CI$ 72377,623

Ain't got no cache, ain't no file, ain't got no disk to make you smile,
Don`t worry, be happy!