[comp.sys.ibm.pc] OMTI/SMS Controller

parker@epiwrl.EPI.COM (Alan Parker) (10/07/87)

I have a 20Meg ST-225 with an OMTI-5510 controller.  The controller has
died.  Can anyone tell me what controller I can replace the OMTI-5510
with that will be compatible with the format on the disk (so I can use
the bits that are there the way they are!).   I've been told everything
from "no two controllers are the same" to "all controllers made in the
last few years are the same".  I assume the truth is somewhere in
between.

In looking through the ads, I haven't seen the OMTI-5510 listed (I'm
not surprised as mine is >2 years old).  California Digital lists an
OMTI-5520.  Does anyone know if this is the same as the 5510 (as far as
format is concerned?).

Of course, if anyone has a 5510 they would like to sell me, that would
be good also.

Thanks.

Alan Parker,			Internet: parker@wrl.epi.com
Entropic Speech, Inc.		Uucp:     uunet!epiwrl!parker
Washington, DC
(202) 547-1420

bill@hpcvlo.HP.COM (Bill Frolik) (10/09/87)

My SMS reference manual lists quite a few differences between the OMTI 5510
and the OMTI 5520.  Some of the biggies:

	- The 5520 card is shorter (4.95") than the 5510 (5.5").

	- The 5520 has an onboard drive power connecter (not found on 5510).

	- The 5520 fixes the number of bytes per sector at 512, with
	  17 sectors per track (for MFM drives).  Your 5510 has jumpers
	  (W9 and W10) that let you select from 512/18, 256/32, 512/17,
	  and 1024/9 bytes-per-sector/sectors-per-track.  Your 5510 also
	  lets you individually specify LUN 0 and LUN 1 as hard- or 
	  soft-sectored, and lets you specify the drive as fixed or
	  removable (which changes a number of other parameters as well.)

Card I/O base address and BIOS base address configuration are the same;
Buffer size, ECC length, and data transfer rates are also the same.
Controller command set is the same, and I would imagine BIOS command set
is also the same.

If I were you, I'd ask the folks at SMS (415-964-5700) if you can make
the replacement.  Looks like enough things are different that I'd be
skeptical about just dropping in a 5520 and expecting everything to work.

Bill Frolik
hp-pcd!bill
Hewlett-Packard Portable Computer Division
Corvallis, Oregon 97330