[comp.sys.atari.st] Two questions on ST add-{o|i}ns

manis@ubc-cs.UUCP (02/25/87)

I'm considering two purchases over the next few months, and I was wondering
if I could get some input:

a) a company called Terrific advertises a clock chip which mounts underneath
   some chip on the motherboard. I remember the warning from Neil Harris on
   the dangers of the Logikhron (as I remember, it occasionally trashed hard
   disks); has anybody had any experience with the Terrific chip (or any
   other clock)?

b) I'm also considering buying a hard disk. The two alternatives seem to be
   the Atari SH204 and the Supra 30Meg drive, which Computer Mail Order 
   advertises at about US$100 more than the Atari drive. Is the Supra a good
   buy? Is it reliable? Is it faster than, the same speed as, or slower than
   the SH204? The Berkeley Microsystems drive is also a possibility, but 
   the prices I've seen seem a little out of my leage.

I'd appreciate any comments on either of these topics.

-----
Vincent Manis                {ihnp4!alberta,uw-beaver}!ubc-vision!ubc-cs!manis
Dept. of Computer Science    manis@cs.ubc.cdn
Univ. of British Columbia    manis%ubc.csnet@csnet-relay.arpa  
Vancouver, B.C. V6T 1W5      manis@ubc.csnet
(604) 228-6770 or 228-3061

"BASIC is the Computer Science equivalent of 'Scientific Creationism'."

pwp@iuvax.UUCP (02/26/87)

I have been using the Supra 30 Meg drive and am quite happy with it. I
don't have any thing to compare it with. I hope some one fixes the
40 folder problem soon. After making a strong {_effort not to have
many folders I managed to get by with 100. I am very careful to reboot
following any time I open very many, and so far every thing has
worked ok, at least the contents of the disk have been ok. A few
times I rebooted because the system looked like it was in trouble.
I hope I am backed up enough. I just can not seem to find any
reasonable way to use 30 Megbytes and have only 40 folders.

leavens@atari.UUCP (03/05/87)

> a) a company called Terrific advertises a clock chip which mounts underneath
>    some chip on the motherboard. I remember the warning from Neil Harris on

  I've heard good things about them, but have not used it myself.  I have a
board that goes into the chip socket on the keyboard, and uses two rechargeable
nickelcad batteries, with a little program in the auto folder to read the
clock at boot time.  I think it's called ST-Time, and I like it.

> b) I'm also considering buying a hard disk. The two alternatives seem to be
>    the Atari SH204 and the Supra 30Meg drive...

I use an SH204 myself, and like it very much.  I've also heard good things
about the Supra.

--alex @ Atari

BIX: alexl.      GEnie: ALEXLEAVENS         Atari Corp: 408-745-2160

rbk@akguc.UUCP (03/06/87)

> A company called Terrific advertises a clock chip which mounts underneath
> some chip on the motherboard. I remember the warning from Neil Harris on
> the dangers of the Logikhron (as I remember, it occasionally trashed hard
> disks); has anybody had any experience with the Terrific chip (or any
> other clock)?

I have been using the Logikhron clock card and an Atari hard disk together
on my 1040 for about six months now, and have never had any problems.  I
called Logikhron when I first got my hard disk and was told that they had
never been able to verify the reported problems and had never had any
reports of problems directly from users.  Perhaps the reported problems
were not really related to the clock card (the 40-folder bug maybe???) or
were related to some "special" version of the operating system or the
hard disk driver used at Atari.

BTW, when ARE we going to see the updated hard disk driver (or whatever)
from Atari that allows booting from the hard disk???
	
	R. Brad Kummer	{ihnp4, seismo!akgua}!akguc!rbk
	AT&T Bell Labs	Atlanta, GA

leavens@atari.UUCP (Alex Leavens) (03/09/87)

in article <7988@akguc.UUCP>, rbk@akguc.UUCP (R. Brad Kummer) says:
> 
> BTW, when ARE we going to see the updated hard disk driver (or whatever)
> from Atari that allows booting from the hard disk???
> 	
  If we were working on such a thing, I'm sure we'd be trying very hard
to get it out the door.  <grin>

--alex @ Atari

BIX: alexl.             GEnie: ALEXLEAVENS           AtariCorp: 408-745-2006

fischer-michael@YALE.ARPA.UUCP (03/11/87)

In-reply-to:  imagen!atari!leavens@ucbvax.Berkeley.EDU  (Alex Leavens)
> in article <7988@akguc.UUCP>, rbk@akguc.UUCP (R. Brad Kummer) says:
> > 
> > BTW, when ARE we going to see the updated hard disk driver (or whatever)
> > from Atari that allows booting from the hard disk???
> > 	
>   If we were working on such a thing, I'm sure we'd be trying very hard
> to get it out the door.  <grin>

I want to thank Alex for becoming active on the net and responding
to people's questions.  However, I was a little disappointed at
his uninformative answer above.  Perhaps he is unaware of the history
surrounding this issue.

Late last summer, someone at Atari said that such a program was
already finished, was being used in-house at Atari, and would be
released shortly after it had been tested thoroughly.  It never
was.

A couple of months ago, Allan Pratt explained on the net that when
he boots his machine, he simply inserts a blank floppy and the machine
boots automatically from the hard disk.  So apparently the program
is still being used in-house at Atari.

We were also told that the reason it had not been released to the
world was because it can be tricky to recover from a bad boot sector
or bad programs in the C:\AUTO folder on the hard disk, for if the
machine crashes during booting, how can you delete the offending
files?  Atari wanted to be sure that people who encountered this
problem would have a way out other than calling Atari and asking
for help.  (Reasonable enough!)  

It seemed to me that an easy way to recover would be to have a floppy
with a valid boot sector, such as the original TOS-in-RAM system
disk.  Booting from this disk would bypass the hard disk boot,
allowing the machine to come up normally without running the programs
on the hard disk.  One could then install the hard disk driver and
go in and repair the C:\AUTO folder or rebuild the boot sector or
whatever.  If that indeed is the best strategy for recovery, then
it would be reaonable for Atari to make sure that anyone using the
program also had access to the recovery procedures by only
distributing the program with such a disk and not posting it to
the net.  But that has apparently not been done, either.

That's the last we've heard.  We know the program exists and has
been in daily use at Atari for over six months.  We just want to
know when we can have it.

--Mike Fischer <fischer@yale.arpa>

-------

leavens@atari.UUCP (03/14/87)

in article <8703111519.AA03527@yale-eli.YALE.ARPA>, fischer-michael@YALE.ARPA (Michael Fischer) says:
> 
> Late last summer, someone at Atari said that such a program was
> already finished, was being used in-house at Atari, and would be
> released shortly after it had been tested thoroughly.  It never
> was.

> That's the last we've heard.  We know the program exists and has
> been in daily use at Atari for over six months.  We just want to
> know when we can have it.
> 

  Yep, I know.  I'd like to see it released also--Unfortunately, I'm not the
one who has a say-so in this matter.

--alex @ Atari

BIX:alexl.            GEnie: ALEXLEAVENS      AtariCorp: 408-745-2006

"How can you be in two places at once when you're not anywhere at all."