[comp.sys.atari.st] Hard disks - The Saga Continues

ravi@mcnc.UUCP (Ravi Subrahmanyan) (12/25/86)

[  Poodles?  You sure? ]

	Here's another tale of the piecing together of a hard-disk,
including my evaluation (financial and otherwise) of the Ultimate Question:  
Why Bother??  

	Anyway, it all began one dark and stormy night when I read a
posting describing a DMA-->SCSI adapter from Berkeley Microsystems.
My curiosity aroused, I called them up, and found that they offered
the board together with an Adaptek 4000 controller for $250.  Also,
the board has a battery-backed up clock which can be used to update
the ST's internal clock, etc.  Anyway, it seemed that this might be a
nice way to get a hard drive, provided I could get a good deal on a
bare drive.  I snooped around, and the basic choices (within my budget)
were a Seagate ST225N, and a CDC Wren 9415.  The price breakdowns were
roughly as follows:

		a)  DMA-->SCSI 	   :  		~125
		b)  SCSI controller:		~125
		c)  ST506 compatible hard drive:  

			1)  Seagate ST225N (20Mb)     ~325
			2)  Control Data 9415 (30Mb)  ~325

		d)  Power supply:  The CDC needs 4A at 12V during
Sjartup, so it needs a fairly hefty supply:	~75

It was obvious that making the 20Mb system would not save me anything,
at best I would barely break even.  However, the CDC looked promising, and 
so I decided to go ahead and take the plunge.   3 weeks later, I have a
roaring monster strewn all over the table in front of me;  it's noisy, 
the table looks like a Klingon cruiser, but it does work, and I have a 
30 Mb drive.

Is it all worth it?   Well, Tech-Specialities now advertises a
hard disk kit for $595.  They give you some sort of a case and power
supply, with space/power for 2 half-height drives, one Seagate
ST225, and the controller cards.  Considering the convenience that
offers, an experience like mine is of dubious value.  Finding an
appropriate power supply was a pain, plus the CDC is full height, so 
mounting the boards needed some machine work.  Also, I don't have a
case, so it's sitting out front in all it's glory.  

	But, on the other hand,  I do have a 30Mb drive for ~700.
Also, I'm certain it's a faster drive (it's voice-coil), for what 
that's worth.  I think I can get an IBM-PC case for ~30, and if I 
can put it all in that, at least it'll be packaged.  Also, I can add 
a second drive for ~350 (the controller + drivers can handle two 
drives), so I have the option of expanding cheaply at some future date if I 
wish.  All in all, it's almost worth the hassle, especially now that 
it's over.  If you like making things, it's probably a good deal;  
one certainly breaks even.  Finally, it adds an element of (possibly 
unpleasant) surprise to the whole thing.. (will it work or won't it?
Did I just blow $$$?  Will the old lady make me sleep in Fido's 
room for the rest of the decade? Should I have it (Fido's room) 
carpeted before I start this, just in case?.. you get the idea..)  

	Hope this fires up some intrepid adventurers out there,

							-ravi