[comp.sys.atari.st] Magic Sac works/doesn't work update

rowley@ORVILLE.NAS.NASA.GOV (Karl Rowley) (12/11/87)

I have tried some more software with the Magic Sac.

Here is an updated list of software that seems to work with the Sac:
	Finder 6.0
	System 4.2
	MacWrite 4.6
	MacDraft 1.2a  (although I have heard of problems with MacDraft)
	MacDraw	1.9.5
	Microsoft Excel 1.03 and 1.04
	Microsoft Word 3.01
	Versaterm 2.3
	Binhex 5.0
	MacPaint
	LightSpeed C 1.02
Software that does not work:
	Red Ryder 9.2
	New Scrapbook DA (crashes at random times)
	MacWrite 4.5 (use MacWrite 4.6 instead)
	CricketDraw (requires 128K ROMs)
	Hypercard 1.01  (needs 128K ROMs)
	Multifinder

Does anyone have the Transverter, and would they care to comment on it?

			Karl Rowley
			Usenet: {hplabs,ucbvax,lll-crg}!ames!orville!rowley
			Arpanet: rowley@orville.nas.nasa.gov

lsr@apple.UUCP (Larry Rosenstein) (12/12/87)

In article <8712101753.AA15437@orville.nas.nasa.gov> rowley@ORVILLE.NAS.NASA.GOV (Karl Rowley) writes:
>I have tried some more software with the Magic Sac.
>
>Here is an updated list of software that seems to work with the Sac:
>	Finder 6.0
>	System 4.2

This may seem to work, but actually System 3.2/Finder 5.3 is the latest
version that supports the 64K ROMs (which Magic Sac requires).  The patches
for ROM bugs are present in System 3.2 but not later versions.


-- 
Larry Rosenstein

Object Specialist
Apple Computer

AppleLink: Rosenstein1
UUCP:  {sun, voder, nsc, mtxinu, dual}!apple!lsr
CSNET: lsr@Apple.com

engst@batcomputer.tn.cornell.edu (Adam C. Engst) (12/12/87)

In article <6978@apple.UUCP> lsr@apple.UUCP (Larry Rosenstein) writes:
>This may seem to work, but actually System 3.2/Finder 5.3 is the latest
>version that supports the 64K ROMs (which Magic Sac requires).  The patches
>for ROM bugs are present in System 3.2 but not later versions.

>Larry Rosenstein
>Object Specialist
>Apple Computer

     I personally would like to thank Larry for his constructive comment
concerning the Magic Sac and the proper System/Finder to run.  I am sure
that Larry spoke as a member of the net and not as an Apple representative,
but I think that this is the proper order of things.  As I see it, the net
is for an interchange of information, and since an Apple employee probably
knows a great deal about the workings of a Mac, it is appropriate for such a
person to comment.  The Magic Sac can in no way be considered competition to
a Mac, so such comments cause no harm to Apple and can help a number of
normal users.  Besides, if we can stick to comments like Larry's, we
shouldn't have as much of the computer bashing that has so recently
re-erupted.

     Again Larry, thank you.

                                            Adam Engst

engst@tcgould.tn.cornell.edu

rowley@ORVILLE.NAS.NASA.GOV (Karl Rowley) (12/16/87)

I forgot to mention that I was using version 4.52 of the Magic Sac software
when I tested the programs that I listed.
				Karl Rowley
			Usenet: ...{hplabs,ucbvax,lll-crg}!ames!orville!rowley
			Arpanet: rowley@orville.nas.nasa.gov