[comp.sys.atari.st] ** Voting Results: Favorite Games **

totty@flute.cs.uiuc.edu (Brian Totty) (07/23/90)

	Thanks to every one who voted for their favorite games.  There
	were a total of 19 replies to my request for people to vote for their
	favorite Atari ST games.  The mean number of games voted for per voter
	was 5.4.

	The following is the result of the voting where the number on the
	left signifies the number of votes each game received.  The order
	of preference between people's votes (1st choice, second choice, etc.)
	was not taken into account.

	The descriptions shown are fragments of various people's reviews
	mixed and matched together.  I couldn't verify many of the reviews
	because I am not familiar with many of the games.  Some games
	were voted on with no description.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

       A T A R I    S T    G A M E    B A L L O T    R E S U L T S

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

9	Dungeon Master
		This is a very good dungeon-exploration/combat game. 
		Excellent 3-D graphics you can even see the slime on
		the dungeon walls!digitized sound.  Digitized sound,
		sets a new standard in D&D style computer games.
6	Sim City
		Very addictive game.  The player is 'mayor' of a city and uses
		his 'budget' to build public facilities (PD, FD, stadiums) and
		to zone other land for commercial construction (residential,
		commercial, or industrial).  City grows as you go and problems
		of traffic, crime, pollution, etc. arise.  If your suicidal,
		you can play w/ disasters on and face earthquakes, fires,
		floods, monsters, etc......
5	Chaos Strikes Back
		Sequel to Dungeon Master, even better.
5	Populous
		Play God and wipe out other God's population
		Great game for 2 people by Modem.
5	Stunt Car Racer
		You've seen flight simulators? Well, this is a Driving
		(Racing) simulation, where you are racing on a track that
		resembles a rollercoaster, in that it is a raised track (and
		ya can fall off!).  You are in the car looking out the front
		windshield, as you attack the 3D track.  The graphics resemble
		Starglider II quality, in that they are solid filled, and
		update at a reasonable rate.  You can race against the
		computer, on various complex stunt tracks, but the REAL FUN
		begins when you connect two ST's running the same program
		(only need one copy to boot both), and each opponent on their
		respective computer tries to beat/outwit the other driver.  We
		play nasty, and someone usually ends up knocking the other
		player off the track purposely :) ... but don't worry, seconds
		later you are back on the track, and if you can catch 'em you
		can take REVENGE!

3	Elite
		The old space-trading classic, tho' I started to find it
		getting rather "samey" as time went on.
4	Falcon
		I'm sure you've heard lot's about this already...THE F-16
		flight simulator.  Choose mission and skill level.  Higher
		levels are more realistic but difficult to survive in.
		Dogfight with computer MiGs and evade surface to air
		missiles.  Truly a blast flying head to head at 19.2
		baud (get your friend to bring his ST over...it's worth it).
		Also recommend the optional mission disk.  
3	Starglider II
		A space flight sim of large scale.  Involes flying around and
		between planets performing missions and encountering over 130
		different objects.  You have to destroy an enemy battle
		station with a special bomb.  To get the bomb, you must get
		various things from around the solar system.
3	Xenon II
		I only have one game, which I bought after a long time of
		evaluation.  The Game is XENON II, and I love it (did - I have
		blasted through all levels).  It have very good graphics
		(antialised and everything), very smooth 2 plane scroll, and
		lotsa action!
2	Battle Hawks
		Lucasfilm Games - WWII pacific theatre.  Player can fly
		various carrier based aircraft in 32 different missions (16
		amer, 16 Jap).  Medium simulator, great game.
2	Empire
		You may have seen this game on other machines but I beleive
		the Atari port is the best I've seen. It's a conquer the world
		game allowing up to 3 players. You and others (human or
		computer) can have advantages/handicaps. You start with a
		predefined world (many to choose from...you don't know what it
		looks like until you explore...ditto for your opponents). You
		must develop you're cities (you start with 1) and battleforces
		with the hopes of discovering and conquering. You have land,
		air and sea forces available (armies, planes, troop
		transports, aircraft carriers, destroyers, submarines,
		cruisers, battleships) all with different capabilities. Very
		good mouse implementation. Be prepared to spend hours and
		hours with this game.

			... but someone else said ...

		Attempt to crush enemy using armies, navies, and planes.  I've
		seen a better version on the Mac and can envision a MUCH
		better implemenation.
2	Flight Simulator II
		I go back to it again and again.  A learning experience.  The
		best flight sim. ever.  Wonderfully expanded by the scenery
		disks.
2	Gauntlet II
		Dungeon exploration with an overhead view.  A faithful copy of
		the awesome arcade game.  With optional adapter, supports four
		people.
2	Indiana Jones Last Crusade Adventure
		Mouse controlled adventure game that follows the movie.
2	Millenium
		Earth has been hit by a large asteroid, and almost all life
		wiped out.  You have to start from a base on the moon, and
		colonise the solar system.
2	Oids
		Combination Chopper-Lifter & Lunar Lander
2	Pirates
		You are a pirate captain in the 16th or 17th century, raiding
		ships and towns on the Spanish Main.  Realistic pirate
		simulation with many different scenarios.
2	Rick Dangerous
		Platform style game set inside a cave.
2	Silent Service
		WWII submarine. Main factors of submarine warfare.
2	Super Breakout
		PD game from Germany or Holland.  Monochrome version of the
		popular breakout games.  Includes every option I've seen in
		ANY breakout game and over 100 screens.
1	Arkanoid
		Breakout type game with power ups.
1	Breach II
		Very well-done wargame-type game.  You control a squad
		of men.  Infiltrate enemy territory, rescue prisoners,
		acquire enemy data, crack enemy computers.  Includes
		a scenario-builder program to "roll-your-own".
1	Carrier Command
		You command a futuristic aircraft carrier, plus its complement
		of aircraft and amphibious tanks.  So does the computer.  You
		fight for control over a cluster of islands.
1	Chessmaster 2000
1	Chronoquest
		An icon-driven adventure game involving a bit of time travel.
		Pretty graphics, nice music, some difficult puzzles.
1	Damocles
		Took a long time, but worth the wait.  Brilliant exploration
		and clue solving action.
1	Drachen
		Remove a stack of Majong pieces as quick as possible.
1	Fighter Bomber
		Excellent simulator (dubiously realistic but when it's this
		much fun - who cares?).  Better than F29 or Falcon.
1	Full Metal Planet
		An EMPIRE type game, idea is to get as much ore as
		possible...leave the planet with more ore then the other
		player.  Involves combat with the other player's units.  NICE
		graphics. Based on a board game, I believe.  I think this game
		supports STe graphics.
1	Future Wars
1	Gravity
		fascinating strategy/action game, complex, great graphics.
1	Great Giana Sisters
		Excellent Super Mario Brothers clone.
1	Gunship
		I think this is pretty close to tied with Falcon. This is the
		AH-64A Apache helicopter flight simulator and has numerous
		reality levels, missions and terrain.
1	Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy
		Infocom textual adventure game based roughly on the book/
		radio show/television series.  Characters and general
		circumstances are the same but story line differs so people
		familiar with the story will still enjoy the game.  Very
		funny.  Douglas Adams worked on teh game development.
1	In Harm's Way
		WWII. No graphics. Lets you give commands for a naval battle.
		Simple but fairly good. (expensive).
1	International Karate
		A karate game with great graphics and a real nice user
		interface.  It's easy to use and fun.  Can play solo or with
		another player.  You fight against two others, at least one of
		which is computer played.
1	Interphase
		This is kinda a takeoff from the book Neuromancer in which you
		have a partner in the real world trying to get to the top of
		this building (7 levels). You use the Interphase to
		communicate with her. This is a type of virtual reality that
		you 'fly' through and security items are represented by
		various 3D objects that you must manipulate/destroy. Currently
		number 1 as I just got it and I'm having a lot of fun with
		it...up to level 5 (been a few weeks of irregular play). Combo
		shoot 'em up, fly around and strategy/adventure game.

1	Kick Off
		The best football/soccer sim. available. Small sprites but
		fast hectic action.  Soon to be improved in Kick Off II (if
		possible!).
1	Larn
		Public domain. Kill the monster's and find the treasure. Hack
		and Rogue are similar.
1	Man Hunter
1	Mid Winter
		Strategy game after nuclear winter.  Character's personalities
		interact.
1	Mines
		Cross a mine field successfully.
1	Monopoly
		I dunno-- just something about this game that is very
		addicting...
1	Net Hack
1	Omega
		This was my current favorite...Hard to call this a game unless
		you think programming is fun. You have to design/write the
		intelligence for a tank. You start with fairly basic
		'hardware' components and if you tank does well enough in the
		simulations you get more credits and can get better
		'hardware'. You can also design battlefields and simulations
		and it comes with a 'debugger'. This game is also availble for
		the IBM and Amiga so you can pit your tanks against your
		friends (the tank design files are compatible between
		machines...). The progamming language is a bit lame and has at
		least 2 bugs but still a blast.
1	Shuffle Puck Cafe
		A very realistic shuffle board/air hockey type game with
		excellent mouse control...quick and easy to learn/play.
1	Stellar Crusade
		Wargame between computer and player, or two players.  The
		opponents fight for control over a cluster of stars, and must
		colonise the star systems as well as fight for them.
1	Sundog
		An early Atari favorite.  An animated trading simulation
		where you try to "buy low" go elsewhere and "sell high".
		Watch out for pirates and keep your ship in good repair.
1	Tetris
		The Soviet game of dropping shapes.
1	The Pawn
		A rather nice text adventure game with accompanying artwork
		that I actually managed to solve!
1	The Sentinal
		An aging game of strategy unlike anything else, involving
		moving around fractal landscapes manipulating energy.  Very
		ethereal.
2	Time Bandit
		Arcade type game with an underlying adventure game
		scenario.  There are numerous thematic 'time zones' which
		scrolling rooms and monsters all in beautiful color.  You
		shoot the monsters while trying to get treasure (for extra
		lives) and the keys to get out.  As you do this you will
		learn about the underlying story of the time zone you are in
		and will try to solve the adventure.  Split screen allows
		two players to cooperate at the same time.  Fast, colorful
		graphics.
1	Umoria
		Your normal everyday Rogue-type game.
1	Warhead
		A stunningly atmospheric space combat game.  Has real class.
1	Warship
		World War II Navel simulation. Fairly realistic, but several
		bugs (none of which make it crash). Let's you figure out how
		to fight naval battles.
1	XyBots
		This is a good game to play with one other person.  In two
		player mode, it is on a split screen.  It has simple but good
		3D graphics (Maybe simulated 3D is a better word?).  You walk
		through this space station blasting robots and try to kill the
		Master Robot at the end.  Nice shoot-em-up.  Based on an
		Arcade game.



   /                      Brian Totty              o o
  /__  __  o        406 E. Michigan / Apt. 6        o  
 /  / /   /             Urbana, IL 61801           \_/  "We have corn in
/__/ /   /             totty@cs.uiuc.edu                Massachusetts too!"

totty@flute.cs.uiuc.edu (Brian Totty) (07/23/90)

	Two mistakes were in my previous posting, because I added a final vote and
	forgot to resort the list of games:

	(1) Falcon received an additional vote and so should have been placed
	    before Elite:

> 4	Falcon
> 		I'm sure you've heard lot's about this already...THE F-16
> 		flight simulator.  Choose mission and skill level.  Higher
> 		levels are more realistic but difficult to survive in.
> 		Dogfight with computer MiGs and evade surface to air
> 		missiles.  Truly a blast flying head to head at 19.2
> 		baud (get your friend to bring his ST over...it's worth it).
> 		Also recommend the optional mission disk.  
> 3	Elite
> 		The old space-trading classic, tho' I started to find it
> 		getting rather "samey" as time went on.

	(2) Time Bandit received an additional vote which should have placed it
	    before Arkanoid:

> 2	Time Bandit
> 		Arcade type game with an underlying adventure game
> 		scenario.  There are numerous thematic 'time zones' which
> 		scrolling rooms and monsters all in beautiful color.  You
> 		shoot the monsters while trying to get treasure (for extra
> 		lives) and the keys to get out.  As you do this you will
> 		learn about the underlying story of the time zone you are in
> 		and will try to solve the adventure.  Split screen allows
> 		two players to cooperate at the same time.  Fast, colorful
> 		graphics.
> 1	Arkanoid
> 		Breakout type game with power ups.


   /                      Brian Totty              o o
  /__  __  o        406 E. Michigan / Apt. 6        o  
 /  / /   /             Urbana, IL 61801           \_/  "We have corn in
/__/ /   /             totty@cs.uiuc.edu                Massachusetts too!"