[comp.sys.atari.st] reviews and favorites

dkoski@hercules.as.arizona.edu (David Koski) (12/13/90)

As to the favorites list, what about an avoid list?  Is anyone interested in
writing reviews of games, utilities, compilers, editors, etc?  All the stuff
on atari.archive should be reviewed...  Anyway I am willing to review the
programs that I own.  If anyone is interested, where should these go?  On
c.s.a.st?  on atari.archive?  Would anyone else be willing to contribute?


David Koski

pegram@kira.UUCP (Robert B. Pegram) (12/14/90)

From article <698@organpipe.UUCP>, by dkoski@hercules.as.arizona.edu (David Koski):
> As to the favorites list, what about an avoid list?  Is anyone interested in
> writing reviews of games, utilities, compilers, editors, etc?  All the stuff
> on atari.archive should be reviewed...  Anyway I am willing to review the
> programs that I own.  If anyone is interested, where should these go?  On
> c.s.a.st?  on atari.archive?  Would anyone else be willing to contribute?
> 
> 
> David Koski

on atari.archive certainly, if they can be made easy to find.

on c.s.a.st IFF the header contains a keyword (REVIEW ??)so the review can be
avoided by those not interested.

_Note_versions_prominently_ - perhaps have separate reviews of  major upgrades
or less buggy predecessors.

why limit ourselves to atari.archive stuff?  I would like to see
reviews (and feedback) about most ST programs

Just my $ 0.02, and I would be willing to contribute a review once in while.

Bob Pegram

pegram@griffin.uvm.edu

Yonderboy@cup.portal.com (Christopher Lee Russell) (12/14/90)

I am a new St user and would love to see some reviews of software.. And
favorite lists.... I have been spening most of the time since I have gotten
my Atari wading through all of the files available trying to figure out what
is good and bad...

                  ......Yonderboy@cup.portal.com

BTW: Thanks to everyone who has answered my previous questions concerning C
     and DbMan,etc.......

dkoski@hercules.as.arizona.edu (David Koski) (12/18/90)

Well, several people have expressed interest in this project...  If people
mail me reviews, I could combine (and organize) them and post on atari.archive
and c.s.a.st.

Disk space is no problem (well, many many megs would be bad, but ... :), so
send all you have.

dkoski@hercules.as.arizona.edu

David Koski